Skip to content

Top 111 Free Agents: Nos. 10-1

Sep 25, 2009, 6:14 PM EDT

This concludes a series of columns looking at this winter’s free agent class. I’m listing each player along with his age, as of next April 1, and his place in the previous edition of these rankings from May.
Nos. 111-91
Nos. 90-71
Nos. 70-51
Nos. 50-36
Nos. 35-21
Nos. 20-11
10. Ben Sheets (31) – Prev. NR – Because he had yet to sign, Sheets was ineligible for the May edition of the rankings. Now he comes in at No. 10, even though he’s missed the entire year. The original hope was that he’d return from surgery to repair a torn flexor tendon in August, but it was always something of a long shot. Unless there have been setbacks we just don’t know about, it should be assumed that he’ll be at full strength next spring. Sheets has lost his best stuff and it’s probably never coming back, but he was good enough to post a 3.09 ERA in 198 1/3 innings last year. Since he’s not coming off one of the big three surgeries (Tommy John, labrum or rotator cuff), he should find some multiyear offers on the table. However, he may prefer to take a one-year pact in the hopes of landing something like $75 million for five years next winter.
9. Jose Valverde (32) – Prev. #7 – Valverde added an extra birthday recently, sort of. He had been listed recently as having been born in 1979, but the correct 1978 date was also out there and that’s the one that was used here in the original rankings back in May. Valverde has dealt with injury issues this year, but he’s avoided arm problems and posted a 2.12 ERA in 51 innings. He’s the only available closer worthy of a four-year deal, and he’ll probably receive around $10 million per season.
8. Aroldis Chapman (22) – Prev. NR – Chapman, who defected from Cuba in July, is expected to be granted free agency within the near future and he should prove extremely popular, given that he’s one of the five hardest throwing lefties in the world. Reports have had him clocked as high as 102 mph, and he didn’t seem to have much trouble throwing 98 mph in the World Baseball Classic. As a pitcher, he still has a long way to go, and anyone who signs him expecting him to be a quality starter in 2010 will probably be disappointed. He’d be more likely to help as a reliever initially. Because his ceiling is so high and the team that signs him will have him for at least six years — seven if he opens 2010 in the minors — he’s going to be a very rich man. I’m guessing he’ll get around $50 million.
7. Adrian Beltre (30) – Prev. #6 – Beltre’s Mariners tenure will be labeled a disappointment, but thanks in part to his terrific defense at third, he justified his $13 million salary each of the last three seasons before his injury marred 2009. He didn’t recover as hoped from offseason shoulder surgery, struggled throughout the first half and then underwent another surgery in June. Upon returning in August, he hit .390 in nine games and then went down with a bruised testicle. Now he’s back struggling again this month. Beltre is still pretty young, and he’s been very durable aside from this year. He’ll probably receive a smaller deal this time around and prove to be a pretty good value for whatever team that lands him.
6. Tim Hudson* (33) – Prev. #8 – What was in doubt at the beginning of the year seems settled now: Hudson’s $12 million option will need to be exercised mutually by both the team and the player. Any doubt that the Braves would pick up their end should have been erased by the quick and impressive return Hudson has made from Tommy John surgery. Hudson, though, will be able to do better elsewhere. For 2010 alone, there’s a good argument to made for a fully recharged Hudson over any other available free agent starter, particularly if John Lackey ends up working deep into the postseason.
5. Chone Figgins (32) – Prev. #17 – Figgins picked a great time to have his most valuable season to date. He was a better hitter in 2007, when he finished at .330/.393/.432, but he played in just 115 games then. After following that up with a 685 OPS in a 116-game season in 2008, his stock hit a new low. However, he’s bounced back to bat .301/.399/.401 this year and he hasn’t missed any time at all. Odds are that he’ll be viewed primarily as a third baseman this winter, but the Yankees and Cubs are possibilities to consider him as an option in center field, at least for a year or two. Those additional suitors should help him get a deal worth in excess of $50 million for four years.
4. Manny Ramirez* (37) – Prev. #5 – After another scorching start, Ramirez seemed to be in line to decline his $20 million player option for 2010. However, the steroid suspension, at least as much as his subsequent decline, changed everything. He’s remained one of the NL’s better hitters since returning from the 50-game ban, but his .279/.393/.517 line in 70 games since returning pales in comparison to the nearly 1200 OPS he posted in his first 80 games with the Dodgers. Barring an outstanding postseason, it’s doubtful that Ramirez would do better than $20 million out on the open market.
3. John Lackey (31) – Prev. #4 – Lackey has missed the first six weeks of each of the last two seasons due to elbow problems, but he keeps on bouncing back strong. This will be his fifth straight year with an ERA under 3.80 and perhaps the third in which he’s had at least three times as many strikeouts as walks (he’s at 135/46 right now). Whether he’ll reemerge as a 200-inning guy is the question. It’s a good sign that he’s never had any in-season recurrence of problems once he’s returned from the DL, not to mention a testament to the way the Angels have taken care of him. There’s a good chance Lackey will stay put. The Angels will have plenty of cash available with Figgins, Vladimir Guerrero and Bobby Abreu all potentially coming off the books, and keeping Lackey should be the top priority.
2. Jason Bay (31) – Prev. #3 – The middle two months were nothing to brag about, but Bay has come back with 16 homers and 41 RBI since the beginning of August. He’s now established new career highs in both categories, and his 930 OPS would rank as the second-highest mark in his six full seasons. Bay is 16 months older than Matt Holliday and a weaker defender, so the difference in contracts should be significant. Nevertheless, he’s clearly the No. 2 free agent available and he could potentially receive $75 million-$80 million over five years this winter. The Red Sox tried to sign him during the first half and couldn’t come to terms, so odds are that they will take a long look at Holliday this winter. Bay and the Red Sox seem like a good fit, though, so something should be worked out.
1. Matt Holliday (30) – Prev. #1 – Holliday would have ranked as the No. 1 free agent even had he finished the season with the .286/.378/.454 line he posted with the A’s before being traded back to the NL. Still, that he has come in at .356/.414/.630 with the Cardinals certainly won’t hurt him in contract talks. Holliday did seem to be figuring out AL pitchers towards the end of his stay in Oakland, so he shouldn’t be afraid to go back if the money is right. All things being equal, though, he’d probably prefer to stay in the NL. It’s going to be extremely difficult for the Cardinals to come up with the cash when they still have Albert Pujols to worry about. He’s likely due about $100 million for six years.

  1. GrimReaperxxx - Oct 26, 2009 at 9:23 AM

    OK Mr G.M., Lets play which one would you do?
    Manny or Lacky?
    Likely to draw roughly equivalent $.
    With Lacky you get a tough competitor, With Manny you are trading on the Roid inflated 2008 end of season run. Is it really that easy?
    No. No one doubts Manny can hit and he does have a real work ethic. His post season records are #1. But has his ability declined due to lack of Roids, like a Sammy Sosa. And do you care that he is basically a cancer on your team? Or do you chew on another Rolaids when you write the big check, and hope he put butts in the seats like he did with Mannywood, the down the left field line seats that the Dodgers normally cant sell, now populated by a bunch of no necks, sporting Manny wigs, and shrieking Manny, Manny, Manny like a bunch of 13 yr old girls at a boy band concert.
    Or do you write the big check for the ulimate competitor, Lacky? The same pitcher that has had pre and early season arm and shoulder problems, that may be indicative of a serious injury to come. Pitching is a tough skill, and big bucks spent here mean a big risk. For every Greg Maddux there is a Mike Hampton. So do you chew another Rolaids, before you write the big check?
    Come on, your future depends on a roid declining wacko, or a frayed Ulnar? And do you really think that rookie in triple A will really come to save your job, like some sort of long haired girl boo hooing in your tower in the middle of the woods. Or do you start chanting Nomar Nomar NoMarrr!!!, and do a Colletti and sign all the free agents nobody wants and hope that one of them is not ready for the glue factory.

  2. XTrust_No1X - Nov 11, 2009 at 9:27 PM

    With Matt Holiday most likely coming to the 27 Time World Series Champions, The Legendary New York Yankees to take over the Left Field position now vacaded since Johnny Damon’s agent, Scott “The Parasite” Borus insists that Damon requires a four year contract, which in NO Way, will the Yankees give Damon(36). If Matt Holiday signs else where(he’s already stated he wants to come to the World Champions), the Yankees will then sign Clone Figgins, giving the Yankees with a player that can take over third to give A-Rod a rest once in a while, along with starting as the Yankees left fielder. Secondly, it will have to be seen if John Lackey has the stones to also come to pitch for the World Series Champion New York Yankees, who will defintely be trying to sign John Lackey after Non Tendering Chein Ming Wang this off-season. Then, the final peice of the New York Yankees rotation won’t be traded for this year, but signed after next season when he becomes a free agent, in Doc Holiday. Then, the New York Yankees starting rotation will include most likely the 2009 CY Young winner in CC Sabathia, Doc Holiday, AJ Burnett, John Lackey(only a possibility), Andy Pettitte, Chad Gaudin or Joba Chamberlain(He belongs in the pen in my humble opinion). And, if John Lackey doesn’t have the nads (Ed Whitson syndrome as I call it) to play for the Yankees, then they will probably sign either Ben Sheets or Tim Hudson. Next step, resigning Matsui as the DH is a possibility, but, I personally believe the Yankees won’t resign Matsui and leave the DH role open so they can rest they’re aging stars in Jorge Posada and Derek Jeter, and get younger. But, this really isn’t a major issue for the Yankees though, cause after signing these players to replace the ones that left, the World Champion New York Yankees will have plenty to repeat as Champions and really get the gears turning in the next New York Yankees dynasty!!! Pride, Tradition Greatness, that’s the Legendary New York Yankees.

  3. mike - Nov 12, 2009 at 3:48 PM

    yeah well even the evil empire cant pull off all of those deals. you and your comment perfectly represent the spoiled yankee fan and his mindset.

  4. testicular cancer symtoms - Jan 12, 2010 at 8:22 PM

    Really appreciate the great post. I am going to bookmark your site and tell my followers about it when I post on my blog again. Feel free to read some of my material and let me know what you think. I have been working really hard on making valuable content ( similar to yours ) and I could user some tips. Please let me know where you think I can improve. Hopefully my content has decent readability like yours although sometimes it is difficult to do when you have to discuss technical things. Some people either get it or they dont.

  5. herb tea - Feb 9, 2010 at 2:30 PM

    I still can not believe how many different women came forward in order to declare a relationship with Tiger Woods. However I personally don’t think his personal life needed to have influenced his golfing profession.

Leave Comment

You must be logged in to leave a comment. Not a member? Register now!

Top 10 MLB Player Searches
  1. G. Stanton (2541)
  2. C. Correa (2524)
  3. Y. Puig (2524)
  4. B. Crawford (2409)
  5. H. Pence (2292)
  1. G. Springer (2236)
  2. H. Ramirez (2177)
  3. M. Teixeira (2158)
  4. J. Hamilton (2141)
  5. J. Baez (2107)