Skip to content

Baseball's most underrated player: Chase Utley

Oct 29, 2009, 1:10 PM EDT

Perhaps a pair of homers off CC Sabathia last night will end Chase Utley’s reign as the most underrated player in baseball, although even his big night was overshadowed by Cliff Lee’s complete-game victory.
Despite playing for a highly successful big-market team Utley’s excellence has somehow managed to fly under the radar, as many media members and fans seem to think of him as merely a very good player rather than a truly great one.
However, his combination of big batting averages (.295 career), excellent power (30 homers and 40 doubles per 600 at-bats), strong plate discipline (.379 on-base percentage), efficient baserunning (23-for-23 on steals this year), and outstanding defense at an up-the-middle position is extremely difficult to find and makes him one of MLB’s elite all-around players.
Runs Above Replacement (RAR) is a stat that combines offensive and defensive contributions to calculate the total number of runs someone was worth compared to a replacement-level player at the same position. This season Utley ranked second in the NL with 76.7 runs above replacement, trailing only Albert Pujols and his 84.3 RAR. And it’s been a similar story in past seasons:

2009              RAR     2008              RAR     2007              RAR
Albert Pujols    84.3     Albert Pujols    89.2     David Wright     86.6
CHASE UTLEY      76.7     CHASE UTLEY      81.0     CHASE UTLEY      82.2
Hanley Ramirez   73.2     Chipper Jones    76.7     Matt Holliday    80.5
Ryan Zimmerman   70.7     Hanley Ramirez   75.7     Albert Pujols    78.5
Prince Fielder   67.1     David Wright     74.3     Chipper Jones    71.9
2006              RAR     2005              RAR
Albert Pujols    79.5     Andruw Jones     87.0
Ryan Howard      72.4     Albert Pujols    77.3
Carlos Beltran   72.2     Derrek Lee       74.1
CHASE UTLEY      70.8     CHASE UTLEY      73.8
Miguel Cabrera   69.8     Jason Bay        63.6



In his five full seasons Utley has ranked second, second, second, fourth, and fourth among all NL position players in RAR, yet he’s never finished higher than seventh in the MVP balloting while two of his Phillies teammates have won MVPs. Pujols and Utley are the only players to rank among the NL’s top five in all five of those seasons, and if you value things like on-base percentages, positional adjustments, and defense there’s a clear case for Utley being the second-best player in the league during that time.
In fact, during that time there’s a pretty good argument for Utley being the second-best player in baseball, regardless of league. Runs Created is a relatively widely used stat that measures, quite simply, how many runs a player produced offensively. For some context, this season the NL leader was Pujols with 165 and the AL leader was Joe Mauer with 138. Not coincidentally, they figure to be the MVPs when the awards are announced next month. Here are the Runs Created leaders from 2005-2009:

Albert Pujols     764
Alex Rodriguez    661
Mark Teixeira     645
CHASE UTLEY       641
Miguel Cabrera    641
David Ortiz       622
Matt Holliday     617
David Wright      613
Ryan Howard       598
Lance Berkman     594



Pujols obviously stands head and shoulders above the pack, but Utley is within spitting distance of the No. 2 spot and you’ll notice that he’s the only guy in the top 10 who plays an up-the-middle position defensively. Getting that kind of offensive production from a Gold Glove-caliber second baseman is extremely rare and hugely valuable, which is why even after last night’s heroics Utley is probably still the most underrated player in baseball.

  1. scatterbrian - Oct 30, 2009 at 7:10 PM

    Thanks Mike, I was about to say the same. The entire underrated argument hinges on this: “he’s never finished higher than seventh in the MVP balloting while two of his Phillies teammates have won MVPs.” Of course most of us rabid fans who waste time commenting on baseball stories know he’s great, but the MSM doesn’t seem to get it, and that was the whole point.
    What I find interesting, if only coincidental, is that the last guy who was truly considered underrated was Bobby Abreu when he was a Philly.

  2. Alex - Nov 1, 2009 at 12:04 AM

    Ok, Yankee fan, Red Sox fan, Phillies fan or even Nationals fan, everyone needs to understand something. There are things called adjectives and adverbs, each of which describes something. An adjective describes a noun which is a person, place or thing. An example of an adjective would be “CC Sabathia is FAT and STRONG.” An adverb describes a verb, which is an action word. An example of an adverb would be “Cliff Lee threw the ball WELL.” If you’re going to flame on someone for being an idiot about their opinions (and by all means go ahead) then at least do it with correct English. It is grammatically impossible for someone to throw GOOD. That’s wrong. Flat out wrong. If you passed 4th grade you’d know that’s wrong. Either speak correctly or STFU.

  3. Mark - Nov 1, 2009 at 2:25 PM

    I totally disagree Utley is no way the most underrated player. NOt by a longshot. He is probably the best second baseman in baseball and everyone pretty much thinks that.

  4. anonymous - Jan 3, 2010 at 4:30 AM

    he is the best second basemen in baseball without a doubt, with brandon phillips following close behind. i have to say both are pretty underrated. utley stands in ths shadows of ryan howard & j-roll & phillips is underrated because he plays in cincinnati, with dustin pedroia & robinson cano getting all the attention. but utley & phillips i’d be happy to have either one of them on my team. and they’re great fantasy players too

  5. Rickie Tuer - Feb 6, 2010 at 4:41 AM

    To commercialize in conditions of quality rather than monetary value, and in order to specialize consequently, you require to adopt the criterial format of the 4 Ps marketing plan. That is, Price, Product, Place and Promotion obviously you recognise the strategic properties of the product, and the cost, but for place you should consider about the type of individuals who are willing to pay over 4x price of competing merchandise whereas the cheap option may be sold where emphasis is on cost, your product will be suited to places/distributors where the customers will be willing to pay for high-performance. Thank you for this article! I’ve just received a surely awesome archive about how to get rich Attempt it!

  6. one tree hill free online - Feb 6, 2010 at 3:10 PM

    Lovely! I always like your posts and this one is simply fantastic! You have done a fantastic effort and I wish your blog will reach the topmost rankings soon! We are always with you mate!

  7. Estell Mcclory - Feb 13, 2010 at 6:08 PM

    I saw this really good post today, found it on google. i think i may return soon.

  8. watch tv and movies - Mar 8, 2010 at 8:30 PM

    Thanks from sweden for this post

Leave Comment

You must be logged in to leave a comment. Not a member? Register now!

Featured video

A managerial overanalysis epidemic
Top 10 MLB Player Searches
  1. T. Lincecum (2724)
  2. M. Bumgarner (2702)
  3. J. Shields (2414)
  4. M. Morse (2262)
  5. Y. Cespedes (2014)
  1. T. Ishikawa (1672)
  2. B. Roberts (1476)
  3. U. Jimenez (1467)
  4. L. Cain (1422)
  5. H. Pence (1408)