Skip to content

Now that the BBWAA is enlightened, can we get a re-do on 2005?

Nov 20, 2009, 1:55 PM EST

Since a big portion of the Baseball Writers Association of America seems to be beyond their past over-reliance on win-loss records to evaluate starting pitchers, can we have a good old-fashioned mulligan on the AL Cy Young vote from 2005?
Bartolo Colon, who won the award that year, had a 3.48 ERA, 157/43 K/BB ratio, and .244 opponents’ batting average in 223 innings.
Johan Santana, who did not win the award that year, had a 2.87 ERA, 238/45 K/BB ratio, and .210 opponents’ batting average in 232 innings.
Santana was clearly superior in just about every possible way, throwing more innings than Colon with an ERA that was 20 percent lower, racking up 50 percent more strikeouts with the same number of walks, and being 15 percent harder to hit. So how did Colon not only win the award, but win the award with 15 more first-place votes than Santana in a pool of 28 voters?
Colon was 21-8.
Santana was 16-7.
They may not care so much about that now, but the BBWAA were sure obsessed with win-loss records four years ago. The voters saw those 21 wins and ignored everything else, including the fact that Colon pitched for a 95-win team that provided him with 5.6 runs of support per nine innings. Santana pitched for an 83-win team that gave him 4.4 runs of support per nine innings. Colon received 30 percent more run support than Santana overall, including an amazing 10 or more runs eight times in 33 starts.
So yes, the BBWAA deserves credit for recently changing their stance and correctly rewarding the best pitcher in each league with the Cy Young award that’s supposed to go to the best pitcher in each league even when they didn’t have the best win-loss record. With that said, Zack Greinke and Tim Lincecum are lucky that they weren’t trying to win the award in 2005 and it remains to be seen if the voters would have been willing to look beyond an otherwise inferior 20-game winner like Colon had there been one this year.

  1. Steve F - Nov 20, 2009 at 1:57 PM

    If we want a more enlightened BBWAA to go back and fix awards, they should hand Justin Morneau’s 2006 MVP to Derek Jeter.

  2. SBG - Nov 20, 2009 at 2:02 PM

    They got the team right, just wrong player. Joe Mauer should be picking up his 3rd MVP on Monday. (2006, 08, 09)

  3. David - Nov 20, 2009 at 2:02 PM

    Hah. Actually, they should hand it to Joe Mauer.

  4. Brian - Nov 20, 2009 at 2:55 PM

    The crazy thing about that year, too, was that the Twins’ record in Santana’s starts was 24-9 (7-2 in Santana’s no-decisions, of which Santana was a big part (one example http://sports.yahoo.com/mlb/boxscore;_ylt=Ali0B.nNLTSJilfZBT3neH6FCLcF?gid=250903109), while the Angels were 22-11 in Colon’s starts (1-3 in his no-decisions).

  5. Leo - Nov 20, 2009 at 2:56 PM

    Heck, they should hand the Cy Young to St. Derek, too.

  6. brian - Nov 20, 2009 at 2:56 PM

    let me try that again. http://sports.yahoo.com/mlb/boxscore;_ylt=Ali0B.nNLTSJilfZBT3neH6FCLcF?gid=250903109

  7. EvilEmpireE - Nov 20, 2009 at 3:37 PM

    HE IS A YANKEE THAT WON’T HAPPEN, BUT I AGREE WITH YOU.
    THE AWESOME THING IS DEREK DOESN’T CARE ABOUT IT, I BET
    THE GOLD GLOVE AND SILVER SLUGGER THIS YEAR MEAN MORE
    BECAUSE HE ALSO HAS THE WORLD SERIES TROPHY, WHICH HE WOULD
    SAY IS MORE IMPORTANT.THE YANKEES HAVE THE MOST IMPORTANT
    AWARD, LET THE LOSER PICK UP THEIR INDIVIDUAL AWARD’S.
    THE YANKEES ARE CHAMPIONS OF BASEBALL………AGAIN

  8. EvilEmpireE - Nov 20, 2009 at 3:40 PM

    YOU BETTER HOLD ON TIGHT TO YOU GIRLFRIEND/WIFE, HE WILL END UP WITH HER TOO. WINTER IS COMING, YOU WILL BE COLD AND ALONE.

  9. STEVENELL - Nov 21, 2009 at 3:07 AM

    YOUR REAL GOOD AT TALKIN LOUD ON TEH INTERNETS.

  10. billybill - Nov 21, 2009 at 11:49 AM

    I want to know how much the Hank Aaron Award means to Derek.
    Did Joe Mauer have his name removed from the list of candidates or What?

Leave Comment

You must be logged in to leave a comment. Not a member? Register now!

Featured video

Cubs shore up rotation with Jon Lester
Top 10 MLB Player Searches
  1. C. Gonzalez (2219)
  2. J. Grilli (2144)
  3. A. Pierzynski (2095)
  4. D. Young (2013)
  5. D. Ross (1998)
  1. S. Smith (1945)
  2. T. Stauffer (1852)
  3. D. Uggla (1692)
  4. J. Walden (1677)
  5. H. Kuroda (1624)