Skip to content

Report: Tigers wanted Ellsbury, Buchholz for Granderson

Dec 8, 2009, 8:44 PM EDT

The Boston Herald’s Michael Silverman says the Red Sox did discuss Curtis Granderson with the Tigers before the still unfinalized trade with the Yankees took place, but that Detroit requested both Jacoby Ellsbury and Clay Buchholz in return.
If that seems like a substantially higher price than the Yankees paid, well, that’s mostly because it is. Ellsbury doesn’t quite qualify as a star, but he was a better player than Granderson while hitting .301/.355/.415 with 70 steals last season and he’s going to be much cheaper than Granderson going forward. Buchholz probably wouldn’t have been on the table, either, so it’s doubtful any match would have been found even if the Yankees talks had broken down.
If the Red Sox were truly interested in Granderson, it suggests that there’s a real chance that they could sign Mike Cameron, with the idea of playing Ellsbury in left field. Cameron isn’t as dynamic as Granderson, but he’s the more well rounded player and he’d only require a one- or two-year contract. He’s a definite option for Boston if Jason Bay leaves..

  1. Jason @ IIATMS - Dec 8, 2009 at 9:37 PM

    Matt, that’s the initial asking price. They asked for Hughes and AJax from the Yanks initially. And that was for BOTH Grandy and Edwin Jackson.

  2. Arendell - Dec 8, 2009 at 10:35 PM

    Not to worry J-Bay can not go anywere. The other teams do not want that poor a feilder and thrower, at such a high $$ figure. Ya he and Wille Mo Pena can pound the ball. But if ya stink at feilding & hit around the .250 mark. Bye bye, No big money long term contract for you.

  3. Jake - Dec 8, 2009 at 11:32 PM

    Cameron is the more rounded player than Granderson? HUH? He’s a lot older and is a strikeout machine!! And Ellsbury has no power and doesnt get on base nearly enough for a leadoff guy. Amazing

  4. Buck - Dec 9, 2009 at 12:19 AM

    Cameron is more well rounded how? fatter? Yah…otherwise he hits for a lower average, fewer homers, many fewer steals, K’s more, worse defense by a tick, doesn’t hit triples like Granderson does and at 37 could collapse at any time like most CF do at age 35-38, plus he makes DOUBLE what Granderson does…Yah I guess all those zeroes on his check are more well rounded….sportswriters are generally idiots.
    Ellsbury is a one trick pony…it’s a nice trick but no one would trade what the Yankees did for Granderson for Ellsbury…because he’s not worth what Granderson is, and it was just proven in that trade.
    Oh for two on the analysis, just what I would expect from a hack EC sportswriter

  5. Andy L - Dec 9, 2009 at 2:03 AM

    Cameron had 15 more points of OBP last year, and if you look at righty/lefty splits, I think you’ll see what Matt meant by “well-rounded.” Granderson is a good player, but is really, really terrible against lefties. Cameron is a good player who hits both hands well, while not hitting righties as well as Granderson does.
    It’s a fair thing to say. He wasn’t talking about the money they make in terms of trade, only that the Red Sox would be interested because they’d only have to offer him a short-term deal (and he IS old).
    Why are you so angry?

  6. Joey B - Dec 9, 2009 at 8:52 AM

    A fair amount of RS are saying the same thing. Cameron for one year, maybe two, at $8M per, makes more sense than $60M/4 for Bay, especially considering the two picks. I was hoping Seattle would ink Bay, and we’d land the #16, if that’s what they have.
    For all the talk about Granderson, there is virtually no difference between him and Cameron in terms of OPS+. Both nice players, neither is Willie Mays.

  7. Dan - Dec 9, 2009 at 10:13 AM

    On what planet was Ellsbury better than Granderson last season

  8. SHOES INSOLES - Jan 6, 2010 at 12:42 PM

    Hello, cheers for a excellent article, a truly great beginning to the new year, keep up the great work, Cheryl.

  9. Dan Scherer - Feb 13, 2010 at 6:08 PM

    Hey thanks for posting this, found it to be a interesting read after finding it on google searching for similar topics and i shall pass the link on to severa friends.

Leave Comment

You must be logged in to leave a comment. Not a member? Register now!

Featured video

The Jon Lester-Yoenis Cespedes trade is a win-win
Top 10 MLB Player Searches