Skip to content

Free agent predictions review

Dec 10, 2009, 9:09 PM EDT

With everyone headed home from the meetings and a quiet night likely, it seemed like a good time to revisit some of the predictions from my Free Agency Preview columns. Here’s a list of the 18 signed free agents to receive guesses in those columns:
Ramon Hernandez
Guess: Reds – one year, $4 million
Result: Reds – one year, $3 million
Ivan Rodriguez
Guess: Rangers – one year, $1.5 million
Result: Nationals – two years, $6 million
Others will point to Brandon Lyon, but this is the real mindblower of the offseason to date for me. He’s certainly no better of a bet now than he was last winter, when he went unsigned into March and settled for $1.5 million.
Placido Polanco
Guess: Dodgers – two years, $12 million
Result: Phillies – three years, $18 million
Chone Figgins
Guess: Cubs – four years, $48 million
Result: Mariners – four years, $36 million + vesting option
I was guessing new ownership meant new money, but the Cubs aren’t shaping up as real spenders this winter. I’m still surprised no one stepped up and offered Figgins at least $10 million per year.
Pedro Feliz
Guess: Astros – one year, $2.5 million
Result: Astros – one year, $4.5 million
Marco Scutaro
Guess: Red Sox – three years, $18 million
Result: Red Sox – two years, $12.5 million + mutual option
Alex Gonzalez
Guess: Blue Jays – one year, $2.5 million
Result: Blue Jays – one year, $2.5 million
Randy Wolf
Guess: Mariners – three years, $36 million
Result: Brewers – three years, $29.5 million
The market for Wolf clearly wasn’t what I thought it’d be. If he had been offered arbitration by the Dodgers, he’d probably still be on the market looking for a three-year offer. The Brewers were more inclined to give him one because they didn’t have to surrender a draft pick.
Rich Harden
Guess: Orioles – two years, $18 million
Result: Rangers – one year, $7.5 million + mutual option
The fun thing about this prediction is that the Rangers could only sign Harden after dumping Kevin Millwood’s contract on the Orioles.
Andy Pettitte
Guess: Yankees – one year, $10 million plus incentives
Result: Yankees – one year, $11.75 million
Brad Penny
Guess: Brewers – two years, $16 million
Result: Cardinals – one year, $7.5 million
Carl Pavano
Guess: Diamondbacks – one year, $7 million
Result: Accepted arbitration
Rafael Soriano
Guess: Rays – two years, $14 million
Result: Accepted arbitration
Definitely the better result for the Rays. They’ll have Soriano at around $7 million for one year, and they were able to hold on to their first-round pick.
Billy Wagner
Guess: Orioles – one year, $7.5 million
Result: Braves – one year, $7.5 million + vesting option
LaTroy Hawkins
Guess: Astros – two years, $9 million
Result: Brewers – two years, $7.5 million
Brandon Lyon
Guess: Phillies – two years, $8 million
Result: Astros – three years, $15 million
The Astros could have had Hawkins for $7 million-$8 million over two years. Lyon isn’t deserving of the scorn some are dishing out right now, but Hawkins at his price surely seemed like the more attractive option.
Takashi Saito
Guess: Diamondbacks – one year, $4 million
Result: Braves – one year, $3.2 million plus incentives
Rafael Betancourt
Guess: Rockies – one year, $4 million
Result: Accepted arbitration

  1. Bob R. - Dec 11, 2009 at 8:32 AM

    ” Lyon isn’t deserving of the scorn some are dishing out right now….”
    Although there is some mocking of Lyon, the real scorn is for the Astros. The problem is less that paying so much for a generic middle reliever off one outlier year is silly than that it is foolish for the Astros to be doing it.
    Had the Phillies signed him for that money, they might have been overpaying, but as serious contenders it could be justified. The extra bullpen help might be the difference between a title and being an also-ran.
    But the Astros are at best long shots. Paying Lyon suggests they think he will help them contend which makes no sense. A team with a barren farm system and little reasonable expectation to make the post-season should not be squandering money on relievers.

  2. Dirck - Dec 11, 2009 at 11:26 AM

    Why is a team like the Astros who are unwilling to invest 5 million or so by choosing quality prospects in the draft who might have the potential to become stars for them willing to waste 15 million on a relief pitcher who will never be more than mediocre and 4.5 million on Pedro Feliz , whose best days are well behind him and who wasn’t that good even then , when they have several other possible 3B already on their roster who are roughly as good ?

Leave Comment

You must be logged in to leave a comment. Not a member? Register now!

Featured video

Orioles turn AL East on its head
Top 10 MLB Player Searches
  1. G. Stanton (3798)
  2. R. Castillo (2899)
  3. A. Rizzo (2407)
  4. A. Pujols (2050)
  5. H. Ryu (2048)
  1. E. Gattis (2027)
  2. C. Davis (1871)
  3. B. Belt (1846)
  4. J. Hamilton (1830)
  5. C. Young (1773)