Skip to content

Spring training questions: Oakland Athletics

Feb 25, 2010, 7:40 PM EDT

Over the next couple of weeks, I’ll be looking at a few of the questions facing each team this spring.
1. Can Ben Sheets and Justin Duchscherer hold up at the top of the rotation?
Sheets would seem to have the better chance of the two. He hasn’t put in a full season since 2004, but he did make 31 starts in 2008 and he should be completely recovered from the torn flexor tendon in his elbow that cost him last season. It’s important to remember that he’s not coming off major shoulder surgery or Tommy John surgery — he’s a far better bet than most pitchers coming off a missed season. Duchscherer, on the other hand, has never put in a full season as a starter and he has significant back and hip issues to go along with history of arm problems. Also, he missed the end of last season with clinical depression.
If the two pitchers somehow combine to make 55-60 starts, the A’s would have a legitimate chance of reaching the postseason. But while I think Sheets is a reasonable bet to hold up his end of the bargain, I wouldn’t pencil in Duchscherer to make even 20 starts.
2. Will a Rajai Davis-Coco Crisp-Ryan Sweeney outfield hit enough to remain intact?
It should be baseball’s best outfield defensively, but the three players have combined for one 800 OPS season between them and that was Crisp’s 2005. Davis, a big surprise over the final four months of last year, is far from the prototypical left fielder, and Sweeney, while still possessing some upside, has hit 12 homers in 948 major league at-bats. I have the trio projected for 23 homers in 1,453 at-bats this season, and even that might be optimistic.
The A’s do have alternatives, but they traded the two best (Scott Hairston and Aaron Cunningham) to the Padres for Kevin Kouzmanoff. Jack Cust could log some outfield time if Eric Chavez forces his way into the lineup as a DH. Gabe Gross is an adequate fourth outfielder, and both Eric Patterson and Travis Buck are still in the organization, though perhaps not for much longer. Odds are that the A’s will go with the defense-first alignment to start and then adjust once they struggle to score runs.
3. Will Trevor Cahill and Gio Gonzalez take necessary steps forward and provide the A’s with some much-needed rotation depth?
The Sheets signing would mean there’s only room for one in the rotation, but that depends on everyone getting through the spring healthy. Both should factor heavily into Oakland’s plans. Gonzalez, who has fanned 143 but walked 81 in 132 2/3 innings as a major leaguer, has nothing left to prove in the minors, while Cahill might yet benefit from some Triple-A time. I’m very interested in seeing how Cahill looks this spring after he went through his rookie season without ever showing a consistent breaking ball. He has the greater upside of the two. If both prove capable of holding their own at the bottom of the rotation, the A’s will be better able to withstand injuries. It’s doubtful that Sheets, Duchscherer, Brett Anderson and Dallas Braden will all be healthy at the same time very frequently.

  1. Dirck - Feb 26, 2010 at 9:12 AM

    It is interesting that the two best hitters in the Oakland organization were completely ignored . It seems that the suggested outfield is incredibly weak offensively and that Michael Taylor should fit in there somewhere . At 1B , Chris Carter is so much better than Daric Barton that he should start the year off as the 1B , but might not because of the A’s gaming his service time . Cust should be the DH . With Taylor , Carter , Cust and Kouzmanoff in the lineup , the A’s might begin to resemble a major league team offensively .

  2. paulieA's - Feb 26, 2010 at 11:30 AM

    I agree with Dirck!! Carter is a stud and is better than Barton. No mention of Taylor of Kouz much!! Don’t sleep on the A’s this year!!

  3. scatterbrian - Feb 26, 2010 at 1:57 PM

    “Carter is a stud and is better than Barton.”
    The same thing was being said two years ago, only it was Barton the stud who should play over Dan Johnson. Not saying Carter = 2007 Barton, just that we can’t assume Carter is automatically better right now, especially considering Carter’s questionable ability to play 1B.
    Carter and Taylor should both begin 2010 in AAA, and should both be fixtures in the A’s lineup by the end of 2010.

Leave Comment

You must be logged in to leave a comment. Not a member? Register now!

Top 10 MLB Player Searches
  1. M. Morse (2299)
  2. H. Pence (2230)
  3. Y. Cespedes (2112)
  4. J. Panik (2064)
  5. M. Moustakas (2039)