Skip to content

Your Monday Afternoon Power Rankings

Sep 20, 2010, 12:56 PM EDT

For the second straight week, a new team tops the charts.

It’s the second-to-last full-blown Power Rankings of the year — on October 4th I’ll rank the eight playoff teams and after that we’ll let the games speak for themselves — and for the second straight week we have a new number one.

1. Phillies (4): This is in partial recognition of their big winning streak and scorching-hot-September, but this is forward-looking too. They’re a playoff lock now, and with Halladay, Oswalt and Hamels, they have by far the best 1-2-3 punch of any of the potential playoff teams. I suppose a lot can happen in two weeks, but I like their chances to win it all better than anyone’s right now.

2. Twins (1): A bit of a letdown following the White Sox series caused them to drop two of three to Oakland, but — assuming Mauer’s knee thing from yesterday is no big deal — they’re still sitting pretty right now.

3. Yankees (2): They’re starting this week’s series against the Rays the same way they started last week’s series against the Rays: with a bullpen that could use a bit of a breather.

4. Rays (3): Taking two of three from the Yankees was sweet, but dropping two of three to the Angels was sour.

5. Braves (7): Not that they really kicked ass last week or anything — the Mets sweep was nice, but that Nats series was no fun for them, and they are farther behind Philly now than they were this time last week — but just about every other candidate for this slot had a worse week by my reckoning. I was half-tempted to make this a five way-tie between the Braves, Rangers and the three-contenders in the NL West, but that would have merely been fun, satisfying and time-saving, so why bother?

6. Rangers (9): A nice cushion gives them a chance to rest Josh Hamilton. Hopefully his MVP chances are the only thing that come out of this injured.

7. Giants (5): Their 1-2-3 — Lincecum, Cain and Sanchez — is pretty darn good too, but it looks like they’ll be in a dogfight all the way to the end. They have the division lead at the moment, but you won’t find bigger Philly fans this side of Pennsylvania than you will among the Giants during the Phils-Braves series.

8. Padres (8): The only good news this past weekend was that the Rockies got beat by L.A., keeping them at bay for the time being.

9. Rockies (6): Yesterday’s game was a heartbreaker, what with blowing a big lead against a team that had been sleepwalking and everything. One game may very well prove to be the difference in the west. Was that game it for the Rockies?

10. Reds (10): Sporting a 7-11 record in September which simultaneously should give Reds and Cardinals fans pause. The former for the team’s October prospects, the latter for what it’s failure to make up ground on a scuffling team means.

11. Red Sox (11): With J.D. Drew announcing his retirement effective after next season, the Boston writers have just over a year to decide on the next repository for their ire. I guess Lackey will work, but a real replacement will be someone who is actually pretty good most of the time, but whom they hate with an irrational passion.

12. Cardinals (13): They end the season with a four-game series against the Rockies, so it’s not 100% accurate to say that St. Louis is not longer a playoff factor. They are, but just not for their own chances. Beating San Diego this past weekend and crushing Colorado to wind things up would be a pretty neat trick.

13. White Sox (12): How long can Manny Ramirez be the scapegoat before people get bored and turn their attention to Kenny Williams and Ozzie Guillen? Jeez, Peter King was beating on Manny in his column this morning for cryin’ out loud, and he writes about football (or so I’m told).

14. Athletics (15): Based on the 2011 schedule, I’m wondering if there isn’t a plot to drive A’s attendance down even lower than it is. Instead of two series hosting the Yankees and Red Sox there’s only one. Interleague visitors: Marlins, Diamondbacks. Bud Selig doesn’t seem to want to make the case for San Jose overtly, but by gum, he and his schedule makers will do so passively!

15. Tigers (17): Austin Jackson, Alex Avila and Scott Sizemore led the Tigers to a sweep of the White Sox this weekend. Should Tigers fans be hopeful, or is this merely a quick trip to the Island of Flukeopolis?

16. Blue Jays (16): Jose Bautista will get his 50th home run this week in all likelihood. This is the first time 50 home runs has felt special to me since Cecil Fielder did it in 1990.

17. Astros (19): They have to finish 9-4 to reach .500.  Yes, I really was being serious when I said that I was following this “race.”

18. Mets (18): I have no idea how the Braves’ season is going to end, but even if it ends up short of the playoffs, Bobby Cox leaving with a sweep in his last series against the Mets makes for a fitting sendoff.

19. Angels (21): How you lose two of three to the Indians and take two of three from the Rays is a bit of a mystery, but there are a lot of mysteries hiding in the records of non-contending teams playing out the string.

20. Dodgers (19): Apropos of nothing, I noticed last night that someone with a Los Angeles Dodgers IP address had been Googling me by name and reading my personal blog. My first impulse was to worry that Frank McCourt had finally gotten fed up with me ragging on him all the time and was doing some intelligence work in preparation for my assassination, but then I remembered that hit men tend to work on a cash-only basis, so now I know I’m safe. 

21. Cubs (23): I know they’re behind Milwaukee in the standings, but a six game winning streak when they have every reason to pack it in ain’t hay. Mike Quade is making it really hard to hire someone besides him for the permanent job, isn’t he?

22. Brewers (22): I said this morning that the Astros could be a reasonable pick for third place next year. The big caveat: if the Brewers unload Prince Fielder — get me, I mentioned both baseball playing Fielders in the same post! — for a frontline starter, that could change things.

23. Marlins (14): Yeah, this is a freefall, but they lost every game last week for cryin’ out loud.

24. Orioles (24): And yes, they’ve had a much better go of it than Florida lately, but at some point you have to acknowledge that they still have 15 more losses than the Marlins do. You can’t just pretend the early part of the season didn’t happen, even if it weighs less and less each week. Because of that, this is really they’re ceiling, I think.

25. Indians (25): 9-8 in September and a half-game lead for fourth place over the Royals. Little victories, right?

26. Royals (26): 5-11 in September and a worse winning percentage in the second half than the first. Remember all of those “Ned Yost is resurrecting the Royals” columns from earlier this year? Yeah, whatever.

27. Nationals (27): Jim Riggleman is probably coming back. I suppose that’s the right move. This has nothing to do with anything let alone whether it is the right move, but I met Riggleman back in spring training, and I found him to be the most patient and polite of the eight or ten managers with whom I interacted.

28. Mariners (29): They still have a realistic shot of scoring below 500 runs for the seaso
n. A bit of a long shot — t
hey have to score 27 runs in 13 games to reach 499 — but I have faith.

29. Pirates (30); 30. Diamondbacks (28): Pittsburgh is probably still technically the worst team in baseball, but they did sweep the Diamondbacks, so I should give them their props for at least one week.

  1. RichardInBigD - Sep 20, 2010 at 1:05 PM

    Hamilton has now missed 17 games all season, and contributed mightily so that the team would not be in a state of panic if he were not available. How does that hurt his MVP chances?

  2. Chris Fiorentino - Sep 20, 2010 at 1:11 PM

    About time the Phillies made #1 on your list, you biased Braves fan 😉 Just kidding with you Craigy. The fact is that the Phillies haven’t deserved it until they started hitting the Damn Ball!!! Too many people poo-poo’d the trade for Oswalt when the fact is that it single-handedly changed the Phillies from being just the best team in the National League to the best team in all of baseball. They could have gotten to the World Series without Oswalt. With him, they actually have a chance to win it. If Doc pitches on 3 days rest, which he will, then they may not even have to start Blanton. Wouldn’t that be nice.

  3. Craig Calcaterra - Sep 20, 2010 at 1:17 PM

    Because writers who vote tend to place an inordinate amount of weight on what happens in September in close pennant races.

  4. Simon DelMonte - Sep 20, 2010 at 1:29 PM

    See under “Troy, House on Fire, Rockies.”

  5. Jonny5 - Sep 20, 2010 at 1:30 PM

    I just pitched a tent. Clothed in Khaki. It took all season long, but it’s here at last. Not the tent, that’s always a problem. The ranking. Well, all I have to say is, YES!!
    Three games back is far from insurmountable. Kind of in the same way that Inez Sainz is not insurmountable by, myself. But it is not impossible, mkay!!!! Keep your chins up guys and keep winning!!

  6. Utley's hair - Sep 20, 2010 at 1:59 PM

    The Phightins at No. 1? Right before they meet Bobby’s Bravos? Wow. Craig must be trying to say something here, but I can’t quite put my finger on it…

  7. Omega - Sep 20, 2010 at 2:05 PM

    That Dodgers comment may be some of your best writing, Craig. Keep up the good work!

  8. Mrsteve - Sep 20, 2010 at 2:59 PM

    Nick Punto is back so the Twins are in trouble.
    He must have some pictures on Gardy or something.
    Secret Lovers. Humming the tune.
    That Guy before you respond just shut up & have the balls to make your own posts instead of making back handed remarks to other people’s. Ball cheese.

  9. Utley's hair - Sep 20, 2010 at 3:02 PM

    Does that make Tulo the Rockies’ Trojan (work)Horse?

  10. Jonny5 - Sep 20, 2010 at 3:30 PM

    It’s his whole Jinx thing working it’s evil here Hair. Craig thinks he’s outfoxing us, but we’re onto him.

  11. Utley's hair - Sep 20, 2010 at 3:36 PM

    And he thinks ganging together to schmooze the Phightins love on HBT Daily with (apparent) fellow Cox lover Stroup will do something, while he would have a much better chance if it was Tiffany.

  12. Jonny5 - Sep 20, 2010 at 4:01 PM

    mmm hmmmm…… He’s sly as a fox. he’s trying to get his Jinx on alright.

  13. RichardInBigD - Sep 20, 2010 at 4:14 PM

    Except that the Rangers really haven’t been in a pennant race since May, in large part thanks to Josh’s output.

  14. turf24 - Sep 20, 2010 at 6:13 PM

    If they move to San Jose wouldn’t it be smarter for them to call themselves the California A’s for broader appeal? Like how the Angels were before they shortened then hyphenated theirs.

  15. Dustin84v - Sep 21, 2010 at 11:07 AM

    Philly has too many all-stars players for other teams to handle. Jim Rollins, Shane Victorino, Chase Utley, Placido Polanco, Ryan Howard, Raul Ibanez, Jayson Werth, and Mike Sweeney are legitimate mid-summer classic performers.

  16. Bull Durham - Sep 21, 2010 at 1:03 PM

    I’m having a hard time using the word “special” to describe Bautista’s impending 50 homers in light of the fact that he’s never topped 16 before this year. Yes, even in the “post” steroid era, I am skeptical to say the least. Shall we also celebrate the 14th anniversay of Brady Anderson’s “special” achievement as well?

  17. Cleareye - Sep 21, 2010 at 7:10 PM

    The Dodgers are dead, and will remain so, until resurrected by new ownership- any new ownership!

Leave Comment

You must be logged in to leave a comment. Not a member? Register now!

Top 10 MLB Player Searches
  1. G. Stanton (2488)
  2. H. Ramirez (2485)
  3. G. Springer (2458)
  4. S. Strasburg (2380)
  5. J. Baez (2349)
  1. C. Correa (2346)
  2. B. Crawford (2271)
  3. H. Pence (2260)
  4. M. Teixeira (2195)
  5. B. Harper (2057)