Skip to content

Deep Thoughts: The Blue Jays' home runs

Oct 1, 2010, 3:06 PM EDT

A friend of mine emailed me a few minutes ago and asked — all of my previous objections to PED accusations of Jose Bautista notwithstanding — whether the fact that the Blue Jays had hit so many home runs this year still didn’t raise any suspicions in my mind. Specifically, he noted — correctly — that the PED scourge of the 1980s-2000s followed a pattern in which players on one team “infected” players on another team with some of them — notably Jose Canseco — acting as Typhoid Marys or what have you, so why couldn’t this be happening on a team that, as a group, is hitting a ton more home runs.

I thought about it a bit, but I came back to the same place I’ve been all along: yes, anything is possible, but give me some evidence — any evidence — that anyone on the Blue Jays is using in 2010 and then I’ll entertain the thought.

But my friend’s question did cause me to wonder if the mere fact of the home runs themselves, absent any external evidence, can be explained by some factor other than random chance. I came up with two possibilities that, in my mind at least, are more plausible than PEDs:

1) Non-PED cheating such as hanky panky with baseballs thrown to Blue Jays hitters, some elaborate sign stealing scheme or the like.  No, we have no evidence for this either, but if we’re going to assume cheating of some kind, doesn’t this seem like a better bet than ‘roids?  With steroids a couple dozen guys would have to sneak through multiple PED tests this year.  If you pulled a 1951 Giants or had a secret humidor for balls for the opposition however, everyone could benefit and no would get caught unless there was a snitch in the group (I got my eye on you Yunel Escobar!);

2) Swinging for the fences. I’m sure someone has written about this at some point this season, but it’s worth noting that the Blue Jays’ 2010 offense is worse than the Blue Jays 2009 offense, home runs notwithstanding. Team OBP is down from 2009, as is
their run scoring. Meanwhile, their strikeouts are up substantially
(they’ll finish with 130-140 more this year than last year). 
Essentially, they’ve traded a number of singles, doubles and walks for a
greater number of home runs and strikeouts, all to the detriment of

Like I said, I’m sure someone has asked Dwayne Murphy or Bautista about it at some point this season (I put his under “Deep Thoughts” because I’m suffering from the mid-afternoon blahs right now and I don’t want to look it up), but it would not shock me at all if, as a team, everyone just decided to grip it and rip it this year. Proudly Canadian — you always school me on Jays stuff. Am I out to lunch here?

Anyway, the whole reason I even wrote all of this is not because I think either cheating or hacking is the best explanation — I still think chance played a huge role — but because, if people are going to gravitate to easy explanations like the “Bautista is a ‘roider!” thing, they may as well have another couple of easy options at their disposal as well. Especially a couple that seem slightly more plausible.

  1. Proudly Canadian - Oct 3, 2010 at 8:35 AM

    I usually have lunch fully clothed, so I will not comment about about that book. I will say that here in Canada, beavers know how to lay down the lumber. Thus, the hitting feats of the Jays should not surprise anyone.

  2. Proudly Canadian - Oct 3, 2010 at 11:31 AM

    Blue Jay HR totals with 1 game to go:
    Bautista 54 – Previous best 16
    Wells 31 – Previous best 33
    Hill 26 – Previous best 36
    Lind 22 – Previous best 35
    Buck 20 – Previous best 18
    Encarnacion 20 – Previous best 26
    Overbay 20 – Previous best 22
    Gonzalez 17 in TO and 6 in Atlanta – Previous best 23
    Snider 14 – Previous best 9. Many people who have watched the 22 year old Snider think that in the future he will lead the league in home runs several times.

  3. Proudly Canadian - Oct 3, 2010 at 4:26 PM

    The only Blue Jay home run in the final game of the season was hit by Encarnacion. It was his 21 st of the season, His personal best of 26 was set in 2008.

  4. Proudly Canadian - Oct 3, 2010 at 4:31 PM

    Just a quick update. Both Lind and Encarnation hit home runs today. Both of them are below their previous seasonal best.

Leave Comment

You must be logged in to leave a comment. Not a member? Register now!

Top 10 MLB Player Searches
  1. C. Correa (2507)
  2. G. Stanton (2500)
  3. Y. Puig (2495)
  4. B. Crawford (2387)
  5. H. Pence (2251)
  1. G. Springer (2210)
  2. H. Ramirez (2132)
  3. M. Teixeira (2127)
  4. J. Hamilton (2108)
  5. J. Baez (2083)