Skip to content

Rangers bench Vladimir Guerrero for Game 2

Oct 28, 2010, 4:25 PM EDT

World Series Rangers Giants Baseball AP

Vladimir Guerrero made a rare appearance in the outfield last night because the Rangers were playing under NL rules in San Francisco, but after multiple miscues defensively manager Ron Washington has decided to bench the nine-time All-Star and former MVP for Game 2 tonight.

David Murphy replaces Guerrero in the lineup and will start in left field, with Nelson Cruz moving from left field to right field. Cruz will also take over for Guerrero in the cleanup spot behind Josh Hamilton.

And it’s absolutely the right move.

Guerrero didn’t just look bad in right field last night, he looked horrendous. It was sad to watch. Plus, it’s not clear that Guerrero is even a better option than Murphy offensively at this point, at least against a right-handed pitcher like tonight’s Giants starter, Matt Cain.

In his prime Guerrero was a middle-of-the-order monster regardless of the handedness of the pitcher, but this season at age 35 he hit .287/.328/.482 versus righties. That production is right around average for a corner outfielder, which makes Guerrero solidly below average once his defense is factored in. He also struggled overall in the second half and has produced a measly .601 OPS in the playoffs.

Meanwhile, the left-handed-hitting Murphy batted .298/.368/.479 versus righties this season, which is 37 points of OPS better than Guerrero. Murphy is also an above-average defender. Based purely on current ability rather than reputations and names my guess is that Ron Washington would have made this move for Game 1, but he at least deserves some credit for not making the same mistake twice.

And perhaps Guerrero will have a chance to make his presence felt with a big at-bat off the bench.

  1. IdahoMariner - Oct 28, 2010 at 4:28 PM

    thank you, Mr. Washington. That was too painful to watch last night. Apparently running around in the field also made him dog it to and from the plate. rest up, Vlad. see you this weekend.

  2. Jonny 5 - Oct 28, 2010 at 4:31 PM

    Bummer! But it looks the right decision. BTW Aaron, with Lee on the mound Washington probably figured Vlad wouldn’t get too many chances to screw up in the OF.

    • 3greenowls - Oct 28, 2010 at 5:10 PM

      So if Lee pitched masterfully Vlad would have played right again tonight? That’s not sound reasoning to keep someone in the field, let alone a manager of a major league baseball team.

  3. Richard In Big D - Oct 28, 2010 at 5:01 PM

    I love Vlad not in an Angels uni. I love him more in Rangers laundry. But I hate him playing in the field, and I hate it even worse when he does anything at all fancy on the basepaths. He used to be quite fast on the paths, but this season, I ve seen him thrown out at second trying to get there on a legit double several times, and his green light to steal needs to be permanently changed to red. I’m not at all sure he could beat Benji Molina in a footrace any more. He can still hit any kind of crap thrown his way, usually with some force, but he should have standing orders to run through first and never take the turn, unless his hit went over the fence. Once safely on first, it’s time for a pinch runner. Sad, really.

Leave Comment

You must be logged in to leave a comment. Not a member? Register now!

Featured video

Three legends off to Cooperstown
Top 10 MLB Player Searches