Skip to content

Some thoughts on Bruce Bochy and Brian Sabean

Nov 2, 2010, 9:00 AM EST

Brian Sabean, Bruce Bochy

Given that we’re only 11 hours out from the Giants winning the World Series, it’s probably no surprise that there’s euphoria in the Giants’ front office. And there’s no surprise that the front office is telling the Merc’s Andrew Baggarly that they’re planning on extending the contracts of manager Bruce Bochy and GM Brian Sabean. Each of them are under contract for 2011 with options for 2012, but you figure those deals will be torn up and replaced with new ones, befitting their new status as bosses of the champs.

Certainly a no-brainer on Bochy. Even without the title, there’s a reason he stayed on so long in San Diego: he’s a steady manager whose players respect him who has the confidence of his superiors. His performance in the playoffs was pretty damn good too, and there’s little question that he’s one of the better managers in baseball.

I’ve certainly taken my shots at Brian Sabean over the years. So many that I got no less than ten emails from people after last night’s game asking me if I was going to write a mea culpa regarding my criticism of the guy.  Thankfully Matthew put a lot of my thoughts into words overnight. Short version: much of this Giants’ team’s success was built on Sabean’s previous failures. This is not a sharp criticism in my mind, and should even be seen as praise of a sort. How many people refuse to learn from their mistakes, or to even fail to acknowledge them in the first place? Sabean believed that Barry Bonds would play forever and was responsible for the team failing to rebuild for years. But he was also responsible for drafting very, very well in recent years to make up for it and for making a number of shrewd moves during the season that kept a team that a lot of people were writing off in the middle of the summer — myself first and foremost — in the hunt. As reader APBA Guy wrote in a comment thread overnight, this is a results oriented business, and Brian Sabean brought home the title. You can’t argue with that.

But at the same time, you can’t get too carried away. While it’s hard for some to resist calling good luck genius after the fact, I won’t be doing that with Brian Sabean. Most of the time depending on the waiver wire to patch holes midseason is going to backfire on you. Most of the time going into a season counting on aging sluggers like Pat Burrell and Aubrey Huff isn’t going to pan out. Most of the time if your two most expensive players — Barry Zito and Aaron Rowand — are non-factors in your playoff push and postseason, you’ve failed as a general manager.  Thanks to the pitching staff and some lightning in a bottle these things didn’t mortally wound the Giants, and while Sabean gets credit for the staff he shouldn’t get credit for the lightning.

Does Brian Sabean deserve a contract extension? Sure he does, because he got the job done that most general managers — including those who are constantly praised by people like me — don’t get done.

But let’s not hand him a book deal for “Success 101: Winning the Brian Sabean Way” either. Because while he made a lot of good moves, a lot of this happened in spite of his biggest decisions.

  1. apbaguy - Nov 2, 2010 at 10:14 AM

    Largely agree, although in the euphoria here I expect you’ll hear a lot of criticism from Gigantes fans-who seem to be multiplying out here. 49ers? Who are they?

    Let’s also add last year’s # 1 hitter being a non-factor, a SS who hit 3 HR’s all season hitting 2 in 5 games in the WS, etc..

    Despite it all, as I said last night, for a short series the pitching, and it’s still a young staff, was everything a manager, GM or fan could dream it to be.

  2. tomemos - Nov 2, 2010 at 11:18 AM

    Quibble: he didn’t go into the year counting on Pat Burrell. But the larger point is right: a lot of players had to overperform expectations over the whole season (Torres) or just the postseason (Renteria) to get here.

  3. skerney - Nov 2, 2010 at 11:53 AM

    Giants fans still remember Ricky Ledee, michael tucker, jeffery hammonds, alex sanchez, alberto castillo, jose gullien, lance niekro, aaron rowand, barry zito, and breaking camp with brian bocock.

Leave Comment

You must be logged in to leave a comment. Not a member? Register now!

Featured video

Cubs shore up rotation with Jon Lester
Top 10 MLB Player Searches
  1. C. Gonzalez (2192)
  2. J. Grilli (2123)
  3. A. Pierzynski (2074)
  4. D. Young (1990)
  5. D. Ross (1975)
  1. S. Smith (1925)
  2. T. Stauffer (1844)
  3. D. Uggla (1668)
  4. J. Walden (1668)
  5. H. Kuroda (1602)