Skip to content

Carl Crawford = Roberto Clemente, and more of the latest buzz from Rosenthal

Nov 15, 2010, 9:15 AM EDT

carl crawford rays

Ken Rosenthal has a new column up.  Nothing outrageously juicy in it, but several thought-provoking items:

  • Carl Crawford’s career to this point looks a lot like Roberto Clemente’s. A flawed comparison, no question, but an interesting one anyway. If the second half of Crawford’s career follows Clemente’s pattern anyone who signs him will be happy. Well, assuming it ends differently.
  • Understatement of the century, about the Marlins, based on a potential Dan Uggla trade: “a post-Uggla lineup that included Emilio Bonifacio at second and Chris Coghlan in center field would raise significant questions.”  Among those questions are “why would I ever, ever want to watch a Marlins game?”
  • Regarding Victor Martinez’s free agent prospects: “No doubt, he’s an outstanding hitter and teammate, but his numbers, if he were a full-time first baseman, would rank him only slightly ahead of say, free agent Adam LaRoche.”  This is an overlooked point. Everyone loves Martinez’s flexibility — and it is valuable — but he’s not a good enough defensive catcher to stick back there every day, nor is he good enough a hitter to carry first base full time for a contender. He’s a great player to have, no question, but no team should pay him like a front line superstar. Nothing against him, but if he’s your best, you’re not going anywhere.
  • Ken Macha could be the Mets’ bench coach if Terry Collins gets the job, thanks to both his personal connection with Collins — they were minor league teammates — and Macha’s familiarity with the NL.  My view of bench coaches, as far as it goes, is that they should be managerial b.s. detectors. Old guys that aren’t hot prospects for another job elsewhere, but who have been around the block a bit and can tell the manager “Dude. Seriously. You don’t want to do that,” without fear of alienating anyone or hurting their career.  Macha can probably be that guy.

Many more nuggets in there.  Winter stinks, but Rosenthal’s hot stove stuff is always a good way to kill some time.

  1. scapistron - Nov 15, 2010 at 9:58 AM

    That concept really is not out of line, the second graph really says it all.

  2. BC - Nov 15, 2010 at 10:12 AM

    Stats-wise, through their age-29 seasons, it’s actually interesting:
    Crawford: .296 Avg, 104 HR, 592 RBI, 1480 H, 409 SB, 1 Gold Glove
    Clemente: .307 Avg, 104 HR, 657 RBI, 1633 H, 49 SB, 4 Gold Gloves
    Two different players, though. Crawford will end up with 800+ stolen bases, and while he’s very good defensively, Clemente might have been the best ever. Clemente also went on a complete rampage for the remainder of his career. Remains to be seen if Crawford has that in him.

  3. WhenMattStairsIsKing - Nov 15, 2010 at 1:55 PM

    Brilliant point by Ken regarding Victor Martinez. I’ve been thinking about that myself – his offensive numbers are worth 3/$25 or 4/$36 at the most if he becomes a 1B/DH, and that’s just because he can still catch part-time for half that sort of deal.

Leave Comment

You must be logged in to leave a comment. Not a member? Register now!

Top 10 MLB Player Searches
  1. M. Moore (3825)
  2. J. Hamilton (3703)
  3. G. Stanton (3424)
  4. J. Ellsbury (3389)
  5. M. Cain (3261)
  1. H. Ramirez (3192)
  2. M. Sano (3024)
  3. B. Harper (3019)
  4. J. Fernandez (2863)
  5. P. Corbin (2724)