Skip to content

Let’s make all of the Dodgers free agents

May 6, 2011, 4:00 PM EDT

St Louis Cardinals v Los Angeles Dodgers Getty Images

Now we know this isn’t going to happen. But I thought this would be fun. It’s May 31… the Dodgers miss payroll and MLB, not realizing it, is a few minutes late in stepping in to pay the players. Every Dodger player now has the right to elect free agency.

There’s two thoughts here: first, being the middle of the season, most teams don’t have nearly the financial flexibility that they would in the offseason. Budgets are set and many GMs would have to get creative in making contract proposals to the free agents. Odds are that the non-superstars wouldn’t do as well financially as they would as offseason free agents.

Second, while guys like Casey Blake and Jon Garland could take financial hits, leaving might be preferable to sticking around a Dodgers team suddenly reduced to rubble by key departures. So, I’ll work under the assumption that if it’s close, the player is going to move on.

Now the fun part… who goes where.

Clayton Kershaw – This one is obvious, right? No one is going to outbid the Yankees for Kershaw’s services. At 23 and already a dominant force, having posted a 3.19 ERA in 90 career starts, Kershaw is one of the most valuable properties around and it’s make perfect sense for the Yankees to go all in for him. Still four years away from actual free agency, Kershaw would stand to benefit more than anyone from this chain of events. The injury risk is significant, but I imagine he’d get at least $100 million for six years as a free agent. Prediction: Yankees – six years, $108 million

Matt Kemp – In the midst of a bounce-back season, the 26-year-old Kemp is hitting .352/.423/.566 with six homers and 10 steals in 32 games. Making a modest $6.95 million this year, he’d be extremely attractive if the Dodgers decided to turn him into trade bait. However, I’m not sure who would step up and offer him the $18 million-$20 million he’s worth if he became a free agent. The Yankees (with Kershaw), Phillies, Red Sox and White Sox are pretty much tapped out now. The Nationals would make a lot of sense, given their modest $64 million payroll, but they might be gunshy after just adding Jayson Werth. How about the Royals? They’re spending just $36 million this year, so they can take the money, and for all of their prospects, they’re missing a long-term center fielder. What better way to say they’re serious about contending in the AL Central than by signing Kemp? Prediction: Royals – four years, $76 million

Andre Ethier – A good friend of Dustin Pedroia’s, Ethier has been mentioned as a possible Red Sox target several times, and Boston will be looking for a right fielder for 2012 and beyond. Ethier, though, is poor defensively and might be better off as a long-term first baseman. How about the Nationals sign him and move him to first base once Bryce Harper is ready? If he’d rather join an immediate contender, perhaps he could sign a short-term deal with the Rays or Rangers that would allow him to become a free agent again after 2012. Prediction: Nationals – four years, $56 million

Chad Billingsley – Billingsley just inked a three-year, $33 million extension that would keep him in Los Angeles through 2014. However, he could almost surely do better on the open market with so many teams needing pitching. The Mets and Cubs may not have much flexibility for this year, but with all of the contracts they have coming off the books, they could afford to pay Billingsley $15 million per year starting in 2012. The Orioles should also consider a strong bid. Prediction: Orioles – five years, $75 million

OK, let’s go to the lightning round now. I’ll list players with their current salaries.

Rod Barajas ($3.25 million) – The Red Sox, Royals and Rockies might be tempted by his power and solid glove. He’d probably go.
Casey Blake ($5.25 million) – On the shelf with an elbow infection. Still, with so many teams needing third basemen, he’d likely depart, maybe for San Fran.
Jonathan Broxton ($7 million) – With iffy elbow, he’ll stay put and try to rebuild his value.
Rafael Furcal ($12 million) – A broken thumb means he’ll stay put and wait for free agency at season’s end.
Jon Garland ($5 million) – Vesting option for $8 million if he throws 190 innings. He might prefer to stay and get his money.
Matt Guerrier ($2.25 million) – The Dodgers made the biggest offer over the winter, signing him for $12 million over three years. He’ll stay.
Kenley Jansen ($0.4 million) – Struggled with command this year, but big-time arm. It’d be worth a Guerrier-type deal to control him for the next six years.
Hong-Chih Kuo ($2.275 million) – He’d be a big risk on a long-term deal, but if healthy, he’s a potential difference maker in October. The Red Sox or Yankees would give him a raise.
Hiroki Kuroda ($12 million) – Likes L.A. and passed up long-term deals as a free agent in the offseason. He’ll stay.
Ted Lilly ($7.5 million) – He’s due $25 million between 2012-13. Off to a poor start, he probably wouldn’t match that as a free agent. Stays.
James Loney ($4.875 million) – Would anyone want him? He’s not worth his salary with the way he’s played the last two years.
Vicente Padilla ($2 million) – Looking impressive in his stint as a short reliever. Some other NL team would want him as a setup man.
Jerry Sands ($0.4 million) – Everyone would be interested in a 23-year-old with his power. It’d probably take at least $16 million-$20 million for four years to sign him.
Juan Uribe ($5 million) – No one is going to match the three-year, $21 million the Dodgers gave him over the winter. Stays.

  1. yankeesfanlen - May 6, 2011 at 4:17 PM

    This is the reason I don’t go to garage sales. I buy everything. Think my team is much the same.

  2. cup0pizza - May 6, 2011 at 4:43 PM

    Your article sucks. You also claim that Ethier is a poor fielder. Not true. He ain’t Roberto Clemente, but he is not bad in the field at all.

    • Gobias Industries - May 6, 2011 at 5:02 PM

      This would be the downside of putting computers in our middle schools. Kids like this get to use them.

    • tk1966 - May 6, 2011 at 5:05 PM

      It got you to read it and to comment on it. That means that the author is doing his job, therefore the article didn’t suck; it worked. Guess that means you just proved yourself wrong.

  3. Alex K - May 6, 2011 at 5:05 PM

    Kershaw would blow $18 million away. There would be nothing holding his price down. It would probably be something more like 7 years, $165 million.

    • Alex K - May 6, 2011 at 5:08 PM

      I say that assuming since they are free agents there will be no service time consideration. So you sign Kershaw, you only have him for the life of the contract, not his arbitation years.

  4. Kevin S. - May 6, 2011 at 5:28 PM

    I really doubt the fact that budgets are set would really make that big of an impact. The contract would just have a low base for this season and then go up toward what they might get as FA in the off season.

  5. randomdigits - May 6, 2011 at 6:11 PM

    Fun exercise but no way AM ponies up five years, $75 million for a starting pitcher. Buy the bats grow the arms is his mantra these days.

  6. koufaxmitzvah - May 6, 2011 at 6:44 PM

    I’m in the camp that this article blows chunks. And while, yeah, I clicked on the link, it was along the same lines of seeing the massive car wreck and, oh boy, there sure are spilled brains all over the road.

    I expect HBT to be better than this crap. Seriously.

    • Merkle's Boner - May 6, 2011 at 7:33 PM

      We took a vote and decided that we don’t care what you think. Your opinion is worthless to us. Seriously.

  7. sasquash20 - May 6, 2011 at 10:16 PM

    I thought it was a fun, silly read. Kershaw would get way more then a 100 million. Back to back sub 3 era seasons with 200 plus strike outs and hes not even 24 yet. WOW

Leave Comment

You must be logged in to leave a comment. Not a member? Register now!

Featured video

Managers get easier path to Cooperstown
Top 10 MLB Player Searches
  1. H. Street (3997)
  2. C. Lee (2940)
  3. H. Ramirez (2872)
  4. T. Tulowitzki (2820)
  5. Y. Puig (2699)
  1. C. Headley (2693)
  2. B. Belt (2511)
  3. J. Soria (2439)
  4. T. Walker (2235)
  5. A. Rios (2162)