Skip to content

Opening Day shortstop Alexi Casilla moves closer to the exit in Minnesota

May 9, 2011, 12:20 PM EDT

alexi-casilla-twins Getty Images

Alexi Casilla‘s ill-conceived reign as the Twins’ starting shortstop lasted all of a month, as he played his way out of the job by hitting .190 with predictably spotty defense at a position where he lacked both the skills and experience to succeed.

Trevor Plouffe has now taken over at shortstop, earning a call-up by shaking off a dreadful spring training to start well at Triple-A. That leaves Casilla as the primary second baseman, with manager Ron Gardenhire saying:

I talked with Alexi about it. I asked him about second base and he said it’s easier. We’ll see if it’s easier. I know he’s always more comfortable over there too. I think he’s trying to do a whole heck of a lot. At second base maybe he’ll be able to relax a little bit more and not rush things.

Casilla needing to relax and get comfortable has been repeated like a manta since his debut in 2006, along with talk of supposed upside. At this point, however, it might be time to conclude that Casilla just isn’t very good. He’ll be 27 years old in July and has 1,200 plate appearances in the majors, so Casilla is neither young nor inexperienced. Defensively he’s overmatched at shortstop and merely decent at second base, and he’s a career .244 hitter with a .301 on-base percentage and .321 slugging percentage.

Even his best raw tools more often than not go to waste. Casilla has a strong arm, but the big windup and shaky accuracy mean he can’t be counted on to make routine plays. He has great speed and is a remarkably efficient base-stealer, yet has a grand total of just 37 steals in 338 games. Casilla is out of minor-league options and can’t be sent to Triple-A without first passing through waivers, but the risk of losing him should no longer be part of the decision-making.

There’s no immediate reason to cut bait on Casilla, but if Plouffe is performing well enough to keep a starting job by the time Tsuyoshi Nishioka is ready to return from his fractured fibula in a couple weeks keeping Casilla around would likely mean demoting Matt Tolbert to Triple-A or reducing the pitching staff from 12 to 11. It’s difficult to imagine Ron Gardenhire being in favor of either option, so Casilla may truly be playing for his Twins future right now.

  1. minnesconsin - May 9, 2011 at 1:31 PM

    moving him to 2nd is not going to help that .190 batting average in a meaningful way. Once delmon is healthy, I’d rather play him, span, and kubel in the outfield and plug cuddy in at 2nd base until nishi is ready.

    i know the twins “don’t panic,” but it’s time to get real. put your best players on the field as often as you can, period.

Leave Comment

You must be logged in to leave a comment. Not a member? Register now!

Featured video

Who are the favorites for Rookie of the Year?
Top 10 MLB Player Searches
  1. J. Soler (3320)
  2. R. Castillo (2820)
  3. Y. Molina (2621)
  4. A. Dunn (2554)
  5. M. Cabrera (2545)
  1. A. Rizzo (2504)
  2. B. Posey (2311)
  3. J. Ellsbury (2256)
  4. D. Pedroia (2156)
  5. M. Wacha (2064)