Skip to content

2012 Top 111 Free Agents: Nos. 111-81

Jun 20, 2011, 5:00 PM EDT

Jim Thome Getty Images

I posted a look at some honorable mentions yesterday, but here’s the real countdown of the winter’s top 111 free agents. I’m including pretty much everyone except for a few locks. I am assuming that the Yankees and Cardinals will exercise their respective options on Robinson Cano and Yadier Molina. Also, I’m having a hard time imagining Vernon Wells (three years, $63 million) and Rafael Soriano (two years, $25 million) using the out clauses in their contracts. Everyone else is fair game.

So, here’s the first 31. One thing I want to make clear: this list is less about how I rank the players than how I believe they’re perceived by major league teams. There are several guys who didn’t make the cut that I’d take over Miguel Tejada and Juan Pierre, but I’m putting the player in a rough order of the salaries I expect them to make. Most of the players in the first 31 here are guys I see getting guarantees in the $1.5 million-$2.5 million range for next year.

(All ages as of April 1, 2012)

* denotes players with contract options

111. Scott Hairston (31 – Mets): Mets manager Terry Collins doesn’t think highly of Hairston at all — he’s written the outfielder into the lineup once in the last month — but Hairston has produced in his very limited opportunities, hitting .262/.328/.459 with three homers in 61 at-bats. If he can keep it up, he’ll probably get a chance to compete for a starting job with another team next year.

110. Jason Varitek (39 – Red Sox): Varitek has overcome a brutal April to hit .297 with three homers and 13 RBI in 64 at-bats since May 1. Two months ago it looked like the Red Sox would be desperate to upgrade their catching situation before the All-Star break. Now it seems entirely possible that they’ll want the duo of Jarrod Salatalamacchia and Varitek to return in 2012.

109. Miguel Tejada (37 – Giants): It’s safe to say Tejada won’t be signing for $6.5 million again. Had the Giants managed to stay healthier, he may well have been released by now. Tejada is hitting just .220/.251/.288 with one homer in 236 at-bats. It’s going to take a big rebound for him to get taken seriously as a potential 2012 regular.

108. Juan Cruz (33 – Rays): Plucked off the scrap heap by the Rays, Cruz has been a versatile middle man; sometimes he’s just a righty specialist, but he threw three scoreless innings in an appearance against the Mariners earlier this month. Overall, he’s 4-0 with a 3.38 ERA in 26 2/3 innings. He’s not in line for Joaquin Benoit money, but he’ll get a couple of million dollars thrown his way next year if he stays healthy.

107. Ivan Rodriguez (40 – Nationals): Pudge has given the Nationals exactly what they should have expected for their two-year, $6 million investment. He’s no longer enough of an asset defensively to justify regular playing time, but no one has more experience and that counts for plenty with some clubs.

106. Octavio Dotel (38 – Blue Jays)*: Dotel is still racking up strikeouts — he has 24 in 19 1/3 innings — but since he’s also walked 12 and given up four homers, the Jays haven’t displayed a lot of faith in him. He’ll need to improve if he expects the Jays to pick up his $3.5 million option for 2012.

105. Chris Capuano (33 – Mets): A two-time Tommy John survivor, Capuano has stayed healthy for the Mets this year and gone 5-7 with a 4.29 ERA so far. His history should rule out the possibility of a multiyear deal this winter, but he makes for a solid fifth starter.

104. Juan Rivera (33 – Blue Jays): Absorbing the last year of Rivera’s three-year, $12.75 million contract was part of the price the Jays had to pay to get the Angels to take Vernon Wells. He’s been a disappointment, having hit just .250/.314/.364 with five homers and 24 RBI in 220 at-bats. He’s only going to be viewed as a bench player this winter unless he picks it up.

103. Chad Qualls (33 – Padres)*: The club option is for $6 million, so that’s not getting exercised. Qualls hasn’t truly returned to form following his miserable 2010 season: while he has the nice 2.52 ERA, he’s struggled outside of Petco Park and struck out just 20 in 35 2/3 innings overall. Still, it is an improvement and there’s a good chance some contender is going to want to add him prior to the trade deadline.

102. Ben Sheets (33 – free agent): Sheets is rehabbing after undergoing Tommy John surgery last August and isn’t expected to pitch this year. He’s a question mark for 2012 as well, but if he shows velocity in offseason workouts, he should have plenty of teams offering him incentive-laden deals.

101. Edwin Encarnacion (29 – Blue Jays): Encarnacion hasn’t hit for average in years, but at least he managed to smack 21 homers in 332 at-bats for the Blue Jays last season. This year, he has just two while hitting .256/.293/.372 in 180 at-bats. Barring a big turnaround, he probably won’t last the year with the club.

100. Fernando Rodney (35 – Angels): Rodney has posted lower ERAs for the Angels than he did in his final three seasons with the Tigers, but it’s a good bet that he won’t be invited back for 2012. He’ll likely see his current $5.5 million salary halved or worse in free agency.

99. Jonny Gomes (31 – Reds): Gomes is likely better cast as a role player than as a regular: his OPS was 150 points higher against left-handers last year and it’s 450 points higher against them so far this season.

98. Brad Hawpe (32 – Padres)*: The Padres thought 2010 was an aberration when they signed Hawpe to serve as a platoon first baseman, but he’s hit just .231/.301/.344 in 195 at-bats. He’s back playing the outfield now following Anthony Rizzo’s arrival, and the club would be happy to trade him if any suitors pop up. The $6 million mutual option on his contract for 2012 certainly isn’t getting exercised.

97. Jamey Carroll (38 – Dodgers): Carroll didn’t debut in the majors until 28, but he’s a 10-year veteran now and he’s playing about as well as ever at age 37, having hit .308/.376/.375 in 240 at-bats for the Dodgers. One wonders how much longer he can keep it up, but at the moment, there aren’t many better utilitymen.

96. Jeff Francis (31 – Royals): Francis doesn’t have much of a fastball left after battling shoulder problems for years, but he’s managed to turn in nine quality starts in 15 tries for the Royals. Unfortunately, that’s only left him with a 3-7 record and a 4.83 ERA.

95. Lyle Overbay (35 – Pirates): The Pirates spent $5 million to get themselves a solid first baseman, thinking Overbay would come close to repeating his .243/.329/.433 line from 2010 with the Blue Jays. Instead, he’s hit just .228/.307/.353 with five homers for Pittsburgh. His future as a regular will hinge on an improved second half.

94. Michael Wuertz (33 – Athletics)*: Wuertz has struggled to stay healthy since an exceptional first year in Oakland, but he has a 2.95 ERA in 22 appearances this season. His $3.25 million option for 2012 will look pretty reasonable if he can stay off the disabled list the rest of the way. However, it might be another team that has to make a decision on that, since he is a strong candidate to be traded.

93. Clint Barmes (33 – Astros): Barmes likely would have been non-tendered by the Rockies over the winter, but the Astros thought he’d be a solid shortstop and both traded Felipe Paulino for him and signed him for $3.925 million as an arbitration-eligible player. He’ll almost certainly get less as a free agent this winter. Barmes is hitting just .224/.311/.342, which is just about where he finished last year. Most will view him as a utiltyman going forward.

92. Hideki Matsui (37 – Athletics): Matsui usually heats up with the weather, and he has improved to .222/.327/.422 in 45 at-bats this month. Overall, he’s hitting .222/.289/.357 in his first and likely last year as Oakland’s designated hitter.

91. Zach Duke (28 – Diamondbacks)*: The Diamondbacks thought it was worth committing $4.25 million to Duke even after he went 8-15 with a 5.72 ERA for the Pirates last season. After missing nearly two months with a broken hand, he’s come off the DL to go 1-2 with a 4.66 ERA in his first five starts for the club. It’s going to take a lot more than that if the team is going to pull the trigger on his $5.5 million option for 2012.

90. Nate McLouth (30 – Braves): A .240/.335/.341 line may not seem like much, but it’s a huge improvement over what McLouth did for the Braves in 2010. Still rather young at age 29, McLouth may get another crack at a starting job next year. Contenders, though, will likely only look at him as a fourth outfielder.

89. Darren Oliver (41 – Rangers): The ageless Oliver has a chance to post the best ERA of his career for a fourth straight season in 2011. He’s at 2.67 right now, which would be his second-best behind last year’s 2.48 mark. He’s provided a great return on a modest salary six years running.

88. Kerry Wood (34 – Cubs): Wood could have earned at least three times as much elsewhere, but he signed for $1.5 million over the winter because he wanted to return to Chicago. He’s on the DL at the moment with a blister, but he’s posted a 2.25 ERA in 24 innings this season.

87. Jim Thome (41 – Twins): It must be killing Thome that he can’t even stay healthy while being used as a part-time designated hitter. He’s hit a solid .237/.372/.447 in his 76 at-bats this season, but he may opt to call it a career at season’s end if his body continues to fail him.

86. Ryan Doumit (30 – Pirates): Things might have turned out quite a bit differently for Doumit if the Pirates had made him a full-time first baseman or right fielder a few years back. As an injury-prone, subpar defensive catcher, he’s of limited value, even with the nice bat. His latest injury, a fractured ankle, was the result of him getting slid into by Carlos Pena last month.

85. Wilson Betemit (30 – Royals): Betemit just made a huge impact on the NL postseason races by knocking out Albert Pujols for 4-6 weeks. Maybe he’ll get a chance to make another when the inevitable trade out of Kansas City comes. Betemit has hit .287/.344/.410 this season, but the Royals turned him back into a bench player when they called up Mike Moustakas. How he performs for his next team will determine whether he’s viewed as a regular this winter.

84. Livan Hernandez (37 – Nationals): Well, not really 37. Hernandez, though, has enjoyed quite a renaissance in Washington, not that it shows up in his current 4-8 record. He currently has a 3.77 ERA and a 1.30 WHIP in 98 innings. He declined to test free agency last winter, instead signing a $1 million deal to stay with the Nationals. He’ll probably hold out for a bit more next time around.

83. Javier Lopez (34 – Giants): 13 years after being drafted by the Diamondbacks, Lopez has turned into one of the game’s best specialists. Left-handers are just 5-for-50 off him this year, and he hasn’t allowed a homer in 26 2/3 innings for the Giants. He’s currently in line for the first multiyear deal of his career.

82. Juan Pierre (34 – White Sox): Pierre keeps himself in fantastic shape, so he could have more years like his 2010, when he hit .275 and stole 68 bases for the White Sox. Still, with the lack of walks and the nonexistent power, that doesn’t make him much of a left fielder.

81. Freddy Garcia (35 – Yankees): Garcia and Yankee Stadium looked like a bad match, but with a 5-6 record and a 3.62 ERA, the right-hander has been a nice fifth starter for the Bombers. At the rate he’s going, he could be looking at a $5 million guarantee as a free agent this winter. However, given that Garcia hasn’t made 30 starts since 2006, odds are that he will get hurt at some point.

  1. foreverchipper10 - Jun 20, 2011 at 6:11 PM

    I love lists!

  2. royalsfaninfargo - Jun 20, 2011 at 7:00 PM

    If Thome gets to 600 HR this season he retires.

    • sasquash20 - Jun 20, 2011 at 11:03 PM

      I hope he gets there. A girl I know told me how him and a few of his Phillies teammates would go to the local hospitals to lift the spirits of some of the sick or injured. She worked in the burn ward and saw some pretty bad stuff. So I have always liked Thome for being a good guy, didn’t hurt he would smash a ball 400 plus like every other at bat.

      • takemytalentstosoutheuclid - Jun 21, 2011 at 6:58 AM

        Couldn’t agree more on Thome. I had the pleasure of watching him for 12 years in Cleveland. He did that sort of thing all the time (visiting hospitals, sick children, etc.) and is one of the all around good guys in baseball. I am rooting for him to get his 600 HR’s. He is clearly, aside from Vizquel if he retires any time soon, the only person going in to the HOF with a Tribe hat on on the near future.

Leave Comment

You must be logged in to leave a comment. Not a member? Register now!

Featured video

Yanks, Cards and Reds hit with injury bug
Top 10 MLB Player Searches
  1. C. Gonzalez (2611)
  2. J. Votto (2551)
  3. E. Encarnacion (2408)
  4. M. Tanaka (2408)
  5. J. Nelson (2314)
  1. M. Trumbo (2314)
  2. R. Braun (2286)
  3. J. Samardzija (2239)
  4. B. Hamilton (2140)
  5. V. Martinez (2097)