Skip to content

Donavan Tate looks like another draft bust for Padres

Jun 28, 2011, 7:28 PM EDT

padres logo big

In light of his 50-game drug suspension, Donavan Tate is shaping up as the latest in a long line of draft busts for the Padres.

Here are their 17 first-round picks over a 15-year span from 1995-2009, along with their career WARs, courtesy of Baseball-Reference.

1995 – Ben Davis (2nd): 2.9
1996 – Matt Halloran (15th)
1997 – Kevin Nicholson (27th): -0.1
1998 – Sean Burroughs (9th): 1.6
1999 – Vince Faison (20th)
1999 – Gerik Baxter (28th)
1999 – Omar Ortiz (29th)
2000 – Mark Phillips (9th)
2001 – Jake Gautreau (14th)
2002 – Khalil Greene (13th): 8.1
2003 – Tim Stauffer (4th): 4.5
2004 – Matt Bush (1st)
2005 – Cesar Carrillo (18th): -1.2
2006 – Matt Antonelli (17th): -0.4
2007 – Nick Schmidt (23rd)
2008 – Allan Dykstra (23rd)
2009 – Donavan Tate (3rd)

This pretty much all falls on Kevin Towers’ shoulders.  He was the Padres’ scouting director from 1993-1995 and he took over as the GM after that, running the team through the 2009 season.  He often managed to keep the Padres competitive despite modest budgets, but he was unable to find potential stars and even struggled to land quality regulars in the draft.

Only seven of the 17 picks made the majors and just three had signficant careers. Davis is long gone, and it doesn’t look like Greene is going to make it back from the anxiety issues that derailed his career. Stauffer, the 4th overall pick in the 2003 draft, is the one guy contributing to a major league team right now, and at least he is doing it for the Padres.

Besides Stauffer and Tate, Schmidt is the only other pick still in the organization, but he’s struggled to make it back from Tommy John surgery and it’s doubtful he’ll reach the majors.  Dykstra, the 2008 first-rounder, was traded to the Mets for reliever Eddie Kunz this spring in a swap of disappointments.

Now it’s probably not fair to write Tate off just yet; he still has plenty of tools.  However, he’s been troubled by injuries since the day he signed, and the drug issues only make him more of a long shot.  He’s just 20, so he has plenty of time to turn it around.  Little so far has been encouraging, though.

As for the picks since 2009, well, Karsten Whitson has a chance to be a big-time pitcher.  Unfortunately, he didn’t sign after the Padres took him ninth overall last year.  He’ll be starting for the University of Florida tonight in the College World Series.

The Padres’ compensation pick for not signing Whitson was second baseman Cory Spangenberg, but Spangenberg looked like a big reach with the 10th pick in this year’s draft.  The Padres’ other 2011 first-rounder, high school right-hander Joe Ross, seems like a better bet.  Still, he’s a few years away in a best-case scenario.

  1. whitneymuse - Jun 28, 2011 at 8:39 PM

    In a smaller market city, your draft picks have to be winners to fill the seats; it’s infectious when they do win, even non padres fans become fans around the fourth of July.

  2. pisano - Jun 29, 2011 at 12:05 AM

    What the hells the difference if he’s a bust or a superstar the Padres will trade him away because they don’t want to pay anyone the going rate for the good ones. Does Adrian Gonzalez ring a bell?

    • tomemos - Jun 29, 2011 at 10:15 AM

      They didn’t draft Adrian Gonzalez.

  3. kmgannon - Jun 29, 2011 at 12:11 AM

    Wow–that is an impressive list of swings and misses. The draft may be a crapshoot, but you have to do better than that…

  4. simon94022 - Jun 29, 2011 at 1:05 AM

    None of this would have happened if the Padres hadn’t abandoned their distinctive brown-and-gold color scheme and adopted boring blue instead.

    Curse!

  5. foreverchipper10 - Jun 29, 2011 at 10:51 AM

    The Spangenburg kid lives about 20 minutes from me and there were a few write-ups in the paper after the draft abotu him. I would be lying if I said I knew who he was before then.

Leave Comment

You must be logged in to leave a comment. Not a member? Register now!

Featured video

Pitching vs. history in NL wild card game
Top 10 MLB Player Searches
  1. D. Jeter (3416)
  2. C. Kershaw (2598)
  3. R. Martin (2507)
  4. A. Rodriguez (2166)
  5. D. Gordon (1999)
  1. J. Altuve (1969)
  2. J. Hamilton (1944)
  3. I. Suzuki (1752)
  4. D. Ortiz (1730)
  5. E. Volquez (1704)