Skip to content

All-snubs All-Star team led by Paul Konerko, Andrew McCutchen

Jul 3, 2011, 1:28 PM EDT

Paul Konerko Getty Images

A lineup of shoulda-been All-Stars:

Catcher – Miguel Montero (Diamondbacks): The AL found room for three catchers, while the NL had just two.  It really should have been the other way around.  While it would have been just fine for the AL to leave either Russell Martin or Matt Wieters off the team, the NL had three deserving choices in Brian McCann, Yadier Molina and Montero.  Montero has hit .270/.344/.457 with nine homers and 40 RBI this season.  McCann and AL starter Alex Avila are the only catchers with more RBI.

First base – Paul Konerko (White Sox), Mark Teixeira (Yankees): Blame a system that’s gotten too structured; the AL had to take a second actual DH in Michael Young and still carry backups at every infield position.  If manager Ron Washington had a free hand to simply make Young the backup at second or even a utilityman, then there would have been room for Konerko. Even so, it’s rather absurd that the AL team is carrying three catchers, seven outfielders and just two (Adrian Gonzalez and Miguel Cabrera) from a bumper crop of first basemen.  At least Konerko should win the Final Vote.

Second base – Dustin Pedroia (Red Sox): No big complaints here; only four second basemen were chosen and they were arguably the four most deserving in Robinson Cano and Howie Kendrick in the AL and Rickie Weeks and Brandon Phillips in the NL.  Pedroia, now that he’s found his stroke, certainly could have been taken over Kendrick.  However, as a result of Pedroia’s slow start, Kendrick does have the better OPS of the two by 40 points.

Third base – Kevin Youkilis (Red Sox): I was just happy to see Chipper Jones make it as an NL reserve, though the suddenly red hot Aramis Ramirez may have been more deserving.  Adrian Beltre was picked over Youkilis to back up Alex Rodriguez in the AL even though Youkilis has the better OPS by 100 points.  Still, Beltre is the superior defender and he was one of the AL’s 10-best players last year.

Shortstop – Jhonny Peralta (Tigers): If it were my call, the AL roster would have had three first basemen, three shortstops, two catchers and six outfielders.  Peralta, not Asdrubal Cabrera, has been the league’s best offensive shortstop, having hit .311/.359/.538 with 14 homers this season.  I’d still have taken Cabrera first because of his defense, but both deserved to go.

Outfield – Andrew McCutchen (Pirates), Shane Victorino (Phillies), Alex Gordon (Royals): Now this might be the biggest All-Star mystery of all; the NL is carrying eight outfielders, only one of whom (Matt Kemp) actually plays center field.  McCautchen, who is hitting .289/.390/.493 with 12 homers and 15 stolen bases and is the best player on one of the game’s biggest surprises, didn’t even make the Final Vote ballot for some bizarre reason.  Victorino did.  He’s been just as productive as McCutchen, though in 14 fewer games.  Gordon, who is hitting .301/.368/.491, had a fair case on merit alone and should have been the Royals rep over reliever Aaron Crow.

Pitcher: CC Sabathia (Yankees), Tommy Hanson (Braves), Anibal Sanchez (Marlins), Michael Pineda (Mariners), Dan Haren (Angels), Jordan Zimmermann (Nationals), Francisco Cordero (Reds): Incredibly enough, I’m pretty much fine with the pitchers selected.  I don’t get why Ron Washington didn’t take Sabathia, who is due to pitch the Sunday before the All-Star Game, and then just go ahead and replace him later.  That’s expected to happen with Justin Verlander, Felix Hernandez and James Shields, so Pineda and Haren still might make the team.  In the NL, Bruce Bochy’s selection of Ryan Vogelsong was controversial.  Vogelsong has been a terrific story, though, and I can’t say I’m too upset to see him go.

  1. jetsguy1117 - Jul 3, 2011 at 1:45 PM

    peralta having a better offensive season than asdrubel? well, its good to know that we no longer count stolen bases as ‘offensive’ production.

    nor do we consider that peralta hits 6th behind a loaded detroit offense (the perfect recipe for rbi production) whereas asdrubel IS the the loaded offense in cleveland.

    not a knock on peralta – but come on – anyone who watched al central games knows cabrera is having, positions aside, one of the best seasons in baseball and the contest between him and peralta isnt even close

    • paperlions - Jul 3, 2011 at 1:53 PM

      Peralta has a higher OBP, higher slugging, higher wOBA, and higher OPS+ (taking park effects into account). 12 SB are nice, but don’t come anywhere close to making up for the deficits in power and not-out-making.

      • Ari Collins - Jul 3, 2011 at 3:34 PM

        And wOBA counts SBs.

  2. slyordie - Jul 3, 2011 at 2:08 PM

    Chase Headley even got snubbed here. Leads NL 3rd basemen in BA, OBP, OPS. But I’m a Padre fan I’m used to it.

    • icanspeel - Jul 3, 2011 at 8:36 PM

      Yup and I think Mike Adams got snubbed too.. In fact I think he deserved it more than Heath Bell. Bell gets the glamor since he saves the games, but Mike Adams has been lights out this year.

  3. Ari Collins - Jul 3, 2011 at 3:42 PM

    When you factor in defense, Pedroia far surpasses Cano and slightly surpasses Kendrick.

    But a lot of the voting was early, when Pedroia was struggling.

    Democracy would be great if it weren’t for all the voters.

  4. fatcatt - Jul 3, 2011 at 10:10 PM

    CC or probably Pineda deserved to go instead of Felix who has been less than impressive this year..Hanson should’ve went over Vogel and that was a biased pick. Why aren’t the best pitchers who have to pitch Sunday just skipped over in their starts and sent to the All Star game. Verlander should be there. Theres no reason these teams cant find a substitute starter for these guys. It happens all season when the pitching order needs to be tweeked for different reasons..

Leave Comment

You must be logged in to leave a comment. Not a member? Register now!

Top 10 MLB Player Searches
  1. B. Crawford (2770)
  2. Y. Puig (2442)
  3. C. Correa (2431)
  4. G. Stanton (2384)
  5. G. Springer (2294)
  1. H. Pence (2218)
  2. J. Hamilton (2110)
  3. M. Teixeira (1902)
  4. H. Ramirez (1898)
  5. J. Fernandez (1869)