Skip to content

Where will Derek Jeter finish on the all-time hits list?

Jul 9, 2011, 5:38 PM EDT

Derek Jeter Getty Images

Upon reaching the milestone Saturday, Derek Jeter became the fourth youngest player to collect 3,000 hits, doing so just a couple of weeks after his 37th birthday on June 26.

Ty Cobb got there at age 34.  Hank Aaron and Robin Yount were 36.  Pete Rose was just a week older than Jeter when he did it.

And, of course, Rose and Cobb are the only members of the 4,000-hit club.  Rose ended his career with 4,256.  Cobb finished at 4,189.  Next on the list is Aaron at 3,771.

So, where will Jeter stand on the all-time list when he’s finished?  He’s currently 27th after overtaking Roberto Clemente, who died having collected exactly 3,000 hits.  With his 5-for-5 day pushing him up to 3,003 hits, he’s just four hits behind Al Kaline for 26th place.

Jeter has 2 1/2 years to go on the three-year, $51 million contract he signed to remain with the Yankees last winter.  Over the last 2 1/2 years, he has 461 hits.  That, however, is going to be a hard total to match over the remainder of his contract.

So, let’s figure it out.

The Yankees have 74 games left this season.  Let’s say Jeter plays in 68 of them.  Jeter has averaged 1.27 hits per game over the course of his career, but only 1.16 this season.  I’ll split the difference and give him 1.21 hits per game over the rest of the season.

That gives Jeter 82 more hits and puts him at 3,085 entering 2012.

From there, who really knows?  Some Yankees fans have talked about wanting Jeter to retire after the season because of his diminished production.  No one really thinks that’s going to happen, though.  Jeter is almost certainly going to be the Yankees’ regular shortstop again next season.  It may well be for the best if he slides down to the bottom of the lineup, at least against right-handers.  However, if Jeter stays healthy, he’s going to rack up at least another 150 hits next year.

After that, maybe a reduced role will be in store for 2013.  And depending on how he handles the adjustment, he could retire after the season or remain with the Yankees as a part-timer.

Time for some numbers.  Here’s what I’m thinking.

First, a look at the last four seasons:

2008: 179 H in 150 G – 1.19 H/G
2009: 212 H in 153 G – 1.39 H/G
2010: 179 H in 157 G – 1.14 H/G
2011: 77 H in 67 G – 1.15 H/B

And now my remainder of career of projection:

2011: 82 H in 68 G – 1.21 H/G
2012: 157 H in 140 G – 1.12 H/G
2013: 131 H in 125 G – 1.05 H/G

That would put him at 3,373 hits for his career, placing him ninth all-time between Carl Yastrzemski at 3,419 and Paul Molitor at 3,319.

And that sounds about right to me.  Jeter isn’t likely to hang on like Rose did.  Retiring at 39 as MLB’s ninth-leading hitter seems pretty appropriate.

But how about one more projection. Let’s say Jeter rebounds next year, and the Yankees decide that while he’s probably not a shortstop anymore, he still needs to be an everyday player in 2013, whether it’s in the outfield or at third base (with Alex Rodriguez at DH). He adjusts well, hits about .300 and gets a two-year deal that keeps him in pinstripes through 2015. So here’s the optimistic projection:

2011: 82 H in 68 G – 1.21 H/G
2012: 183 H in 150 G – 1.22 H/G
2013: 171 H in 145 G – 1.18 H/G
2014: 161 H in 140 G – 1.15 H/G
2015: 135 H in 125 G – 1.08 H/G

That would give Jeter 3,735 hits through age 41. Rose and Cobb still appear way out of reach, but he’d be just 36 hits behind Aaron for third all-time. I’d say it’s a long shot, but it’s not so difficult to imagine.

1. Rose – 4,256
2. Cobb – 4,189
3. Aaron – 3,771
4. Jeter – 3,735

  1. yankeesfanlen - Jul 9, 2011 at 5:54 PM

    I’d be happy if he got to Yaz territory without histrionics.

  2. yankeesgameday - Jul 9, 2011 at 5:54 PM

    So if e equals mc squared and it takes 1.21 gigahertz to operate the flux capacitor only if the sun remains a constant 93 million miles from earth and the secret of the pyramids is 3.1456 Jeter will be the all time hits leader at the end of the Maya Calendar

    • yankeesgameday - Jul 9, 2011 at 8:16 PM

      Really? 13 thumbs down? I referenced 2 movies, Einstein and a cultural touchstone all very satirically. and 13 thumbs down? geez, unforgiving crowd today.

  3. takethedtrain - Jul 9, 2011 at 6:22 PM

    No one will ever touch Rose’s record. Just not possible no matter what math you use. And Rose didn’t “hang on”. He kicked ass year after year. Look at the record books – they don’t lie. (Too bad he blew it all through his idiotic off-field choices. . .)

    • aceshigh11 - Jul 9, 2011 at 7:04 PM

      Oh, he most certainly did hang on.

      Look at his last couple of seasons…he was CLEARLY only playing to break the record. He had very little to offer as a player in ’85 and ’86, in his mid-40s.

      I’m not knocking him…he HAD come all that way thus far, so why not try for the record?

      BUT “hanging on” describes Pete Rose in those days perfectly.

  4. samoanjungle - Jul 10, 2011 at 1:18 PM

    Not to pick but Cobb had 4191 didn’t he? Rose broke the record at 4192.

    • Matthew Pouliot - Jul 10, 2011 at 1:43 PM

      It was believed Cobb had 4,191 back then, and that’s still the official number. The current belief is that he finished with 4,189.

Leave Comment

You must be logged in to leave a comment. Not a member? Register now!

Featured video

Alex Gordon, MVP candidate
Top 10 MLB Player Searches
  1. R. Castillo (5001)
  2. Y. Molina (2972)
  3. J. Soler (2831)
  4. D. Ortiz (2674)
  5. B. Colon (2223)
  1. M. Cuddyer (2179)
  2. D. Wright (2144)
  3. M. Machado (2124)
  4. B. Posey (2119)
  5. Y. Darvish (2103)