Aug 18, 2011, 2:30 PM EST
Pay no attention to the mutual option behind the curtain. From the day it was dreamed up, it had virtually no chance of being exercised. What were the odds that both team and player thought said player would be worth exactly $4 million in 2012?
On Thursday, the Royals and Jeff Francoeur both decided the 27-year-old outfielder was worth well more than that. They agreed to a two-year, $13.5 million extension that locked up the former Brave through 2013.
The dollar amount figures to cause a great deal of hand-wringing. Francoeur is a polarizing player with his popularity and athleticism and occasional offensive outbursts never completely obscuring the fact that he’s a career .269/.312/.430 hitter.
This year, Francoeur has been considerably better. Playing for his fourth team, he’s hit .277/.329/.463 with 15 homers and 66 RBI. He’s also set a career high with 19 steals, nearly matching his total of 23 from his first 5 1/2 years in the bigs. He’s still made more outs than all but seven American Leaguers, but he rates as an above average offensive corner outfielder for the first time since his rookie half-season of 2005.
One very important thing to remember here is that Francoeur is just 27. He should have a few more prime years in front of him. Since he’s 27 and not 30, it’s more likely that his 2011 performance represents real growth.
But this is also Jeff Francoeur we’re talking about. He always talks a good game. Every spring, he talks about how his plate discipline is going to improve. And it usually does for a few weeks in March and the first week in April before he goes back to hacking away. Francoeur has walked 34 times versus 94 strikeouts this season. He’s on pace to break his previous career high of 42 walks. However, he’s already used 462 at-bats in getting 34, so discipline remains a big issue.
Also, Francoeur has truly been above average only the quarter of the time he gets to face left-handers. He’s batting .315/.379/.602 against southpaws this year, compared to .266/.314/.421 against righties.
Now, that .735 OPS against righties this year isn’t bad at all. But a little bit of overall regression would be enough to turn him back into a liability against the majority of major league pitchers. For his career, Francoeur has an .841 OPS against lefties and a .704 OPS against righties.
That’s where the deal falls apart for me. Even this new and improved Francoeur wouldn’t be anything more than the sixth- or seventh-best regular on a contender, and there’s a realistic chance that the Royals would be better off with Lorenzo Cain in center and Melky Cabrera in right next year than with Cabrera in center and Francoeur in right.
On the plus side, the $13.5 million won’t kill the Royals. They’ve lopped enough off their payroll over the last year that $6.75 million per year will be pretty easily absorbed, and while it may cut into the budget a bit, spending that kind of cash on such a well-liked player could actually make them a more attractive destination in free agency this winter. They just need to target better players than Francoeur next time they open their wallets.
- Mets sign 40-year-old Bartolo Colon for two years, $20 million 20
- MLB rules committee decides to eliminate collisions at home plate 29
- Mariners sign Corey Hart to incentive-laden deal 27
- David Price would not consider an extension with the Mariners if he’s traded there 33
- Media paying for athlete interviews? Not likely. But watch this stuff closely anyway. 20
- Robinson Cano agrees to $240 million deal with Mariners (260)
- Report: Mariners willing to offer Robinson Cano a 10-year, $240 million deal (143)
- Report: Yankees have agreed to a three-year deal with Carlos Beltran (125)
- Brett Gardner is drawing “significant” trade interest (113)
- Managers, GMs to meet today to discuss the abolition of home plate collisions (113)