Aug 30, 2011, 2:55 PM EDT
Yesterday, I posted an entry dismissing Jordan Walden as an American League Rookie of the Year candidate without really looking at the race as a whole. So, let’s do that this time around.
Here are how the candidates rank according to Baseball-Reference’s WAR:
1. Jeremy Hellickson: 2.7
2. Michael Pineda: 2.6
3. Desmond Jennings: 2.5
4. Dustin Ackley: 2.3
4. Aaron Crow: 2.3
6. Mark Trumbo: 2.1
7. Ivan Nova: 1.9
7. Greg Holland: 1.9
7. Chris Sale: 1.9
10. Jordan Walden: 1.8
11. Vinnie Pestano: 1.7
12. Casper Wells: 1.6
13. Josh Reddick: 1.5
14. Mike Carp: 1.2
14. Al Alburquerque: 1.2
16. Zach Britton: 1.0
17. J.P. Arencibia: 0.9
17. Jemile Weeks: 0.9
And according to Fangraphs’ WAR:
1. Michael Pineda: 2.9
2. Dustin Ackley: 2.5
3. Desmond Jennings: 2.3
4. Mark Trumbo: 2.2
5. Zach Britton: 2.1
6. Ivan Nova: 1.9
7. Josh Reddick: 1.8
7. Jordan Walden: 1.8
9. Jeremy Hellickson: 1.6
9. Ben Revere: 1.6
11. Casper Wells: 1.5
11. Greg Holland: 1.5
13. J.P. Arencibia: 1.3
13. Jemile Weeks: 1.3
13. Vinnie Pestano: 1.3
There are some big disparities there, particularly in how Fangraphs views Hellickson vs. Pineda. Hellickson has a 3.01 ERA in 149 1/3 innings, while Pineda has a 3.71 ERA in 153 innings, but Pineda has the much stronger peripherals. Since Fangraphs goes off FIP, instead of ERA, it rates Pineda as the far superior pitcher.
Fangraphs also says Walden has been the most valuable reliever because his innings have come in higher leverage. B-Ref’s WAR doesn’t really care that Walden is pitching the ninth, while guys like Crow, Pestano and Sale have mostly been tasked with the seventh and eighth innings.
Personally, I’m more on B-Ref’s side of the argument in both of these cases. Yes, Pineda has better peripherals than Hellickson. However, I don’t think the Rays’ defense is much better than Seattle’s. Plus, Hellickson has faced the tougher schedule. Hellickson has been lucky to strand 81 percent of the runners to reach against him, but that luck has translated into real results for the Rays. I think he’s the class of the pitching rookies, at least to date.
Things are also complicated with the hitters. Trumbo has been a bit above average all year, Ackley has been more than a bit above average since his callup June 16 and Jennings has been nothing short of fabulous since his callup July 27.
Ackley and Jennings have already overtaken Trumbo in value according to both versions of WAR, and I’m not going to argue against it. Still, I think there’s a lot to be said for the Rookie of the Year actually having contributed for the entire year.
Regardless, Ackley doesn’t have a shot at the real award. While his .831 OPS is excellent for a second baseman playing in Safeco, his triple crown line is .291-5-30 and that’s simply not going to get it done. Jennings is likely a big long shot, too. He’ll have played in a maximum of 64 games this year.
Trumbo, meanwhile, is poised to finish with 27-30 homers and around 90 RBI. His .296 OBP is unacceptable, and I’m not optimistic about him for the long haul. However, he’s been an asset for the Angels from day one this year.
So, my (non-existent) Rookie of the Year ballot would have to go Hellickson-Pineda-Trumbo at the moment. However, I was too quick to dismiss the alternatives Monday and the race is definitely close enough for things to change in September.
- AL All-Star voting update: now “only” five Royals in the starting lineup 56
- Andy MacPhail introduced by the Phillies. And the first topic of conversation is sabermetrics 16
- What a world: Orioles are in first place and Ubaldo Jimenez has been their ace 16
- Settling the Scores: Sunday’s results 98
- Steven Matz stellar on the mound — and at the plate — in his major league debut for the Mets 19
- The 2015 Gillette Home Run Derby will have a new format 32
- Meet the Matz! The Mets call up Steven Matz to make his MLB debut 11
- Settling the Scores: Saturday’s results 23
- With the same-sex marriage decision, the San Francisco Giants get another big win (275)
- Joe Maddon is the latest manager to rip instant replay. He’s got a point. (108)
- Settling the Scores: Sunday’s results (98)
- And That Happened: Monday’s scores and highlights (79)
- There was a super ump show in Chicago yesterday (75)