Skip to content

Running down the rosters: Oakland Athletics

Feb 9, 2012, 6:12 PM EDT

Kurt Suzuki, Brandon McCarthy AP

At least to the outside eye, it seems like the A’s have lacked a plan since they shipped off Matt Holliday after 93 games in 2009. It finally appeared that they were going for a full rebuild this winter, but after trading Trevor Cahill, Andrew Bailey and Gio Gonzalez, they re-signed Coco Crisp for $14 million, added Bartolo Colon, Seth Smith and Jonny Gomes and flirted with over-the-hill designated hitters like Manny Ramirez and Magglio Ordonez. The drive for 75 wins appears on.

Brandon McCarthy – R
Bartolo Colon – R
Tom Milone – L
Tyson Ross – R
Graham Godfrey – R

Grant Balfour – R
Brian Fuentes – L
Fautino De Los Santos – R
Joey Devine – R
Jerry Blevins – L
Ryan Cook – R
Jordan Norberto – L

Disabled list: Brett Anderson (L), Dallas Braden (L)
SP next in line: Jarrod Parker (R), Brad Peacock (R), Sonny Gray (R)
RP next in line: Neil Wagner (R), Andrew Carignan (R), Travis Schlichting (L), Edgar Gonzalez (R), Evan Scribner (R)

Not only did the A’s shed Cahill and Gonzalez, but they traded two more guys who would have fit into their projected rotation for a platoon outfielder in Smith. It wasn’t necessarily a bad move — I like Josh Outman, but I doubt Guillermo Moscoso would have remained an asset as a starter — but it’s left the A’s without any experienced depth here.

I penciled in Ross and Godfrey at the bottom of the rotation, but Parker and Peacock should have opportunities to win jobs. The A’s might be better off with Ross in the bullpen anyway.

The A’s figure to add a reliever or two prior to Opening Day. There isn’t much left in free agency now, but there should be some intriguing out-of-options arms available before the end of March.

2B Jemile Weeks – S
CF Coco Crisp – S
LF Seth Smith – L
C Kurt Suzuki – R
RF Josh Reddick – L
3B Scott Sizemore – R
DH Brandon Allen – L
1B Daric Barton – L
SS Cliff Pennington – S

C Landon Powell – R
INF Adam Rosales – R
OF Jonny Gomes – R
OF Collin Cowgill – R

Next in line: C Josh Donaldson (R), C Anthony Recker (R), 1B Kila Ka’aihue (L), 1B Chris Carter (R), INF Eric Sogard (L), OF Jermaine Mitchell (L), OF Michael Taylor (R), OF Jason Pridie (L)

I think it’s probably best for the A’s to stick with what they have now and try to figure out if Barton and Allen belong in their long-term plans. Still, it’s not hard to see why they’d want to have a Manny Ramirez in there. Putting a strong right-handed hitter in the cleanup spot would make the whole lineup look better. Suzuki could then hit sixth, with Sizemore in the eighth spot.

The only position battle in the starting lineup should be at DH, though a bad spring from Barton could open up first base. Barring an addition, Allen will compete with Gomes, Ka’aihue and Carter at DH. Gomes will certainly play against lefties, and that should be good enough for him. Gowgill should also start against lefties in place of Smith or Reddick.

The backup catcher gig is up for grabs, with Donaldson and Recker challenging Powell, who was bumped off the 40-man roster earlier this winter.

I’d like to see Sogard get a chance to overtake Rosales for the utility infield spot, but I’m not sure that will happen on day one.

  1. dw3dw - Feb 9, 2012 at 6:20 PM

    Last year at this time some pundits were picking the A’s as a dark horse in the division, with Willingham and Matsui adding just enough offense to back the great pitching. Holliday was similarly supposed to push them over the edge. Now the plan is to contend when (if) the new stadium opens.

  2. sjsharksfan11 - Feb 9, 2012 at 8:11 PM

    This team SUCKS. 100 losses or more guaranteed.

    • atmrover - Feb 10, 2012 at 2:11 AM

      Yes I agree, I expect the A’s to lose 100+ games because they traded away all their good players – especially pitchers – and did not resign Willingham. Their pitching will be bad; their offense will be awful; and their defense will probably suck as well, uggh ..

  3. Ari Collins - Feb 9, 2012 at 9:51 PM

    Looks like the Astros, but at least they have a good farm system. Parker should be another very good young As pitcher, though of course if they don’t move to their new digs fast enough they’ll just trade him when he stops making minimum wage.

  4. atmrover - Feb 15, 2012 at 2:01 AM

    Bartolo Colon is fat and over the hill. Sogard and Rosales are mediocre players, IMHO – can field Ok but, like the rest of the A’s Roster, cannot hit worth a darn. Barton has no power, didn’t hit a single home run last year, that I can remember – which as you know, is swell for first base, which is supposed to be a power position. Scott Sizemore is decent at third base, he was a pleasant surprise last year – has occasional pop in his bat, too. Brandon Allen at DH, huh? Where did he come from? Josh Reddick in RF, Seth Smith in LF, it’s going to be fun (not!). Hmm, a LOoong summer ahead, get ready for some heartache and boredom, A’s fans! Only positive I’ve seen in all this? Maybe it means the A’s are really serious about moving to San Jose in the South Bay, whoopee ..

Leave Comment

You must be logged in to leave a comment. Not a member? Register now!

Top 10 MLB Player Searches
  1. G. Stanton (2767)
  2. G. Springer (2658)
  3. H. Ramirez (2655)
  4. C. Correa (2650)
  5. B. Crawford (2465)
  1. M. Teixeira (2421)
  2. H. Pence (2386)
  3. J. Baez (2340)
  4. J. Hamilton (2272)
  5. Y. Puig (2260)