Skip to content

Running down the rosters: Cleveland Indians

Feb 18, 2012, 5:04 PM EDT

Carlos Santana, Chris Perez

Even after giving up their top two pitching prospects for Ubaldo Jimenez, the Indians couldn’t maintain their hot start last year and lost their last four games to finish under .500 at 80-82. The offseason saw them shopping from the scrap heap, which isn’t unusual, but even as they were forced to pick from largely unwanted players, they did well with what they had. Unfortunately for them, they couldn’t answer when the team that finished 15 games ahead of them last year added Prince Fielder.

Ubaldo Jimenez – R
Justin Masterson – R
Derek Lowe – R
Josh Tomlin – R
Kevin Slowey – R

Chris Perez – R
Vinnie Pestano – R
Tony Sipp – L
Joe Smith – R
Rafael Perez – L
Dan Wheeler – R
Frank Herrmann – R

Disabled list: Carlos Carrasco (R)
Restricted list: ex-Fausto Carmona (R)
SP next in line: David Huff (L), Jeanmar Gomez (R), Zach McAllister (R)
RP next in line: Nick Hagadone (L), Chris Ray (R), Jeremy Accardo (R), Robinson Tejeda (R)

The addition of Lowe from Atlanta was supposed to give the Indians the most groundball-focused rotation the league has seen in years. The Fausto Carmona situation, however, has taken some of the wind out of those sails, especially since it looks like he’ll be replaced by Slowey, one of the league’s top flyball pitchers. I don’t necessarily think that’s a downgrade, though. In fact, I’m not sure the Indians’ original strategy was such a good idea; they play in a pitcher’s park and their outfield defense figures to be quite a bit better than their infield defense.

The bullpen has two openings, with Herrmann and Hagadone competing against a host of veterans on minor league deals. I’m nervous about Perez in the closer’s role — his velocity is down a bit and his strikeout rate took a big tumble last year — but Pestano rates as maybe the game’s best reliever no one knows about. He can step in if Perez struggles.

CF Grady Sizemore – L
SS Asdrubal Cabrera – S
RF Shin-Soo Choo – L
C Carlos Santana – S
DH Travis Hafner – L
2B Jason Kipnis – L
1B Casey Kotchman – L
3B Jack Hannahan – L
LF Michael Brantley – L

C Lou Marson – R
INF Jason Donald – R
1B/OF Shelley Duncan – R
OF Ryan Spilborghs – R

Next in line: C Matt Pagnozzi (R), 1B Matt LaPorta (R), 1B-3B Russ Canzler (R), 2B Cord Phelps (S), 2B-3B Jose Lopez (R), 3B Lonnie Chisenhall (L), 3B Andy LaRoche (L),
OF Aaron Cunningham (R), OF Ezequiel Carrera (L), OF Felix Pie (L), OF Fred Lewis (L), OF Trevor Crowe (S)

And then there’s the lineup. After re-signing Sizemore and bringing in Kotchman to start over LaPorta, the Indians will be able to go with nine left-handed hitters against right-handed pitching. Of course, things will get dicey against lefties. I think Cleveland might have been better off moving Brantley to center and adding a right-handed bat in Sizemore’s place.

That said, the Indians do deserve a ton of credit for bringing in the winter’s greatest haul in minor league free agency. That “next in line” group is probably the strongest any team can boast, and it gives the Indians plenty of bench options.

My controversial call above is sticking Chisenhall back in the minors. I didn’t want to do it, but the bench works much better that way. A right-handed-hitting backup infielder is a must, whether it’s Donald or Lopez. Hannahan, as a lefty, would be pretty useless as a reserve, but the Indians appear unlikely to cut him after re-upping him for $1.35 million last month. My preference would be for a Hannahan trade, leaving Chisenhall as the starter at third.

The Indians’ chances in 2012 figure to hinge on return to forms from Sizemore, Choo and Jimenez. If two of the three former All-Stars contend for a return to this year’s Midsummer Classic, then the Indians should be capable of winning 90 games and hanging in the playoff race.

  1. hbdbrowns33 - Feb 18, 2012 at 5:21 PM

    Its a lot of “ifs” but it should be fun to watch good or bad. Roll Tribe

  2. jason1214 - Feb 18, 2012 at 5:49 PM

    Well call me nuts, but I would’ve also let Sizemore walk, moved Brantley to Center. Not re-upped Hannahan, started Chisenhall @ 3rd and gone with LaPorta or others in LF. Indians have too many punch & judy LH hitters.

  3. stairwayto7 - Feb 18, 2012 at 10:47 PM

    Indians finish at least 20 games out of 1st..maybe 30!

  4. bigtrav425 - Feb 19, 2012 at 8:42 AM

    As a Tribe fan i am embarrassed and well have been fora few yrs now because of ownership/front office…Bringing back Sizemore was a mistake.Tribes Brass have been obsessed with this guy since day one for some reason.He was/is overrated. he is a 5 hole hitter with speed not leadoff.Brantley should be CF/leading off…i mean i can go on and on..unless everything turns out perfect we will finish in 3rd place…

    • dnc6 - Feb 19, 2012 at 3:27 PM

      The Indians should have signed Sizemore for the same reason Oakland signed Cespedes. There’s no other way for a team in that market size to get that kind of upside. Yeah, its a big risk, but there’s no way they can outbid the Yankees/Sox/etc for premium talent. The alternative to Sizemore isn’t something you would have wanted to see.

      It’s going to boil down to health again for the Indians. If it’s only Sizemore and Hafner (and those two are certainly going to miss time) then they have a pretty good chance.

  5. Pierre Cruzatte - Feb 19, 2012 at 10:14 AM

    The Jon Garland pickup must have slipped in under your radar. Most people have him contending with Slowey for #5.

Leave Comment

You must be logged in to leave a comment. Not a member? Register now!

Top 10 MLB Player Searches
  1. C. Correa (2550)
  2. G. Stanton (2498)
  3. H. Ramirez (2483)
  4. G. Springer (2480)
  5. B. Crawford (2298)
  1. M. Teixeira (2280)
  2. H. Pence (2206)
  3. J. Baez (2203)
  4. J. Hamilton (2160)
  5. Y. Puig (2104)