Skip to content

Can Jesus Montero catch? He’s motivated to show he can

Feb 28, 2012, 11:42 PM EDT


PEORIA, Ariz. – There are some who say Jesus Montero will never be a quality major league catcher.

Analysts who rush to praise his quick, powerful bat are equally quick to pan his defensive skills. His receiving is poor, his footwork worse, they say. He’s too big (6-3, 235), and not athletic enough to play the position. His arm, while strong, takes too long to release the ball. It goes on and on, and there are numbers to back it up, as he has thrown out only 21 percent of base-stealers over the course of five minor leagues seasons.

Montero, the 22-year-old Venezuelan who the Seattle Mariners acquired from the New York Yankees in exchange for pitcher Michael Pineda, has heard the criticisms. He understands it, but he’s not buying into it. Montero says he’s been catching since he was 4 years old, and he’s certainly not ready to change positions. He loves the challenges that come from the position, the ability to control the game from behind the dish, to help his pitcher through the rough spots. He’s eager to prove his critics wrong, to show that he can be that rare breed of catcher that is equally proficient behind the plate as he is in the batter’s box.

“Most catchers don’t hit but they control the game, they know how to catch,” Montero said on Tuesday in the Mariners clubhouse. “Sometimes you have to give something away so you can catch or you can hit. But if you can do all that together you can be amazing like (Jorge) Posada, you know?”

(Listen to Montero talk about his desire to prove his doubters wrong) 

Montero draws inspiration from Posada, his former Yankees teammate who retired this offseason after 17 years in New York. Posada was never known as a great defensive catcher, but he was good enough to log 1,574 games there for the Yankees, more than 86 percent of his starts.

“If I see a big example in front of my face, it was Posada,” he said. “I want to be like him. We were together a lot. He taught me a lot.”

Montero projects to be an even better hitter than Posada, but what about the defense? Can he become good enough at the position to make the Mariners comfortable keeping him there? It’s certainly worth a try, as big-hitting catchers are hard to find. The Mariners acknowledge that Montero has some work to do to become proficient defensively, but they’re working hard to do just that.

“He’s a talented young man and we’re very happy to have him,” said third base coach Jeff Datz, who is also charged with working with Mariners catchers. “There is work to be done with him, as with all our other catchers. We like his size, we like the body, and there’s arm strength there, obviously a lot of ability to work with. Yes, he needs some cleaning up in certain areas, and we’re going through that process right now with him and with our other catchers.”

Montero is expected to be primarily a DH this season, spelling starting catcher Miguel Olivo behind the plate for 20-40 games. Olivo, for his part, preaches patience, pointing out that he also reached the big leagues in his early 20s and admitting that it took him “2 ½-3 years to really realize what I need to do behind the plate.”

 (Listen to Miguel Olivo talk about what Montero must do to improve)


“He’s young and he can hit already. That’s not a problem,” Olivo said. “He needs to get better at receiving and blocking, and communicate more with the pitchers. It takes time, though. I had the same problems. … That’s the thing he needs to go through now. Maybe a couple years, one year and he’ll be ready to do it.”

Montero said he’s ready for the challenge. He speaks calmly and confidently. He doesn’t seem upset by his critics, but admits that they motivate him.

“I just want to get more opportunities to catch and show everybody that I can catch,” he said. “I did it in Triple-A. I hope I can do it here, too, to help my pitchers like I did in the minors. I’m gonna work hard day-by-day to help my team. That’s it.”

You can follow Bob on Twitter here, or if Facebook is your thing, be his friend here.

  1. aaronmoreno - Feb 29, 2012 at 1:20 AM

    That’s great that he’s motivated, but he won’t catch.

    • cur68 - Feb 29, 2012 at 3:19 AM

      Leave Jesus alone.

  2. uyf1950 - Feb 29, 2012 at 5:39 AM

    I wish him luck and I hope he has success as a catcher. Because I think now that he’s out in Seattle playing at spacious Safeco Park his offense/power will probably suffer a bit. But, good luck to him.

    • proudlycanadian - Feb 29, 2012 at 6:59 AM

      I wish him luck also, although when he was a Yankee prospect, many NY fans thought that he walked on water. He would be an interesting pick as a catcher in a fantasy league.

    • churchoftheperpetuallyoutraged - Feb 29, 2012 at 8:41 AM

      Dave Cameron at Fangraphs has mentioned numerous times that Safeco’s power alley is Right-Center, so it shouldn’t hurt Montero much as he’s got a ton of opposite field power. Safeco is death to righty pull hitters like Adrian Beltre.

  3. rob0527 - Feb 29, 2012 at 6:29 AM

    Good luck Jesus. If u couldn’t throw out minor league runners what makes him think he could throw out major league runners. Maybe good back up catcher, but bat will keep him in line up every day.

  4. paperlions - Feb 29, 2012 at 10:15 AM

    So….the guy has been catching since he was 4, and he still sucks at it? Pretty much every scouting report tears apart every single aspect of his attempt to play the position.

    I’m sure plenty of guys are motivated to throw 95 MPH, have great control and breaking pitches, walk more, strike out less, play better defense, hit with more power, etc….while the motivation is nice, it really is the talent that determines who is successful and who is not.

  5. drewsylvania - Feb 29, 2012 at 12:05 PM

    “His arm, while strong, takes too long to release the ball.”

    Oh god, it’s Tim Tebow again. At least this one’s actually named Jesus.

  6. drewsylvania - Feb 29, 2012 at 2:32 PM

    The downthumbs suggest a trend of Mariner wishcasting.

Leave Comment

You must be logged in to leave a comment. Not a member? Register now!

Top 10 MLB Player Searches
  1. C. Correa (2546)
  2. G. Stanton (2494)
  3. H. Ramirez (2476)
  4. G. Springer (2475)
  5. B. Crawford (2286)
  1. M. Teixeira (2275)
  2. H. Pence (2198)
  3. J. Baez (2198)
  4. J. Hamilton (2154)
  5. Y. Puig (2101)