Skip to content

Deadspin has a pretty controversial theory on the Braun decision

Feb 28, 2012, 8:49 AM EDT

ryan braun wide getty Getty Images

Over at Deadspin, Tommy Craggs offers a potential theory of why Ryan Braun won his arbitration, even though many believe the case against him was so strong:

Over the weekend, however, I spoke with someone familiar with the arbitration process in general. He had another theory: Ryan Braun didn’t get off because of the merits of his case; he got off because the arbitrator who cast the decisive vote in Braun’s favor—the vote with which baseball “vehemently disagrees”—was thinking about his own future.

The upshot: arbitrator Shyam Das serves at the pleasure of both the union and the league. He has ruled against players an awful lot lately, especially on drug cases, and he used the Braun case as a means to balance the scales a bit so the union wouldn’t get fed up with him and fire him from his lucrative and high-profile gig. As Craggs puts it “If ever there were a case for Das to throw to the players, it was this one.”

Possible? Well, I suppose anything is possible. But saying that an arbitrator is placing his self interest ahead of the case in front of him is an extraordinarily serious charge. One which I’d feel a lot more comfortable entertaining if it was based on something more than a theory from “someone familiar with the arbitration process in general.”  Because really, this is not terribly different from saying that a judge threw a case because he was thinking about his reelection.

Less broadly, the theory has a major problem:  if the arbitrator was really throwing this thing — a case where it seems most people who are not Ryan Braun’s legal team think MLB should have won — it’s just as likely if not more so that Major League Baseball would get angry and fire Das.  At least it’s a risk, so what would Das have to gain here by being unethical?

What would not be as risky is if Das were to make a well-reasoned decision that explains why this case, and not any others, had this particular outcome. It would satisfy the union because it would be based in reason and would have an outcome with which they were happy. It would satisfy the league, eventually anyway, because it would be based in reason, would not present a scenario that would be replicable in future appeals and would provide a road map to the league about how to fix the problem.

We’re going to get Das’ reasoning, by the way, within a few weeks, so we’ll be able to judge that for ourselves.  Until then, I’m loathe to accuse this man of violating ethical considerations in reaching the decision he reached.

Latest Posts
  1. No progress in extension talks between Reds, Johnny Cueto

    Apr 1, 2015, 10:45 PM EDT

    johnny cueto getty Getty Images

    Johnny Cueto is due to become a free agent five days after the 2015 World Series and he has said that he will not allow in-season extension negotiations. So the countdown clock is on in Cincinnati’s front office, and it sure looks like time is going to run out.

  2. Chris Sale strikes out 13 batters in minor league game

    Apr 1, 2015, 9:28 PM EDT

    chris sale getty Getty Images

    As noted by CSNChicago.com’s Dan Hayes, White Sox left-hander Chris Sale struck out 13 batters over six-plus innings of one-run ball Wednesday in a game against a group of Reds minor leaguers.

  3. Yankees acquire infielder Gregorio Petit from Astros

    Apr 1, 2015, 8:34 PM EDT

    gregorio petit getty Getty Images

    Petit batted .278/.300/.423 with eight doubles and two home runs in 100 plate appearances last season for the Astros. He wasn’t going to make their Opening Day roster this spring, but the versatile 30-year-old infielder could be of immediate use to the Yankees …

  4. Christian Vazquez to undergo Tommy John surgery

    Apr 1, 2015, 7:41 PM EDT

    christian vazquez getty Getty Images

    As first reported by Brian MacPherson of the Providence Journal, Red Sox catcher Christian Vazquez will undergo Tommy John reconstructive elbow surgery on Thursday morning.

  5. Video: Carlos Martinez goes six scoreless vs. Mets

    Apr 1, 2015, 7:07 PM EDT

    carlos martinez getty Getty Images

    Martinez wraps up the spring with a 2.86 ERA and 21 strikeouts in 22 innings. He was officially named the Cardinals’ fifth starter on Monday …

  6. Bruce Rondon scratched Wednesday with sore shoulder

    Apr 1, 2015, 6:12 PM EDT

    bruce rondon getty Getty Images

    Tigers setup man Bruce Rondon was supposed to make an appearance in Wednesday’s Cactus League game against the Padres, but he woke up with a sore shoulder and couldn’t shake the discomfort during pregame stretching.

  7. HBT Extra: It’s World Series or bust for the Washington Nationals

    Apr 1, 2015, 4:50 PM EDT

    Max Scherzer Getty Images

    Jenna and I continue to preview the divisions. Next up: the NL East.

  8. Duke ace, potential No. 1 pick Mike Matuella needs Tommy John surgery

    Apr 1, 2015, 4:26 PM EDT

    Mike Matuella Duke

    Matuella started six games this season, throwing 25 innings with a 1.08 ERA and 24 strikeouts.

  9. 2015 Preview: Colorado Rockies

    Apr 1, 2015, 4:15 PM EDT

    Colorado Rockies spring training in Scottsdale Getty Images

    With a new GM and questions surrounding the futures of Troy Tulowitzki and Carlos Gonzalez, where are the Rockies headed?

  10. Video: Inside the park home runs are kinda lame

    Apr 1, 2015, 3:58 PM EDT

    Screen Shot 2015-04-01 at 3.58.01 PM

    Allen Craig hit one today. Yawn.

  11. Wrigley Field has a jumbotron, you guys

    Apr 1, 2015, 3:03 PM EDT

    Wrigley Field

    Now you all will know when it is time to “MAKE SOME NOISE!!!!!!”

  12. Justin Verlander resumes throwing, but disabled list stint remains possible

    Apr 1, 2015, 1:40 PM EDT

    justin verlander getty Getty Images

    Verlander has never been on the disabled list in his 10-year career.

  13. 2015 Preview: Philadelphia Phillies

    Apr 1, 2015, 12:00 PM EDT

    Cole Hamels Getty Images

    The Phillies are going to be bad in 2015. But just how bad?

  14. Phillies waived $12 million Cuban pitcher Miguel Gonzalez, but no team wanted him

    Apr 1, 2015, 11:50 AM EDT

    Miguel Alfredo Gonzalez Getty Images

    Philadelphia’s pitching staff isn’t exactly stacked, but Gonzalez blew his chance to make the team by allowing 12 runs in 14 spring training innings.

  15. The Mets and Juan Lagares are close to a four-year extension

    Apr 1, 2015, 11:03 AM EDT

    Juan Lagares Getty Getty Images

    The Mets are locking up one of the best defensive center fielders in the game.

  16. Astros demote first baseman Jon Singleton to Triple-A

    Apr 1, 2015, 10:47 AM EDT

    Jonathan Singleton Getty Getty Images

    If he crushes Triple-A pitching he’ll be back soon enough.

  17. Marlins reliever Aaron Crow needs Tommy John surgery

    Apr 1, 2015, 10:15 AM EDT

    Aaron Crow AP

    Miami gave up left-hander Brian Flynn and minor leaguer Reid Redman to get Crow from Kansas City.

Top 10 MLB Player Searches
  1. J. Fernandez (5452)
  2. A. Rendon (4760)
  3. Y. Tomas (4556)
  4. C. Rodon (4554)
  5. K. Jansen (4367)
  1. C. Martinez (4233)
  2. C. Davis (4174)
  3. J. Verlander (4172)
  4. S. Doolittle (4163)
  5. H. Pence (4032)