Skip to content

In which I still don’t get Jim Tracy

Apr 7, 2012, 7:20 PM EDT

Jim Tracy AP

Earlier today I complimented Kirk Gibson on how he’s worked the No. 2 spot in the order in these first two games, using Chris Young against the righty Tim Lincecum on Friday and Aaron Hill versus the lefty Madison Bumgarner today.

Rockies manager Jim Tracy, on the other hand, isn’t really looking for his No. 2 hitters to hit three homers in two games. Or really hit at all. The Rockies’ plan going into the spring was to open the season with Dexter Fowler leading off and Marco Scutaro hitting second. However, Fowler was so terribly lost at the plate this spring (.149 average, 17/3 K/BBin 67 AB) that the decision was made to switch the two. Because, I guess, the leadoff spot is so very much more important than the two hole?

This isn’t just a Rockies thing either. NL No. 2 hitters hit .256/.313/.369 last year. No. 8 hitters — already typically the worst hitter in most lineups and at the added disadvantage of hitting in front of the pitcher — were barely worse at .246/.315/.359. Every other spot in the lineup, except the pitcher’s, was better. Only the Phillies, with Placido Polanco and Shane Victorino manning the spot, got a .750 OPS from their No. 2 hitters last year. The Braves got a .747 OPS from their No. 8 hitters and a .644 OPS from their No. 2 hitters. The Nationals and Diamondbacks (hopefully Gibson is figuring this out) also got much better results from the eighth spot than the two hole.

And all of this has never made sense to me. The No. 2 hitter is probably more important in the act of scoring runs than the leadoff man is, since he gets to hit with more guys on base. He may be more important than the No. 3 hitter, too, since he doesn’t come up with two outs and none on nearly as often as a No. 3 hitter does. Lineup simulations will often suggest batting a team’s best hitter second, and while that may be controversial, it’s still just common sense that you’d want one of your better hitters up there so close to the top of the lineup.

Which Fowler might be. But the Rockies have him hitting second because and only because he’s struggling right now. If they thought he was going to hit like he did last year, he’d be leading off instead. Batting him second while he’s racking up outs like this will cost the team runs and maybe a win or two down the line. It’d make a lot more sense to hit him seventh or eighth instead and maybe get Carlos Gonzalez and Troy Tulowitzki up with some men on base.

Latest Posts
  1. Justin Verlander resumes throwing, but disabled list stint remains possible

    Apr 1, 2015, 1:40 PM EDT

    justin verlander getty Getty Images

    Verlander has never been on the disabled list in his 10-year career.

  2. 2015 Preview: Philadelphia Phillies

    Apr 1, 2015, 12:00 PM EDT

    Cole Hamels Getty Images

    The Phillies are going to be bad in 2015. But just how bad?

  3. Phillies waived $12 million Cuban pitcher Miguel Gonzalez, but no team wanted him

    Apr 1, 2015, 11:50 AM EDT

    Miguel Alfredo Gonzalez Getty Images

    Philadelphia’s pitching staff isn’t exactly stacked, but Gonzalez blew his chance to make the team by allowing 12 runs in 14 spring training innings.

  4. The Mets and Juan Lagares are close to a four-year extension

    Apr 1, 2015, 11:03 AM EDT

    Juan Lagares Getty Getty Images

    The Mets are locking up one of the best defensive center fielders in the game.

  5. Astros demote first baseman Jon Singleton to Triple-A

    Apr 1, 2015, 10:47 AM EDT

    Jonathan Singleton Getty Getty Images

    If he crushes Triple-A pitching he’ll be back soon enough.

  6. Marlins reliever Aaron Crow needs Tommy John surgery

    Apr 1, 2015, 10:15 AM EDT

    Aaron Crow AP

    Miami gave up left-hander Brian Flynn and minor leaguer Reid Redman to get Crow from Kansas City.

  7. HBT Extra: Anyone but the Twins could win the AL Central

    Apr 1, 2015, 9:46 AM EDT

    Corey Kluber Corey Kluber

    Jenna and I talk about whether the Tigers can do it again.

  8. Wrigley Field will still be a work in progress, but it will be ready for Opening Day

    Apr 1, 2015, 9:05 AM EDT

    Wrigley construction Getty Images

    So don’t listen to the rumors about how it’s not fit for man nor beast nor Cubs fan.

  9. HBT Extra: Talkin’ about the NL Central

    Apr 1, 2015, 8:37 AM EDT

    Mike Matheny Getty Images

    The Cardinals and Pirates are the class here, even if the Cubs get all the chatter these days.

  10. Coco Crisp likely to open season on 15-day disabled list

    Mar 31, 2015, 11:58 PM EDT

    coco crisp getty Getty Images

    A’s left fielder Coco Crisp has been bothered by discomfort in the middle of his right arm for much of spring training, limiting him to seven Cactus League games. And the injury isn’t getting any better.

  11. 2015 Preview: Cincinnati Reds

    Mar 31, 2015, 11:02 PM EDT

    votto getty Getty Images

    Is the fun over in Cincy?

  12. Rays get Erasmo Ramirez from M’s for Mike Montgomery

    Mar 31, 2015, 10:26 PM EDT

    erasmo ramirez getty Getty Images

    As first reported by beat writer Marc Topkin of the Tampa Bay Times, the Rays have acquired right-handed starter Erasmo Ramirez from the Mariners in exchange for left-hander Mike Montgomery.

  13. Luke Gregerson officially named Astros’ closer

    Mar 31, 2015, 9:40 PM EDT

    gregerson getty Getty Images

    Gregerson figured to get the job after signing a three-year, $18.5 million free agent contract with Houston in early December and he pitched well enough this spring to fend off any potential competition.

  14. Roberto Osuna makes Blue Jays’ bullpen, will be youngest pitcher in franchise history

    Mar 31, 2015, 8:36 PM EDT

    osuna getty Getty Images

    The 20-year-old right-hander announced the news on his Twitter account Tuesday …

  15. Ken Giles exits Grapefruit League game with back pain

    Mar 31, 2015, 6:54 PM EDT

    ken giles getty Getty Images

    Jim Salisbury of CSNPhilly.com shares the news …

  16. Adam Wainwright named Cardinals’ Opening Night starter

    Mar 31, 2015, 6:09 PM EDT

    wainwirght getty Getty Images

    Adam Wainwright tossed a spring-high 93 pitches in a Grapefruit League appearance Tuesday afternoon against the Marlins and was officially declared the Cardinals’ Opening Night starter after the outing by manager Mike Matheny.

Top 10 MLB Player Searches
  1. J. Fernandez (4964)
  2. C. Rodon (4324)
  3. Y. Tomas (4167)
  4. A. Rendon (4112)
  5. K. Jansen (3907)
  1. S. Doolittle (3846)
  2. C. Davis (3807)
  3. C. Martinez (3793)
  4. J. Verlander (3789)
  5. K. Bryant (3766)