Skip to content

Johan Santana put Terry Collins in a tight spot

Jun 1, 2012, 10:04 PM EDT

Johan Santana Reuters Reuters

Terry Collins was thrust in between a rock and a hard place tonight.

His choices:

A) Let one of the most expensive pitchers in major league history, a guy who happens to be coming off shoulder surgery, top his previous career high in pitches in search of the franchise’s elusive no-hitter

B) Pull his left-handed ace, something that surely would have happened in the eighth had he already allowed a hit or two, and try to protect his team’s investment while also likely increasing his team’s chances of completing the no-hitter by bringing in a right-handed reliever to face three straight right-handed hitters.

Obviously, he chose A. I imagine every manager in the league would have done the same. It would have been extremely difficult to go the other way, assuming that Johan Santana wanted to stay in. I do think the Mets would have had the better chance of getting the hitless ninth with Frank Francisco or Bobby Parnell facing Matt Holliday, Allen Craig and David Freese. Santana, though, got the job done, giving the Mets their first no-no in their 51-year history.

Repercussions, if there are any, will take time to manifest. Santana had never topped 125 pitches in 273 career starts before throwing 133 pitches tonight. He hadn’t thrown more than 108 pitches in a start this season. The Mets will almost surely give him an extra day or two off before his next start. But rightly or wrongly, if he breaks down again later this year, people are going to point to tonight as the cause.

Latest Posts
  1. Update: Anibal Sanchez loses no-hit bid against Twins

    May 24, 2013, 9:16 PM EDT

    Anibal Sanchez Getty Images

    Tigers starter Anibal Sanchez has no-hit the Twins through seven innings tonight in Detroit. The only base runners he has allowed came on walks to Jamey Carroll and Chris Parmelee, and he has retired each of the last 17 batters he has faced. Parmelee, Eduardo Escobar, and Aaron Hicks are slated to face Sanchez when…

  2. Curtis Granderson exits after being hit on hand

    May 24, 2013, 9:00 PM EDT

    curtis granderson getty Getty Images

    Yankees outfielder Curtis Granderson was hit in the hand by Rays reliever Cesar Ramos in the fifth inning of tonight’s game against the Rays. He stayed in the game to run the bases, scoring on a bases loaded walk by Jayson Nix, but exited before the top of the sixth. Ichiro Suzuki took his place…

  3. Evan Gattis returns to New York under better circumstances

    May 24, 2013, 8:40 PM EDT

    Evan Gattis

    The Braves are in Queens, New York tonight to open up a three-game series against the Mets. Catcher Evan Gattis isn’t starting, but figures to be used as a pinch-hitter late in the game if the Braves are in need of some offense, as the 26-year-old came up with two big home runs recently: on…

  4. Joey Votto and the generation gap

    May 24, 2013, 7:55 PM EDT

    Joey Votto

    Two articles were posted recently in stark contract to one another. The first is a very insightful piece by ESPN’s Jerry Crasnick, detailing Reds first baseman Joey Votto‘s approach to hitting. The second was a not-so-insightful piece by Paul Daugherty of the Enquire, taking a swipe at Votto because he doesn’t have many runs batted…

  5. Davey Johnson refuses to shave until the National offense wakes up

    May 24, 2013, 7:10 PM EDT

    Davey Johnson AP

    Nationals manager Davey Johnson isn’t happy with his team’s offense, which enters tonight’s series opener against the Phillies having averaged 3.38 runs per game, the second-worst rate in the league. Looking for a quirky way to motivate his team, Johnson says he will not shave until the offense makes an appearance: The Nationals manager apologized…

  6. The best and worst from MLB lineups in 2013

    May 24, 2013, 6:21 PM EDT

    Miguel Cabrera AP

    This is a quick look at the very best and worst each major league lineup spot has to offer this year. Posted along with each line is the player most responsible. We’ll start out with the good before moving on to the bad. 1. Reds: .292/.442/.517, 9 HR, 37 R, 20 RBI, 5 SB (Shin-Soo…

  7. Member of the Kauffman Stadium K-Crew helps save a fan’s life

    May 24, 2013, 5:41 PM EDT

    Kauffman Stadium

    The K-Crew at Royals games are people who roam the stands, dance on the dugout and fire up the fans. One of them also happens to be a nurse, and she helped save a 14 year-old fan’s life last Friday: Sam Sapenaro, 26, was working her second job as a member of Kauffman Stadium’s K-Crew…

  8. Mark Teixeira planning to rejoin the Yankees next week

    May 24, 2013, 5:17 PM EDT

    Mark Teixeira AP

    Mark Teixeira laid out his rehab schedule for Wallace Matthews of ESPN New York, saying the current plan calls for him to play four games in the minors next week and then come off the disabled list to rejoin the Yankees by the end of the week. It’s worth noting that Teixeira has repeatedly laid…

  9. Danny Espinosa has been playing with a broken wrist since April

    May 24, 2013, 5:02 PM EDT

    Danny Espinosa, Allen Craig

    Since that series against the Braves, specifically. The one in which he said he wasn’t impressed by them. Guess he meant it, because one of the Braves pitchers broke his friggin’ wrist and he apparently didn’t take notice of it: Source: #Nats 2b Danny Espinosa‘s right wrist was broken when Paul Maholm hit him with…

  10. Don Sutton is really, really slick

    May 24, 2013, 4:30 PM EDT

    Don Sutton

    Barry Bloom of MLB.com has a fun, wide-ranging interview with Don Sutton. Lots of good stuff in there as Sutton is never short of opinions. But this is easily my favorite part: MLB.com: Did you cheat? Sutton: No, I never got caught cheating. Bloom did not, sadly, follow up on that. Maybe his mind was…

  11. Red Sox place Victorino and Middlebrooks on DL, call up Aceves and Iglesias

    May 24, 2013, 4:16 PM EDT

    Shane Victorino AP

    David Ross is returning from a concussion tonight but the Red Sox are far from healthy, placing Shane Victorino and Will Middlebrooks on the disabled list. Victorino has a strained hamstring and Middlebrooks has lower back spasms, and Boston has added infielder Jose Iglesias and right-hander Alfredo Aceves from Triple-A to replace them. Iglesias, who’s…

  12. Alfonso Soriano is tired of losing

    May 24, 2013, 4:00 PM EDT

    Alfonso Soriano AP

    I get the sense that if Alfonso Soriano is on the trading block this summer he’s not gonna have a big problem waiving his no-trade rights. From Carrie Muskat at MLB.com, here’s Soriano venting about losing: “You think we’re going to win that game 3-0, and in five minutes, [we're down] 5-3 … I’m tired…

  13. David Ross returns from concussion, rejoins Red Sox

    May 24, 2013, 3:45 PM EDT

    Toronto Blue Jays v Boston Red Sox Getty Images

    David Ross, who’s missed the past two weeks with post-concussion symptoms, has been cleared to return to the Red Sox and will be active for tonight’s game. That means Ryan Lavarnway is headed back to Triple-A after filling in for Ross as Jarrod Saltalamacchia‘s backup. Ross played in one minor-league rehab game at Double-A yesterday,…

  14. Reds reliever Sean Marshall goes back on the disabled list

    May 24, 2013, 3:15 PM EDT

    Cincinnati Reds Photo Day Getty Images

    For the second time this season Reds left-hander Sean Marshall is headed to the disabled list with shoulder problems. Last month it was tendinitis and now it’s being called a sprained shoulder, so it seems likely that Marshall will be out of action for more than the minimum 15 days. In between the injuries he…

  15. Robert Andino designated for assignment by the Mariners

    May 24, 2013, 3:00 PM EDT

    Erick Aybar, Robert Andino

    Not long ago the Mariners benched Brendan Ryan for Robert Andino. Not realizing, it seemed, that while neither of then could hit their way out of a wet paper bag, at least Ryan could flash some serious leather. Someone finally figured that out, however: Andino has been designated for assignment. Andino was hitting .184/.253/.237 in 85…

  16. Alex Rodriguez sold his house in Miami for $30 million

    May 24, 2013, 2:14 PM EDT

    alex rodriguez house

    As of last year Alex Rodriguez had his house in Miami on the market for an asking price of $38 million and Darren Rovell of ESPN.com reports that he finally sold the place for $30 million. According to Rovell he paid $7.4 million for the place in 2010 and then dropped another $7.4 million or…

  17. Could Don Mattingly wind up with the Nationals?

    May 24, 2013, 1:30 PM EDT

    mattingly getty Getty Images

    He’s still employed by the Dodgers. And Davey Johnson is still employed by the Nats. But the latter situation is only going to last for this year and the former could end at any time. In light of that Danny Knobler of CBS Sports.com hears some chatter that the former could replace the latter: People…

  18. Ryan Mattheus likely to miss 4-6 weeks after locker punch

    May 24, 2013, 1:16 PM EDT

    Ryan Mattheus AP

    How long is a pitcher sidelined after he punches a locker with his pitching hand and breaks it (the hand, not the locker)? Well, in Ryan Mattheus‘ case 4-6 weeks. That’s the official word from the Nationals and as Amanda Comak of the Washington Times notes the good news is that the reliever won’t need…

  19. Miguel Cabrera home run Gif > Yu Darvish pitches Gif

    May 24, 2013, 1:00 PM EDT

    Miguel Cabrera Getty Getty Images

    I was a big fan of Drew Sheppard’s Gif of Yu Darvish throwing five different pitches. As were some folks in Japan, who inexplicably made that post the most-read thing in the history of HardballTalk. By a wide margin. But I think I’m more impressed by Drew putting six Miguel Cabrera home runs into one…

  20. HBT Daily: The Phillies should sell at the deadline

    May 24, 2013, 12:30 PM EDT

    HBT Daily Logo

    Hey, Kay asked me buy or sell, I gave my answer.

Top 10 MLB Player Searches
  1. J. Odorizzi (4218)
  2. J. Profar (4143)
  3. J. Garcia (3995)
  4. A. Eaton (3802)
  5. K. Gausman (3693)
  1. M. Cabrera (3665)
  2. B. Harper (3406)
  3. B. Beachy (3378)
  4. M. Garza (3291)
  5. Y. Gomes (3111)