Skip to content

Austin Jackson, Bryce Harper lead All-Star snubs

Jul 1, 2012, 2:14 PM EDT

Bryce Harper AP

You knew it was coming. In truth, I think those in charge did a better job of picking this season’s All-Stars than they have in recent years. Still, I have some disagreements, even if none of them are quite as vehement as last season’s.

Austin Jackson (OF Tigers) – Jackson’s DL stint probably cost him a roster spot, but he’s played in just as many games as Mike Trout this year and has the better OPS of the two at .945. In fact, he ranks sixth in the AL in OPS, and he’s played an outstanding center field for Detroit. Ideally, the AL would have found room for him, Trout and Adam Jones on the squad, but if one of them had to be left off, it should have been Jones.

Bryce Harper (OF Nationals) – No, Harper didn’t necessarily deserve a roster spot on merit. But it’s not like he was far off, either, and he’d give a lot of people more reason to watch the All-Star Game. ┬áHe probably would have been voted in as a starter had he been listed on the ballot. His .274/.346/.475 line is about as valuable as Jay Bruce‘s .257/.327/.526, especially once one factors in that Bruce is putting up his numbers at Great American. There still could be room for him on the team if he wins the Final Vote, as seems likely.

James McDonald (RHP Pirates) – Incredibly enough, the NL All-Star pitching staff will feature just one guy in the top six in the league in ERA and three of the top 11. Brandon Beachy and Ryan Dempster, Nos. 1 and 2 respectively, are on the DL, so they weren’t possibilities. No. 3 R.A. Dickey did get the nod. However, the next three on the list: Ryan Vogelsong, Johnny Cueto and McDonald, were all left out. I see McDonald as the biggest snub. Not only is he sixth in ERA, but he’s fourth in the league in WHIP. His three losses this year have all come in games in which the Pirates were shut out.

Johan Santana (LHP Mets) – How many no-hitters does a guy have to throw to get some recognition? Santana is 10th in the NL in ERA ahead of All-Stars Gio Gonzalez, Stephen Strasburg, Wade Miley, Cole Hamels and Lance Lynn. I’d have gone with McDonald over Lynn, Santana over Miley and either Cueto or Madison Bumgarner over Hamels.

Edwin Encarnacion (1B-DH Blue Jays) – The AL is carrying three designated hitters and still couldn’t find room for this guy? Encarnacion ranks seventh in the league in OPS and fifth in homers. He’s also struck out 70 times fewer than Adam Dunn.

Jake Peavy (RHP White Sox) – In stark contrast to the NL, the AL managed to take its top five pitchers by ERA. Still, manager Ron Washington left off No. 6 in Peavy. Peavy also ranks fourth in WHIP and sixth in strikeouts, but he’s just 6-5 thanks to poor support. The White Sox probably didn’t want him pitching in the game anyway.

Jed Lowrie (SS Astros) – Lowrie leads all shortstops in homers and is third in OPS behind the AL All-Star Asdrubal Cabrera and the injured Troy Tulowitzki. I don’t mind Jose Altuve as Houston’s All-Star, but on merit, the NL should have picked Lowrie over Starlin Castro.

Aar0n Hill (2B Diamondbacks) – With Lowrie representing the Astros, Hill could have made the team over Altuve. Mr. Cycle’s .878 OPS is 75 points better than that of Altuve and 100 points better than that of any other NL second baseman.

Ernesto Frieri, Scott Downs (RP Angels) – Frieri has pitched 23 1/3 scoreless innings and struck out 40 since arriving in Anaheim. Downs has a 0.35 ERA in 26 innings after finishing at 1.34 last year. I’d certainly rather rely on those two for matchup purposes late in the game than either Chris Perez or Joe Nathan.

Josh Willingham (OF Twins) – Willingham has the AL’s 10th best OPS at .913, but he was a casuality of the fact that the AL is carrying three DHs in David Ortiz, Dunn and Billy Butler.

Paul Goldschmidt (1B Diamondbacks) – If anyone deserves to play nine innings in the All-Star Game, it’s Joey Votto. Not only is he the NL’s best hitter, but there just weren’t any great options to back him up. Bryan LaHair was chosen as the team’s other first basemen, even though his numbers have taken a big nosedive of late. Adam LaRoche was more deserving, even if his .251/.338/.506 line is nothing special. My preferred choice, though, would have been Goldschmidt, who has shaken off a rough start to hit .293/.369/.542 in 225 at-bats.

  1. normswifevera - Jul 2, 2012 at 7:06 AM

    The Royals’ Alcides Escobar has the highest batting average for a shortstop in the majors, is a fantastic defender, and plays for the host city . Obviously he’s not going to bump out guys like Jeter, but given that there’s another Royal on the vote-in list, I think a case can easily be made that Escobar would be a better addition than Jonathan Broxton. If nothing else, he’d be a great defensive addition or pinch runner late in the game.

  2. skinswin222 - Jul 2, 2012 at 8:13 AM

    What about Zack Greinke?

  3. homelanddefense - Jul 2, 2012 at 9:40 AM

    I disagree with Harper. He will be good for a long time, but IMO All Star games are for the best players now.

    If you are going to make an argument for Harper then you would have to do the same for Middlebrooks, who has outperformed Harper in the short time they have both been playing. More avg, HR, RBI, etc….in less ABs.

  4. rebel21das - Jul 2, 2012 at 9:40 AM

    I think Josh Reddick got snubbed.

  5. drewsylvania - Jul 2, 2012 at 1:11 PM

    There are about 20 players having better seasons than Adam Dunn.

  6. chitownmatt - Jul 2, 2012 at 5:25 PM

    A.J. !?!?!?

  7. 65kris - Jul 2, 2012 at 7:14 PM

    Why is no one talking about Chris Capuano? Clayton Kershaw is the defending Cy Young winner but you could argue that Capuano has acually been the best pitcher on the Dodgers this season.

Leave Comment

You must be logged in to leave a comment. Not a member? Register now!

Featured video

Patience finally paying off for Royals fans
Top 10 MLB Player Searches
  1. R. Castillo (2931)
  2. D. Ortiz (2196)
  3. J. Hamilton (2161)
  4. N. Arenado (2138)
  5. C. Kershaw (2091)
  1. G. Stanton (2076)
  2. A. Rizzo (1974)
  3. A. Pujols (1932)
  4. M. Trout (1920)
  5. A. Pagan (1830)