Oct 17, 2012, 6:31 PM EDT
If Derek Jeter‘s broken ankle didn’t take him out of the mix for the World Baseball Classic the moment it happened, today’s news that he needs surgery definitely makes the issue moot.
But as unfortunate as Jeter’s injury is for the Yankees, it’s not necessarily a bad thing for Team USA in next spring’s World Baseball Classic. With Joe Torre running the show, one imagines Jeter would have been the team’s starting shortstop, even though he hardly seems like the best option.
Team USA has also lost another likely starter to surgery in the Dodgers’ Matt Kemp. Again, that’s hardly a disaster, though Kemp was the National League’s best player in 2011 and for the first month of 2012. There’s still plenty of talent to go around.
I’m just going to look at the position candidates for now, with perhaps a separate blog dedicated to pitching possibilities later.
It’ll obviously be a Posey-Mauer duo unless one of those two opts to step aside. Posey would probably do the bulk of the catching in the scenario, which is surely how the Twins would prefer it anyway.
Although Adrian Gonzalez was born in San Diego, he played for Mexico in the 2009 WBC. Team USA could use him here, but Fielder isn’t a bad alternative.
I’m listing Utley, though with his knee problems, I doubt he’ll opt in. Pedroia was set to be Team USA’s second baseman in 2009, but he was injured and replaced by Brian Roberts. I think he’s the best option here, but Phillips may well get the nod over him as a starter. The versatile Zobrist would be a perfect reserve.
Both Longoria and Wright were on the 2009 team, and it’d make sense to go with that duo again. Headley might have been the best of this bunch in 2012, but he still doesn’t have the track record of the top two.
Given how much of the 2012 season Tulowitzki missed, one wonders if the Rockies might try to block him from playing in the WBC. Let’s hope not, because he’s pretty clearly Team USA’s best option at shortstop. If he’s unavailable, then Rollins is the logical starter.
Kemp would have looked pretty good as a starting right fielder, had he been willing to switch positions, but his loss isn’t a particularly big one. Hamilton seems like a long shot to play, particularly if he signs with a new team this winter.
So, how about this for a lineup:
RF Mike Trout – R
2B Dustin Pedroia – R
CF Andrew McCutchen – R
LF Ryan Braun – R
1B Prince Fielder – L
C Buster Posey – R
DH Giancarlo Stanton – R
3B Evan Longoria – R
SS Troy Tulowitzki – R
With a bench of Mauer, Zobrist, Rollins, Wright and one of the left-handed-hitting outfielders.
Yes, the entire group is righty heavy, but that’s pretty much the way it has to be. Torre can always start Mauer at catcher or DH or play Rollins at short if he wants some lefties in there. It should have the edge on the outstanding Dominican lineup, that could include such talents as Jose Bautista, Albert Pujols, Robinson Cano, David Ortiz, Jose Reyes and Adrian Beltre.