Skip to content

Mike Trout, baseball’s best player, is denied MVP award

Nov 15, 2012, 7:04 PM EDT

Mike Trout Reuters

In handing Miguel Cabrera the American League MVP award, the voters weren’t making a statement that Cabrera’s four additional points of batting average, his 14 homers or even his 56 RBI made him a better player than Mike Trout last season.

Because this isn’t really about who was the better player.

Sportswriters decided long ago that the Most Valuable Player isn’t necessarily the best player. Because the best player is often quite obvious. One doesn’t need any inside knowledge to deduce the best player. In fact, it’s very much in the best interests of the BBWAA to keep the MVP criteria ambiguous and controversial. It’s the debate that keeps the machine going.

Mike Trout was pretty obviously a better overall player than Miguel Cabrera this year. He hit .326/.399/.564 to Cabrera’s .330/.393/.606, while playing in the tougher environment for hitters. He also grounded into 21 fewer double plays. Cabrera was still probably a bit more valuable offensively, but Trout more than made up for that with his defense and baserunning.

So what trumps that…

Cabrera won the Triple Crown.

But he wouldn’t have been any more or less valuable had Jose Bautista remained healthy and hit 50 homers. It’s a really cool feat, but the title adds nothing to his value.

Cabrera’s team made the postseason.

But the Angels had a better record while playing in a better division. Also, for what little it’s worth, the Angels were 81-58 when Trout played and 8-15 when he didn’t.

Cabrera moved to third base for the good of the team.

He never wanted to move off third base in the first place. Trout opened the season in the minors “for the good of the team” and never uttered a peep, even though that decision could have cost him millions in future earnings, the Rookie of the Year award and, as it turns out, the MVP award.

Cabrera was better from Aug. 24 until the end of the season.

Why Aug. 24? Oh, that’s right, Cabrera had a good game that day and Trout had a good one the day before.

Cabrera certainly did have better stats than Trout over the final five weeks. But here’s another truth: Cabrera’s RBIs were the difference in one Tigers victory down the stretch (3 RBI in a 6-4 win over the Twins on Sept. 29). Trout’s RBIs were equal to or greater than the Angels’ margin of victory on Sept. 30 against Texas (solo homer in a 5-4 win), Sept. 9 against Detroit (solo homer in a 3-2 win), Aug. 28 against Boston (two RBI in a 6-5 win) and also in that Aug. 23 game that no one wants to count (two RBI in a 14-13 win).

In my opinion, the best argument for Cabrera as the AL MVP is that he was the league’s second best player and he played in 22 more games than the best player, which has a whole lot of value. It’s hardly his fault, but the fact is that Trout contributed nothing for three weeks in April. Cabrera already had six homers and 16 RBI by the time Trout was called up.

And I’m OK with Cabrera getting the MVP. He’s been one of the game’s best players for a long time, and he hadn’t won one before. He’s not Juan Gonzalez; he’s a legitimately superb hitter and a sure-fire Hall of Famer unless he suddenly falls off a cliff. He wasn’t quite as good as Trout in 2012, but then, Trout’s 2012 campaign trumps that of most MVPs most years.

Latest Posts
  1. Rangers snap Astros’ 10-game winning streak

    May 4, 2015, 11:25 PM EDT

    Delino DeShields Jr.;Hank Conger AP

    The Astros hadn’t lost a game since April 22.

  2. UPDATE: Hanley Ramirez exits game with a left shoulder sprain

    May 4, 2015, 10:43 PM EDT

    hanley

    Ramirez suffered the injury when he ran into the wall along the left-field line while attempting to make a catch.

  3. UPDATE: Anthony Rendon diagnosed with oblique strain

    May 4, 2015, 10:13 PM EDT

    anthony rendon getty Getty Images

    Anthony Rendon’s long road back from a left knee sprain has hit a roadblock due to an oblique strain.

  4. Jeff Karstens announces his retirement

    May 4, 2015, 10:05 PM EDT

    Pittsburgh Pirates v New York Mets Getty Images

    Jeff Karstens hasn’t appeared in the majors since 2012 due to injury and today he took to Instagram to announce his retirement from baseball.

  5. Mariners place Austin Jackson on disabled list with a right ankle sprain

    May 4, 2015, 9:03 PM EDT

    austin jackson ap AP

    Jackson sprained his ankle during Sunday’s game and will require an extended absence.

  6. Blue Jays hitting coach Brook Jacoby suspended 14 games for conduct toward umpiring crew

    May 4, 2015, 7:34 PM EDT

    Tampa Bay Rays v Toronto Blue Jays Getty Images

    MLB brought the hammer down really hard on Blue Jays hitting coach Brook Jacoby for an incident with the umpiring crew while the team was in Boston last week.

  7. Alex Cobb shut down after setback with forearm injury

    May 4, 2015, 6:35 PM EDT

    Alex Cobb AP

    Rays right-hander Alex Cobb has been sidelined since the middle of March due to forearm tendinitis and it doesn’t sound like he’ll be back in the near future.

  8. Rockies closer Adam Ottavino needs Tommy John surgery

    May 4, 2015, 5:29 PM EDT

    Adam Ottavino AP

    Ottavino finishes the season with a 0.00 ERA and 13/2 K/BB ratio in 10 innings.

  9. Nelson Cruz, Adrian Gonzalez named Players of the Month

    May 4, 2015, 5:11 PM EDT

    Nelson Cruz Nelson Cruz

    The pitchers and rookies of the month were also named.

  10. Twins place Oswaldo Arcia on DL, call up prospect Eddie Rosario

    May 4, 2015, 4:20 PM EDT

    Oswaldo Arcia AP

    Not so long ago Rosario was viewed as a very good prospect, but …

  11. Video: Debating Pete Rose’s possible reinstatement

    May 4, 2015, 4:17 PM EDT

    pete rose getty Getty Images

    Are we now to the “when,” rather than the “if” portion of the Rose reinstatement debate?

  12. Nick Swisher set to rejoin Indians after two knee surgeries

    May 4, 2015, 2:50 PM EDT

    Oakland Athletics v Cleveland Indians Getty Images

    He’s being paid $15 million this season and is owed another $15 million in 2016.

  13. Did the Brewers follow the “Selig Rule” in hiring Craig Counsell?

    May 4, 2015, 12:25 PM EDT

    Brewers logo

    The Selig rule requires that requires that every club consider minority candidates for manager positions. There really wasn’t a search for Ron Roenicke’s replacement in Milwaukee.

  14. Craig Counsell gets a three-year deal to manage the Brewers

    May 4, 2015, 11:29 AM EDT

    Craig Counsell Getty Images

    Milwaukee now has the guy who had easily the best batting stance of any current manager.

  15. Orioles shortstop J.J. Hardy cleared for rehab assignment

    May 4, 2015, 11:19 AM EDT

    St. Louis Cardinals v Baltimore Orioles Getty Images

    Nearly a month ago Hardy was said to be “close” to starting a rehab stint.

  16. Quote of the Day: A-Rod isn’t gonna talk about the $6 million home run bonus

    May 4, 2015, 10:30 AM EDT

    Alex Rodriguez Getty Images

    He says “it’s family business” and that “the old A-Rod is gone.”

Top 10 MLB Player Searches
  1. A. Rendon (3715)
  2. J. Hamilton (3612)
  3. J. Lowrie (3206)
  4. A. Colome (3035)
  5. D. Span (2959)
  1. A. Ottavino (2854)
  2. D. Jennings (2851)
  3. D. Wright (2832)
  4. C. Gomez (2800)
  5. J. Reyes (2733)