Skip to content

Melky Cabrera’s contract is not evidence that the drug program is broken

Nov 16, 2012, 2:38 PM EDT

melky cabrera getty Getty Images

As soon as the news broke that Melky Cabrera is signing with the Blue Jays, several people in my Twitter timeline said things to the effect that it must be the case that baseball’s drug testing system is broken if someone fresh off a PED suspension can sign a two-year, $16 million deal. And I get the frustration I suppose, because no one likes to see cheaters prosper, but whatever you think of this deal, it cannot reasonably be interpreted as an indictment of the drug testing system.

Based on his last two seasons, Melky Cabrera was poised to make something like $40 million bucks in free agency. Maybe more. And now, though he is not going to be hurting or anything, he’s going to make less than half that.  Say what you want about the drug testing system, but tens of millions of dollars in lost wages is no small penalty.

Now, that doesn’t mean that Cabrera’s use of PEDs didn’t still somehow help him. I’ll acknowledge that $16 million over two years may still be more than he ever could have got if he never took PEDs.  But we don’t know. We simply have no way of knowing how much of Cabrera’s improvement over the past two years was a function of PEDs and how much of it was natural improvement as he reached an age when most players put up their best years. Maybe he would have turned into the player his potential always suggested he might, in which case he’d still be making a good living. Maybe he wouldn’t have. If anyone claims to know this for sure, they’re making crap up, because it’s unknowable with current science and baseball analytics.

But no matter what amount of advantage he still realized, it’s on Cabrera, human nature and the incentives any person — and any team like the Blue Jays — is subject to, not baseball’s drug program.  Just as no laws, no matter how tough, can eradicate crime, no drug testing program can eradicate cheating. People will still do it from time to time. And when they do, they run the risk of getting caught. And when they get caught, they are punished. As Melky Cabrera was punished, to the tune of tens of millions of dollars.

Still not good enough for you? OK, that’s your right to think so. But know that the only logical conclusion to such thinking is to advocate for a lifetime ban for first time drug users. Because that’s the only thing that would have kept a team from taking a chance on Melky Cabrera like the Blue Jays are.  And while you may disagree, I think such a thing would be way too damn harsh.

Latest Posts
  1. Video: Derek Jeter surpasses Lou Gehrig for first place on Yankees’ all-time doubles list

    Jul 22, 2014, 10:24 PM EDT

    derek jeter getty Getty Images

    Yankees shortstop Derek Jeter made a little more history on Tuesday night against the Rangers …

  2. Marlins are not shopping Casey McGehee, might sign him to multi-year contract extension

    Jul 22, 2014, 9:37 PM EDT

    casey mcgehee marlins getty Getty Images

    Casey McGehee entered play on Tuesday evening with a batting average (.322) that is 54 points above his career mean (.268) and an RBI total (56) that ranks ninth in the National League. The 31-year-old third baseman fits the mold of a sell-high candidate. But it doesn’t sound like he’s going to be moved.

  3. Video: Leonys Martin robs Brian McCann with juggling grab

    Jul 22, 2014, 8:41 PM EDT

    leonys martin getty Getty Images

    Watch as Rangers outfielder Leonys Martin leaps above the right-center field wall at Yankee Stadium to rob Brian McCann of a home run in the bottom of the second inning Tuesday night …

  4. Taijuan Walker returning to Mariners’ rotation Wednesday

    Jul 22, 2014, 7:53 PM EDT

    taijuan walker getty Getty Images

    Mariners right-hander Taijuan Walker will be called back up from Triple-A Tacoma to start Wednesday night against the Mets at Seattle’s Safeco Field.

  5. Why aren’t the Cardinals playing Oscar Taveras?

    Jul 22, 2014, 7:08 PM EDT

    oscar taveras getty Getty Images

    Oscar Taveras has started just two of the Cardinals’ last seven games and the left-handed-hitting outfield prospect is not in St. Louis’ starting lineup on Tuesday night against Rays right-hander Jake Odorizzi. Getting the nod instead is the right-handed-hitting Allen Craig. What’s the deal?

  6. Kevin Siegrist expected to return Wednesday

    Jul 22, 2014, 6:14 PM EDT

    kevin siegrist getty Getty Images

    According to Brian Stull of CBS Sports 920, left-handed reliever Kevin Siegrist joined back up with the Cardinals on Tuesday in St. Louis and is expected to be activated from the disabled list on Wednesday.

  7. Rockies place Troy Tulowitzki on the disabled list

    Jul 22, 2014, 5:27 PM EDT

    Troy Tulowitzki Troy Tulowitzki

    Troy Tulowitzki exited Saturday’s game with what the Rockies called a “cramp” in his quadriceps, but now the star shortstop is out of the lineup tonight for the third consecutive game and it’s clear the injury is more serious.

  8. Josh Reddick rejoins A’s after latest knee injury

    Jul 22, 2014, 4:46 PM EDT

    josh reddick getty Getty Images

    A’s outfielder Josh Reddick is off the disabled list after missing all but one week of the past two months with knee problems.

  9. Kirk Gibson gives a jerky kind of “no-comment” on the Brandon McCarthy cutter controversy

    Jul 22, 2014, 4:31 PM EDT

    Kirk Gibson AP

    Apparently, one does not ask Kirk Gibson about the decisions he and his coaching staff make about on-the-field decisions.

  10. Geovany Soto lasted three games before going back on the disabled list

    Jul 22, 2014, 4:16 PM EDT

    Geovany Soto AP AP

    At this point the Rangers’ injury situation is absurd.

  11. Rob Manfred “heavily favored” to be Bud Selig’s replacement

    Jul 22, 2014, 4:00 PM EDT

    Rob Manfred

    After a bit of a dance, it seems like the early favorite to take over for Bud Selig is the favorite when it really matters.

  12. Cubs designate Darwin Barney for assignment, activate Emilio Bonifacio from disabled list

    Jul 22, 2014, 3:45 PM EDT

    Darwin Barney Getty Getty Images

    Darwin Barney logged 500-plus plate appearances for the Cubs each season from 2011-2013 and was the Opening Day second baseman this year, but today he was designated for assignment to make roster room for Emilio Bonifacio’s return from the disabled list.

  13. Justin Masterson wants to rejoin the Indians, but he’ll make at least one more rehab start

    Jul 22, 2014, 3:15 PM EDT

    masterson getty Getty Images

    Justin Masterson tossed five innings in a minor-league rehab start Sunday, but rather than welcoming him back from the disabled list the Indians will have the right-hander make another rehab start.

  14. Yankees acquire Chase Headley from Padres

    Jul 22, 2014, 1:22 PM EDT

    Chase Headley Chase Headley

    Two seasons ago Headley smacked 31 homers, led the league in RBIs, and finished fifth in the MVP balloting, but his production plummeted last season and this year he’s been mostly injured and ineffective.

  15. Michael Cuddyer still 3-4 weeks from returning to Rockies

    Jul 22, 2014, 12:46 PM EDT

    cuddyer getty Getty Images

    Cuddyer, who won the batting title last season by hitting .331 with a .919 OPS in 130 games, hit .317 with five homers and an .866 OPS in 31 games before the injury this year.

  16. Changes to official scorers rulings have tripled in recent years

    Jul 22, 2014, 12:30 PM EDT

    World Series - Boston Red Sox v St Louis Cardinals - Game Four Getty Images

    Murray Chass — yes, Murray Chass — has an excellent article about this today.

  17. No one is sure when Matt Cain will pitch for the Giants again

    Jul 22, 2014, 11:50 AM EDT

    Matt Cain AP

    After letting Matt Cain pitch (poorly) through a “cranky” elbow since spring training the Giants finally shut him down yesterday, placing him on the disabled list with elbow inflammation.

  18. The guy with the curly-W beard is . . . awesome?

    Jul 22, 2014, 11:30 AM EDT

    Nationals cap logo

    That’s some real Nattitude right there.

Featured video

Colby-on-Colby crime in Toronto
Top 10 MLB Player Searches
  1. H. Street (3521)
  2. C. Lee (2586)
  3. H. Ramirez (2392)
  4. T. Tulowitzki (2387)
  5. Y. Puig (2176)
  1. T. Walker (2097)
  2. B. Belt (2062)
  3. D. Price (2029)
  4. D. Uggla (1946)
  5. D. Salazar (1884)