Skip to content

Let’s stop beefing about the fact that Melky Cabrera got a contract

Nov 19, 2012, 9:35 AM EDT

melky cabrera getty Getty Images

I’ve seen a dozen of these sorts of sentiments from baseball writers since Melky Cabrera signed with the Blue Jays last week:

Melky Cabrera was rewarded with a two-year, $16-million free agent contract by the Toronto Blue Jays. Cabrera’s deal came less than two weeks after the Oakland Athletics gave pitcher Bartolo Colon a pay raise and a one-year contract that could be worth, with incentives, $6 million. Steroids win again, in other words.

I railed against this last week, but let’s put it in simpler terms:  if you are upset that Melky Cabrera got a contract to play baseball, you must necessarily believe that PED users should get lifetime bans, yes? If you’re not willing to make the latter argument, you are being intellectually dishonest if you make the former. The guy has served his time, has been penalized significantly in terms of dollars and shame, and has a right to continue his career, does he not? If not, make your case for him being banned for life or shut the hell up (I know many of you in the comments section and many casual fans will do so, but I direct this specifically at baseball writers who, unless they are trying to traffic in some easy outrage like this, never independently make the case that PED users should be banned for life and never seriously would).

Even if you discount Melky Cabrera’s past two seasons as 100% fraudulent and without an ounce of actual baseball talent underlying them — which is itself silly given what we know about how PEDs work — an eight million dollar a year deal for a normal 27 year-old outfielder who has played in nearly 1000 games and can play some center is not by any stretch of the imagination a “reward” compared to what other players like him get paid. Coco Crisp is going to make just a bit less than that over the next two years and he’s five years older than Melky. Coco Crisp is a nice player, but it’s not like he’s making crazy elite superstar bucks.

Heck, even if you pretended that 2011 and 2012 didn’t exist at all, I’d then ask you to go back to 2010 and value a 21-25 year-old center fielder who is able to stick in the lineup of two winning teams and show some occasional power. Not a great player by any stretch of the imagination, but someone who has shown some flashes of quality mixed in with his erratic play and who, by most accounts, just needs to dedicate himself more in order to become a useful, everyday player.

What does that guy make when he hits the free agent market? I submit that it’s much closer to $8 million a year than $8 million a year is to whatever Cabrera would have made this winter if he had not been busted for PEDs.

But please, go ahead and continue arguing that Cabrera got away with something and that “steroids have won again.”

Latest Posts
  1. Settling the Score: Saturday’s results

    Jul 13, 2014, 8:48 AM EDT

    adam wainwright getty Getty Images

    The tide continues to change in the NL Central. Playing with heavy hearts in the aftermath of shortstop Jean Segura losing his nine-month-old son, the Brewers were blown out 10-2 by the visiting Cardinals on Saturday afternoon at Miller Park.

  2. Indians acquire Nick Maronde from the Angels

    Jul 12, 2014, 11:00 PM EDT

    Nick Maronde Nick Maronde

    The Indians and Angels made a small deal on Saturday, swapping a lefty reliever for cash.

  3. Fernando Rodney replaces David Price on the American League All-Star roster

    Jul 12, 2014, 10:05 PM EDT

    Fernando Rodney Fernando Rodney

    The American League has added a reliever rather than a starter with David Price giving up his spot on the roster for the All-Star Game.

  4. Play of the Day: Brian Dozier gets the out at home

    Jul 12, 2014, 9:10 PM EDT

    Brian Dozier Brian Dozier

    Brian Dozier made a nifty play at Coors Field to get an out at home plate on Saturday.

  5. Dexter Fowler hopes to return to the Astros on Friday

    Jul 12, 2014, 8:15 PM EDT

    Dexter Fowler Getty Images

    The Astros may get their center fielder back on Friday if all goes according to plan.

  6. Carlos Ruiz aims to begin rehabbing next week

    Jul 12, 2014, 7:20 PM EDT

    Carlos Ruiz Carlos Ruiz

    Phillies catcher Carlos Ruiz will take batting practice and work on blocking baseballs. The hope is to begin a rehab assignment by the weekend.

  7. Pirates sign Rafael Perez to a minor league deal

    Jul 12, 2014, 6:25 PM EDT

    Rafael Perez Getty Getty Images

    The Pirates added some relief depth, signing Rafael Perez to a minor league deal on Saturday.

  8. Nolan Reimold is hurt again

    Jul 12, 2014, 5:30 PM EDT

    Nolan Reimold AP AP

    A pair of neck surgeries limited Nolan Reimold to just 56 games between 2012-2013 and now he’s dealing with a calf strain.

  9. Alexei Ramirez exits game with back stiffness; considered day-to-day

    Jul 12, 2014, 4:29 PM EDT

    Alexei Ramirez Getty Getty Images

    White Sox shortstop Alexei Ramirez was forced to exit this afternoon’s game against the Indians in the top of the fourth inning due to back stiffness.

  10. Reds hope to get Joey Votto back for the “stretch run”

    Jul 12, 2014, 4:14 PM EDT

    Votto Getty Getty Images

    Reds first baseman Joey Votto has received platelet-rich plasma injections in an effort to get past his lingering quad injury.

  11. Henderson Alvarez replaces Jordan Zimmermann on NL All-Star roster

    Jul 12, 2014, 3:02 PM EDT

    Henderson Alvarez Getty Getty Images

    This is the first All-Star selection for Henderson Alvarez.

  12. The Pirates could be interested in Huston Street

    Jul 12, 2014, 2:01 PM EDT

    Huston Street Getty Getty Images

    The Pirates are focused on adding pitching in advance of the July non-waiver trade deadline.

  13. Jean Segura leaves Brewers following the death of his nine-month-old son

    Jul 12, 2014, 1:08 PM EDT

    Jean Segura Getty Getty Images

    Jean Segura has returned to his native Dominican Republic following the death of his nine-month-old son yesterday.

  14. Skip Schumaker placed on concussion disabled list

    Jul 12, 2014, 12:20 PM EDT

    Skip Schumaker Getty Getty Images

    Brandon Phillips underwent surgery yesterday to repair a torn ligament in his left thumb and now the Reds will be without one of the potential options to fill in at second base.

  15. VIDEO: Billy Hamilton goes all Matrix to avoid a tag

    Jul 12, 2014, 11:36 AM EDT

    Billy Hamilton matrix

    There’s increasing evidence that Reds center fielder Billy Hamilton is not of this world.

  16. David Price scratched from start due to illness

    Jul 12, 2014, 10:53 AM EDT

    David Price AP AP

    Jake Odorizzi will move up in the rotation to start this afternoon. The hope is that Price will feel well enough to pitch tomorrow.

  17. Aroldis Chapman sets MLB record with strikeout in 40th straight relief appearance

    Jul 12, 2014, 10:22 AM EDT

    Aroldis Chapman Getty Getty Images

    The previous record was held by Hall of Famer Bruce Sutter, who went 39 consecutive appearances with a strikeout in 1977.

  18. Jordan Zimmermann exits start with right biceps cramp; will go for MRI

    Jul 12, 2014, 9:38 AM EDT

    Jordan Zimmermann AP AP

    At the very least, Jordan Zimmermann will not be able to pitch in the All-Star Game next week. His availability beyond that is up in the air.

  19. Settling the Score: Friday’s results

    Jul 12, 2014, 8:56 AM EDT

    Francisco Rodriguez AP AP

    A quick recap of a busy Friday around MLB, including another loss for the Brewers.

  20. Ian Kinsler replaces teammate Victor Martinez on the AL All-Star Roster

    Jul 11, 2014, 11:05 PM EDT

    Ian Kinsler Ian Kinsler

    The AL Roster swaps one injured Tiger for a healthy one. Ian Kinsler will replace Victor Martinez.

Featured video

Yanks, Cards and Reds hit with injury bug
Top 10 MLB Player Searches
  1. J. Nelson (2572)
  2. M. Tanaka (2471)
  3. C. Gonzalez (2440)
  4. M. Trumbo (2342)
  5. B. Hamilton (2235)
  1. A. Alcantara (2224)
  2. J. Votto (2222)
  3. V. Martinez (2171)
  4. C. Lee (2021)
  5. C. Beltran (1950)