Skip to content

I wonder if Bonds and Clemens might make the Hall of Fame this year after all

Nov 29, 2012, 11:00 AM EDT

clemens getty Getty Images

My strong presumption is that Barry Bonds and Roger Clemens will not make the Hall of Fame this year. I think, at best, they get about 50% of the vote and stay in that limbo-land until the anti-PED crowd’s fever breaks.

But I just read something that makes me wonder if I’m being too pessimistic. It’s a column from Ian O’Connor of ESPN New York in which he takes the “Bonds and Clemens were so good that you have to vote for them even though they juiced” tack. Kind of a “discounter” argument which, while obviously flawed, makes some degree of sense and allows one to differentiate between guys like McGwire and Palmeiro on the one hand — guys who may not have had Cooperstown numbers without PEDs — and Bonds and Clemens on the other, who were gonna make it regardless.

This is somewhat surprising coming from O’Connor, because he has, in the past, given off all the indications of a “PED use = disqualification” kind of guy.  Back in 2010 he demanded that Mets general manager Sandy Alderson offer a public apology for being complicit in allowing “the monstrous steroid culture to grow fangs on his watch.”  Earlier that year he eviscerated Alex Rodriguez as a player who “cheated the game, cheated the fans and cheated himself” and wrote that nothing could “absolve him of his not-so-venial steroid sins.”

I know there is a vast, silent block of Hall of Fame voters who don’t actively write columns and tweet like O’Connor does and who do not, per their job description, think all that much about baseball.  As such, he may not be truly representative of the electorate and thus it may be premature to view O’Connor’s surprising reasonableness about Bonds and Clemens as some sort of harbinger.

But it is interesting. Very, very interesting.

Latest Posts
  1. The Braves are going to designate Jordan Schafer for assignment

    Aug 1, 2014, 1:04 PM EDT

    Jordan Schafer Getty Images

    Perhaps he and Uggla can join up to fight crime someplace?

  2. Red Sox general manager Ben Cherington begins second roster overhaul

    Aug 1, 2014, 12:48 PM EDT

    Ben Cherington AP

    For the second time in 22 months, Ben Cherington must find a way to turn a last place team into a winner — and fast.

  3. Jurickson Profar has been ruled out for the season

    Aug 1, 2014, 12:16 PM EDT

    Jurickson Profar AP

    Profar held his own as a 20-year-old rookie last season, but shoulder problems sidelined him during spring training and he never got healthy, eventually undergoing surgery.

  4. Dan Uggla will be cut by Giants, might accept demotion to Triple-A

    Aug 1, 2014, 11:49 AM EDT

    uggla giants getty Getty Images

    Despite initial reports to the contrary the Giants have not yet released second baseman Dan Uggla after the Braves castoff went 0-for-11 with six strikeouts and three errors in his first four games for San Francisco.

  5. Dirk Hayhurst’s story of sexual abuse and debauchery in the minors has caused some blowback

    Aug 1, 2014, 11:32 AM EDT

    Dirk Hayhurst

    Many good points have been made. And Hayhurst himself has weighed in with a response.

  6. Manny Machado makes another ridiculous throw

    Aug 1, 2014, 10:47 AM EDT

    Manny Machado AP

    Maybe just stop hitting the ball to third base, Albert.

  7. James Paxton will rejoin the Mariners’ rotation Saturday

    Aug 1, 2014, 10:15 AM EDT

    james paxton getty Getty Images

    Paxton has begun his career by going 5-0 with a 1.75 ERA in six starts dating back to last season’s debut.

  8. Deep Thought: Justin Verlander: playoff relief ace

    Aug 1, 2014, 9:24 AM EDT

    justin verlander getty Getty Images

    He’s probably the fifth starter on this Tigers team at the moment. So why not?

  9. Allen Craig found out he was traded by a TV report; Joe Kelly learned it on Twitter*

    Aug 1, 2014, 8:55 AM EDT

    allen craig getty Getty Images

    A good trade, I think, but it probably wasn’t handled 100% perfectly.

  10. The plate-blocking rule leads to a dumb result once again. And helps cost the Marlins a game.

    Aug 1, 2014, 8:27 AM EDT

    Screen Shot 2014-08-01 at 8.23.06 AM Getty Images

    A rule that was designed to protect catchers is being used as a weapon against them.

  11. And That Happened: Thursday’s scores and highlights

    Aug 1, 2014, 6:35 AM EDT

    Clayton Kershaw Getty Images

    A good day for Clayton Kershaw. A bad day for Cliff Lee, Tyler Skaggs and Eric Hosmer.

  12. Royals could lose Eric Hosmer for month with stress fracture

    Jul 31, 2014, 11:24 PM EDT

    Eric Hosmer Eric Hosmer

    Royals robbed of their hottest hitter after quiet deadline day Thursday.

  13. Cliff Lee placed on DL with recurrence of flexor pronator strain

    Jul 31, 2014, 11:19 PM EDT

    Cliff Lee AP AP

    Cliff Lee has aggravated the flexor pronator strain that has already cost him two months. It’s safe to say that his season is over.

  14. C.J. Wilson expected to return from disabled list Saturday

    Jul 31, 2014, 10:31 PM EDT

    Cliff Lee AP AP

    C.J. Wilson landed on the disabled list earlier this month due to an ankle sprain, but he’s due to rejoin the Angels’ rotation on Saturday.

  15. Winners and losers at the trade deadline

    Jul 31, 2014, 10:12 PM EDT

    A.J. Burnett, Ruben Amaro Jr., Ryne Sandberg A.J. Burnett, Ruben Amaro Jr., Ryne Sandberg

    Keeping score in the aftermath of Thursday’s deadline deals.

  16. Dave Dombrowski sent some fun smack talk to Billy Beane after the David Price deal

    Jul 31, 2014, 9:50 PM EDT

    f674aba0893b522acb1e0a3177608bc1 AP

    The arms race between the Athletics and Tigers is just too much fun.

  17. Tyler Skaggs leaves after 4 2/3 hitless innings due to left forearm tightness

    Jul 31, 2014, 8:59 PM EDT

    Tyler Skaggs Getty Getty Images

    Angels left-hander Tyler Skaggs was working on a no-hitter against the Orioles this evening before he left his start with forearm tightness.

  18. Athletics will go ahead with Yoenis Cespedes t-shirt night even after trade to Red Sox

    Jul 31, 2014, 7:45 PM EDT

    b42a3c37d8e650e611bed40b8ce53060 Getty Images

    Yoenis Cespedes t-shirt night is a little awkward now that he’s with the Red Sox, but the Athletics are going ahead with the giveaway anyway.

Featured video

The Jon Lester-Yoenis Cespedes trade is a win-win
Top 10 MLB Player Searches