Skip to content

The Hall of Fame case for Tim Raines

Dec 5, 2012, 1:44 AM EDT

Tim Raines

I’ve long hesitated to make the Tim Raines Hall of Fame pitch, simply because there’s a website already dedicated to the cause that does a far better job of it than I can here. Still, I figure I can have a quick go at it, and if nothing else, it means a few more people might check out Raines30.com for the better pitch.

Raines’ Hall of Fame problem is Rickey Henderson. Raines might be the second best leadoff hitter off all-time, but he played at the same time as the best. Also, he was a left fielder without much power and he never won an MVP award or came particularly close.

On the other hand, Raines was quite possibly the NL’s best player in a five-year span from 1983-87.  WAR thinks so, placing him ahead of Mike Schmidt, Tony Gwynn and Dale Murphy. Raines hit .318/.406/.467 during that span and averaged 114 runs scored and 71 steals per year. During those five years, only Henderson scored more runs (572-568) and only Wade Boggs had a better OBP (.443 to .406). And those two were playing in the other league.

Raines led the NL in average and OBP in 1986, but 1987 may well have been his best season. After sitting out the first month because of baseball’s collusion against free agents, he hit .330/.429/.526 with 123 runs scored in 139 games. He was so feared that he was intentionally walked 26 times, even though he was one of baseball’s premier basestealers.

Unfortunately, Raines ceased being a superstar pretty young, and while he was still an asset as a role player into his upper-30s, he’s not getting much Hall of Fame credit for those years. The entire body of work is worthy, though. While Raines wasn’t Rickey Henderson, he was a very good match for Tony Gwynn.

Raines finished his career with a .385 OBP, a .425 SLG and a 123 OPS+ in 10,359 PA
Gwynn finished his career with a .388 OBP, a 459 SLG and a 132 OPS+ in 10,232 PA

Raines scored 1,571 runs and drove in 980
Gwynn scored 1,383 runs and drove in 1,138

Raines stole 808 bases and was caught 146 times
Gwynn stole 319 bases and was caught 125 times

B-ref WAR has Raines at 66.2, good for 97th all-time. It has Gwynn at 65.3 wins, 102nd place all-time.

Obviously, it’s commonplace throughout history to trump up one Hall of Fame candidate by matching him with another, typically one barely over the borderline. Gwynn, though, was a sure-fire Hall of Famer, getting in on the first ballot with one of the all-time highest percentage of the votes. And the one real difference between him and Raines was hits. Raines had 2,605 hits and Gwynn had 3,141. That’s a difference of 536. However, Raines had 1,330 walks to Gwynn’s 790, a difference of 540.

I think Raines is also well over what should be the borderline for Cooperstown. He mixed in five years of true greatness into long career in which he was almost always an asset. It’s a career that’s clearly worthy.

Latest Posts
  1. The reason for the collapse of the Brewers-Mets deal? Depends on who you ask.

    Jul 30, 2015, 11:15 AM EDT

    Carlos Gomez Carlos Gomez

    Money? Health? And what the hell is a “hip doctor” anyway?

  2. Miguel Montero wants the Cubs to activate him so he can play through a sprained thumb

    Jul 30, 2015, 10:47 AM EDT

    Miguel Montero Cubs Getty Images

    “If I wait to be 100 percent, it’s going to be season-ending.”

  3. MLB execs “absolutely convinced” that David Price is going to the Dodgers

    Jul 30, 2015, 9:56 AM EDT

    David Price David Price

    A playoff rotation of Kershaw, Greinke and Price would be reDONKulous.

  4. Cardinals, Fox Sports Midwest sign a billion dollar TV deal

    Jul 30, 2015, 9:37 AM EDT

    cardinals logo

    The Cardinals may be small market, but they’re certainly not small revenue.

  5. The Indians trade Brandon Moss to the Cardinals for pitching prospect Rob Kaminsky

    Jul 30, 2015, 9:15 AM EDT

    Brandon Moss Getty Images

    Moss is hitting just .217/.208/.487 this season but he has a line of .254/.340/.504 over the previous three years.

  6. What in the heck happened with the Carlos Gomez-Wilmer Flores trade that wasn’t?

    Jul 30, 2015, 8:45 AM EDT

    Screen Shot 2015-07-30 at 8.42.54 AM

    Even if the deal wasn’t done, the Mets should’ve taken Wilmer Flores out of the game.

  7. Both the Phillies and the Rangers did well in the Cole Hamels trade

    Jul 30, 2015, 7:33 AM EDT

    Ruben Amaro Getty Images

    Trades are judged twice: when they’re made and a couple of years later when we see how they turned out. For now, however, this is a win-win deal for Texas and Philadelphia.

  8. Settling the Scores: Wednesday’s results

    Jul 30, 2015, 7:02 AM EDT

    Gattis Tucker Getty Images

    The Astros regain the lead in the AL West by taking another one from the Angels.

  9. Pirates add Joe Blanton from Royals

    Jul 30, 2015, 1:12 AM EDT

    Kansas City Royals v Chicago White Sox Getty Images

    In a bit of an oddity, two World Series contenders made a trade.

  10. Video: Jose Altuve makes tremendous play at second base

    Jul 29, 2015, 11:31 PM EDT

    Jose Altuve Jose Altuve

    Houston defeated Anaheim 6-3 to jump back into first place in the American League West.

  11. Rangers land ace left-hander Cole Hamels from Phillies

    Jul 29, 2015, 10:46 PM EDT

    Philadelphia at Chicago Cubs Getty Images

    It’s a massive two-team, eight-player blockbuster deal that will net the Phillies a frontline starter for this year and years to come while injecting more young talent into the Phillies’ under-construction minor league system.

  12. Matt Holliday leaves game after re-injuring his right quad

    Jul 29, 2015, 9:31 PM EDT

    St Louis Cardinals v Pittsburgh Pirates AP

    It’s now even more imperative that St. Louis general manager John Mozeliak secures a first baseman before the July 31 trade deadline.

  13. Video: Troy Tulowitzki goes way yard in Blue Jays debut

    Jul 29, 2015, 8:58 PM EDT

    Troy Tulowitzki Troy Tulowitzki

    Troy Tulowitzki struck out swinging in his first Blue Jays at-bat Wednesday night against the Phillies, but he unloaded on this Jerome Williams pitch in his second trip to the plate …

  14. Report: Mets “pushing very hard” for Carlos Gomez

    Jul 29, 2015, 8:12 PM EDT

    Carlos Gomez, Molly Melowski AP

    There’s been a lot of speculation that these two could be a fit, and now it may be close to happening …

  15. Video: Andrew McCutchen hit a Little League home run

    Jul 29, 2015, 7:44 PM EDT

    Andrew McCutchen AP

    Andrew McCutchen launched a traditional two-run homer in the top of the fifth inning Wednesday in the Pirates’ 10-4 rout of the Twins and then went Little League style in the top of the sixth …

  16. Mike Trout out again Wednesday due to left wrist injury

    Jul 29, 2015, 7:01 PM EDT

    Mike Trout AP

    An MRI taken Tuesday ruled out anything serious, but Trout does have a bit of wrist inflammation.

Top 10 MLB Player Searches
  1. C. Hamels (5174)
  2. T. Tulowitzki (3981)
  3. J. Cueto (3756)
  4. A. Rodriguez (3732)
  5. M. Trout (3654)
  1. C. Gonzalez (3362)
  2. C. Gomez (3142)
  3. J. Reyes (3088)
  4. T. Clippard (2981)
  5. D. Price (2860)