Skip to content

The Royals can win this trade even if Myers blossoms — and they can lose it even if he flops

Dec 10, 2012, 9:58 AM EST

Wil Myers Getty Getty Images

Because it’s the Internet overreactions abound with respect to the Royals-Rays trade. Some people are saying this is the dumbest trade ever for the Royals, some saying that they won it. Some are totally overvaluing prospects like Wil Myers, acting as if he’s cant-miss, while some are totally discounting Myers and acting like James Shields is an ace when he is merely a good starter.

My view, as I’ve said a couple of times, is that I think the trade is a bad one for the Royals, and that’s the case even if Myers turns out to be nothing special. That’s because judging the value of this trade from the Royals perspective only with reference to Myers’ future is the wrong way to look at it. Even trades that involve a prospect that goes on to great things can be “won” by the team that traded them away, and even trades that involve a prospect that flops can be lost by that team.

Think back to the trade that is, erroneously, thought of as one of the worst of all time: the Tigers 1987 trade of John Smoltz to the Braves for Doyle Alexander. People slag on that one because Smoltz is probably going into the Hall of Fame someday and Doyle Alexander was out of baseball two years later, ending his career with an 18-loss season.

But the Tigers wanted one thing and one thing only from that trade: they wanted to win the AL East. And, despite trailing the Blue Jays by a game and a half on the day of that deal, they beat ‘em out thanks to Alexander, who went 9-0 with a 1.53 ERA after coming over, including a must-win game against the Jays in game 160.  The Tigers wanted to make the playoffs. They traded off the promise of a prospect (though a not particularly well thought of prospect) in order to do it. Sure, they would have been better off with Smoltz for the next 20 years, but they were trading for 1987, and to a team like the 1987 Tigers — veteran-laden, in win-now mode — 1987 was all that mattered.

Turning to the Royals: trading for James Shields and Wade Davis is a “win-now” move.  They believe that the AL Central is weak and that adding a couple of pitchers will put them in the playoffs. They could be right. I think they need way more than that — they were a 72-win team last season — but that’s the calculus. As such, if Shields and Davis put the Royals in the playoffs for the first time in 27 years, they have accomplished what they set out to accomplish, and that’s the case even if Will Myers turns into a perpetual All-Star. It’s a tradeoff of promise for present, and Dayton Moore is well aware that there is a chance that Myers could be something special. We can disagree with him making that gamble with this Royals team, but that’s what he’s thinking.

But it’s also the case that the Royals could lose this trade if Myers turns into the second coming of Ben Greive and is out of the league before he’s 30. They lose it if what they wanted — that playoff spot — doesn’t come to fruition.

Maybe it won’t matter a ton because in that case Myers wouldn’t have helped much either, but this trade isn’t merely a function of Moore valuing Myers vs. Shields. It’s about Moore getting the Royals to win a lot more games and make the playoffs. And that’s how, from the Royals’ perspective, it should be judged.

Latest Posts
  1. Rusney Castillo suffers left side injury

    Mar 3, 2015, 10:57 PM EST

    rusney castillo getty Getty Images

    It was a successful afternoon in pretty much every way at Fenway South. Except maybe one …

  2. Yankees prospect Luis Torrens needs shoulder surgery

    Mar 3, 2015, 9:44 PM EST

    yankees logo

    The expectation is that he will have to sit out the entire 2015 season.

  3. Orioles sign Pedro Beato to minor league contract

    Mar 3, 2015, 8:31 PM EST

    beato getty Getty Images

    The deal does not include an invitation to major league spring training, so Beato won’t be under consideration for one of the spots in the Orioles’ Opening Day bullpen.

  4. Video: Yoenis Cespedes launches grand slam in Grapefruit League debut with Tigers

    Mar 3, 2015, 7:28 PM EST

    cespedes getty Getty Images

    Yoenis Cespedes made his presence felt around Tigers camp with this fourth-inning grand slam in Tuesday afternoon’s Grapefruit League opener against the visiting Orioles …

  5. Video: Jung-Ho Kang homers in Pirates debut

    Mar 3, 2015, 5:46 PM EST

    jung-ho kang getty Getty Images

    Kang hit .356 with 40 homers in Korea last season.

  6. Noah Syndergaard just learned not to eat his lunch in the clubhouse during a game

    Mar 3, 2015, 4:15 PM EST

    Noah Syndergaard Getty Images

    Because, if he does, David Wright and Bobby Parnell are gonna go kick his butt.

  7. Madison Bumgarner didn’t exactly start 2015 the way he ended 2014

    Mar 3, 2015, 3:54 PM EST

    Madison Bumgarner

    Unless someone gets injured, spring training game results don’t matter a bit. But they are a reminder that everyone starts from square one each season. No matter how well they ended the season before.

  8. Former batting champion Alex Johnson dies at age 72

    Mar 3, 2015, 3:15 PM EST

    Alex Johnson Angels

    Johnson made the All-Star team in 1970 and went on to win the batting championship by hitting .329, marking his third straight season with a batting average above .300.

  9. Spring training quotes: Pants on, pants off

    Mar 3, 2015, 2:10 PM EST

    Miguel Cabrera AP AP

    Baseball has officially started, but opinions on pants vary.

  10. The Pirates have new matte batting helmets and they’re amazing

    Mar 3, 2015, 1:34 PM EST

    Gregory Polanco AP

    Also: there is baseball — honest to goodness baseball — on TV right now.

  11. Meanwhile in Maryvale: Brewers starters have some sweet bathrobes

    Mar 3, 2015, 12:30 PM EST

    Brewers logo

    As a man who knows from hanging around in loungewear all day, I can tell you: this is cool.

  12. Don Mattingly says Jimmy Rollins will be the Dodgers’ leadoff man

    Mar 3, 2015, 12:06 PM EST

    Jimmy Rollins AP

    Not exactly a ringing endorsement, but whatever.

  13. Joba Chamberlain’s son had a lot to do with him signing back with the Tigers

    Mar 3, 2015, 11:03 AM EST

    Joba Chamberlain Getty Images

    The million a year helped, but Chamberlain’s son provided the definitive push back to Detroit.

  14. Sandy Alderson shoots down Dillon Gee trade rumors

    Mar 3, 2015, 10:48 AM EST

    Dillon Gee Getty Getty Images

    Mets general manager Sandy Alderson was asked about a Dillon Gee trade rumor that made the internet rounds Monday night.

  15. Twins working on a contract extension with Brian Dozier

    Mar 3, 2015, 10:10 AM EST

    Brian Dozier AP

    Dozier is making the minimum salary for this season and would then be under team control via arbitration for 2016-2018.

Top 10 MLB Player Searches
  1. A. Wainwright (2439)
  2. M. Upton (2432)
  3. A. Simmons (2422)
  4. F. Rodriguez (2360)
  5. C. Hamels (2169)