Skip to content

No, Hideki Matsui is not a Hall of Famer

Dec 28, 2012, 9:54 AM EDT

File picture shows New York Yankees' Matsui speaking to reporters during "workout day" before MLB's 2009 World Series between New York Yankees and Philadelphia Phillies in New York

This should probably go without saying, but no, Hideki Matsui is not a Hall of Famer.

There is some level of debate about this. Not because anyone truly thinks that Matsui’s ten seasons in the bigs were Hall of Fame-worthy. They clearly were not, even if they were pretty damn good (note: the go-to phrase for Matsui, which I have used myself, appears to be “a nice career” or a “damn nice career” or something like that).

Rather, to the extent anyone is making a Hall of Fame case for Matsui, they’re doing so by mashing together his NPB stats with his MLB stats. If you do that, sure, we’re a heck of a lot closer, for that gives him three MVP awards, three more championship rings to go with his 2009 World Series ring, 332 more home runs, 889 more RBIs and a streak of 1,250 consecutive games played (and he played every game for the Yankees in his first three seasons in the U.S.).  I’d say that is a Hall of Fame resume, indeed.

But the thing is, we just can’t do that. Both for official reasons and logical reasons.

Officially, the Hall of Fame takes the position that is a National Hall of Fame — that’s even the name of the place — meaning baseball accomplishments which took place in America. Indeed, aside from Negro League players, the Hall asks its voters to only consider accomplishments achieved in Major League Baseball. If it didn’t, statboys like me would be making Hall of Fame cases for Roberto Petagine and guys like that (and believe me, we would, for we crush hard on those kinds of guys).

But it makes logical sense to exclude NPB stats too: it’s simply not the same level of competition as we see in MLB. Most folks who pay close attention to these things consider to the Japanese leagues, at best, to be a 4-A kind of thing, and others believe it is more on par with Triple-A. If you don’t believe this just look at what has happened to most of the good Japanese hitters who have come to the U.S. Yes, there are success stories like Matsui and Ichiro, but there are far more flame outs. It’s just not the same hitting environment for these dudes.

I understand why a lot of people don’t simply dismiss the stats. Especially given that it has become fashionable to talk about Ichiro’s hit totals between the NPB and MLB when assessing his career (note: Ichiro, I feel, is a Hall of Famer based on his U.S. production alone, making this argument moot). But U.S. and Japanese baseball are two different beasts, and it doesn’t make a lot of sense to consider what Matsui or anyone else did in the NPB when making their Hall of Fame case.

Latest Posts
  1. 10 nominees for Hall of Fame’s Veterans Committee announced

    Oct 30, 2014, 2:07 PM EDT

    minoso

    Minnie Minoso, Tony Oliva and Ken Boyer are among those back on the 2014 ballot.

  2. Yankees interested in Raul Ibanez … as a coach

    Oct 30, 2014, 1:49 PM EDT

    Division Series - Baltimore Orioles v New York Yankees - Game Three Getty Images

    New York has not hired a replacement for fired hitting coach Kevin Long yet and they also have an opening at first base coach after letting Mick Kelleher go.

  3. Phillies decline 2015 option on Mike Adams

    Oct 30, 2014, 1:15 PM EDT

    Washington Nationals v Philadelphia Phillies Getty Images

    Adams threw 44 innings in two seasons for the Phillies.

  4. What’s in store for the Royals this winter?

    Oct 30, 2014, 12:49 PM EDT

    Dayton Moore, Ned Yost Dayton Moore, Ned Yost

    A look at the tough calls the Royals will have to make following their World Series run.

  5. Flashback to 2010: Everyone was worried about Madison Bumgarner

    Oct 30, 2014, 12:16 PM EDT

    Madison Bumgarner AP

    “He’s 20 years old. We think a lot of him and he has a bright future.”

  6. Marlins will pick up Jeff Mathis’ option for 2015

    Oct 30, 2014, 11:48 AM EDT

    Jeff Mathis AP AP

    Mathis a career .196 hitter and has never topped a .650 OPS in nine seasons as a big leaguer.

  7. Royals likely to decline Billy Butler’s option, but will he re-sign for less?

    Oct 30, 2014, 11:17 AM EDT

    Kansas City Royals v Chicago White Sox Reuters

    He’s the longest-tenured Royal, but his production has slipped.

  8. Royals planned to use Danny Duffy in the playoff rotation, but he was hurt

    Oct 30, 2014, 10:35 AM EDT

    Danny Duffy Getty Images

    “Obviously, he definitely would have been one of our starters.”

  9. Giants on re-signing Sandoval: ‘We’ll do the best we can’

    Oct 30, 2014, 10:20 AM EDT

    cd0ymzcznguwzdbhnduynddiytjhm2yyzthlmtjjotqwyyznpwqznwrhnzixzjqwmty2zjnmmda2odg3mwu0yjrmngqy AP

    Asked about his free agency, Panda only says: “I’m just going to celebrate.”

  10. Bochy’s championship resume ranks among game’s best

    Oct 30, 2014, 9:50 AM EDT

    Bruce Bochy Bruce Bochy

    Bochy has navigated the path to World Series crowns in 2010, 2012 and now 2014. In the process, the Giants have dispatched 10 consecutive postseason foes.

  11. Only thing Royals can do: Tip cap to Bumgarner

    Oct 30, 2014, 9:20 AM EDT

    Madison Bumgarner Madison Bumgarner

    There was no bitterness as Royals hitters talked about the mastery of Madison Bumgarner in this World Series.

  12. Alex Rodriguez, Barry Bonds celebrate the conclusion of the World Series

    Oct 30, 2014, 7:25 AM EDT

    Alex Rodriguez Getty Images

    History’s Greatest Monsters were happy for different reasons last night.

  13. Inside the Giants’ clubhouse …

    Oct 30, 2014, 12:15 AM EDT

    1bochy getty Getty Images

    The champagne and beer is flowing in the visitors clubhouse at Kauffman Stadium following the Giants’ Game 7 win …

  14. Alex Gordon would have been a dead duck had he tried to score

    Oct 30, 2014, 12:11 AM EDT

    Gordon 1

    A breakdown of Alex Gordon’s two-out hit in the bottom of the ninth.

  15. Video: Pablo Sandoval catches final out in foul territory, Giants win 2014 World Series

    Oct 29, 2014, 11:57 PM EDT

    giants world series getty Getty Images

    Here’s the final out of Wednesday night’s Game 7 that secured the Giants’ eighth World Series title …

  16. Madison Bumgarner named World Series MVP … obviously

    Oct 29, 2014, 11:37 PM EDT

    1bumgarner getty Getty Images

    Madison Bumgarner threw five scoreless innings to close out Game 7 on Wednesday night at Kauffman Stadium and allowed just one run in 21 total frames during the 2014 World Series

  17. Game 7 live blog: The Giants are World Series Champions!

    Oct 29, 2014, 11:20 PM EDT

    Madison Bumgarner Getty Images

    Madison Bumgarner gets the win. And becomes a legend.

Top 10 MLB Player Searches
  1. M. Morse (2244)
  2. H. Pence (2177)
  3. Y. Cespedes (2091)
  4. M. Moustakas (2003)
  5. J. Panik (1979)