Skip to content

Nah, there’s nothing wrong with the Hall of Fame voting process

Jan 4, 2013, 11:01 AM EDT

cooperstown

Except for the fact that three writers — not one, not two but three writers — from something called “GolfersWest.com” have Hall of Fame votes. And justify votes for some guys by saying things like “[a]dmitted bias here, as I covered [player] for his entire career …”

But fine, the GolfersWest.com did cover baseball for a long time and their ballots are not awful or anything. But gee whiz this is a bit much:

As for bias, that part is correct. We have the responsibility as to who gets in, so that gives us a natural bias toward doing it correctly. We stand by the door like a nightclub bouncer behind the velvet rope. We check IDs. We check authenticity. We compare those already in to those standing on the doorstep. For better or worse, we are to ones who approve the credentials. Yea or nay. That job has been entrusted to us and our bias tends to bend toward merit, not whim.

Today Joe Sheehan — whose newsletter is fabulous and to which you should subscribe — said the following:

This is the year, I would say, that the Hall of Fame voting ceased to be about the players and became, wholly, about the writers.

I’ve seen nothing to dissuade me of that notion.

There are probably a dozen dudes on the ballot this year who far exceed historical precedent for induction. If the patterns shown among publicly-released ballots so far, absolutely none are getting in.  All because a bunch of writers who, once upon a time, covered baseball for a living have decided that they are neither reporters nor historians nor analysts, but bouncers at Studio 54.  Just fabulous.

Latest Posts
  1. FOX Sports San Diego has been doing a good job with their “Keys to the Game”

    May 2, 2015, 11:55 PM EDT

    Justin Upton, Bud Black Justin Upton, Bud Black

    Are those “Keys to the Game” segments getting stale? FOX Sports San Diego put a fresh spin on it.

  2. Video: Giants win when batted ball hits Angels’ runner for the final out

    May 2, 2015, 8:45 PM EDT

    Tim Hudson Tim Hudson

    A stroke of luck bailed the Giants out in the ninth inning when their bullpen went into meltdown mode.

  3. Hall of Famer Pedro Martinez explains how he would pitch to Mike Trout

    May 2, 2015, 7:55 PM EDT

    Pedro Martinez

    One of the best pitchers in baseball history tells us how he’d approach the best player of this generation.

  4. Video: Logan Schafer scores on a little league home run against the Cubs

    May 2, 2015, 7:05 PM EDT

    Logan Schafer Logan Schafer

    The Cubs had an unfortunate series of events lead to a little league home run for Brewers outfielder Logan Schafer.

  5. Red Sox manager John Farrell doesn’t expect Ryan Hanigan back before the All-Star break

    May 2, 2015, 6:10 PM EDT

    Ryan Hanigan Ryan Hanigan

    Catcher Ryan Hanigan figures to be out until the All-Star break, according to Red Sox manager John Farrell.

  6. Chad Billingsley set to join Phillies’ rotation on Tuesday

    May 2, 2015, 5:29 PM EDT

    Chad Billingsley AP

    Billingsley hasn’t pitched in the majors in over two years.

  7. Athletics designate Cody Ross for assignment

    May 2, 2015, 4:46 PM EDT

    Seattle Mariners v Oakland Athletics Getty Images

    Ross went just 2-for-22 (.091) with three RBI over nine games during his brief stint with Oakland.

  8. Albert Pujols returns to Angels’ starting lineup

    May 2, 2015, 4:14 PM EDT

    Los Angeles Angels of Anaheim v Oakland Athletics Getty Images

    Albert Pujols missed two days after leaving Wednesday’s game due to left hamstring tightness, but he’s back in the starting lineup today against the Giants. While he’ll return to his standard No. 3 spot, Angels manager Mike Scioscia has made some changes with his lineup.

  9. Yankees GM Brian Cashman acknowledges team won’t pay A-Rod $6 million bonus for 660th home run

    May 2, 2015, 3:18 PM EDT

    Alex Rodriguez AP

    Yankees general manager Brian Cashman acknowledged Saturday that the team won’t pay a $6 million marketing bonus to Alex Rodriguez for tying Willie Mays with 660 career home runs.

  10. Christian Yelich to begin minor league rehab assignment Sunday

    May 2, 2015, 2:40 PM EDT

    yelich getty Getty Images

    Yelich has been sidelined since April 19 with a bulging disk in his lower back.

  11. Matt Moore cleared to throw to hitters for first time since Tommy John surgery

    May 2, 2015, 1:50 PM EDT

    Matt Moore Getty Getty Images

    The Rays are hoping that Moore will be ready to return around the middle of June.

  12. Brewers activate Carlos Gomez from disabled list

    May 2, 2015, 1:04 PM EDT

    Carlos Gomez Carlos Gomez

    Gomez has been out since April 15 due to a strained right hamstring.

  13. Pedro Martinez says in new book that Mets COO Jeff Wilpon urged him to pitch hurt

    May 2, 2015, 12:03 PM EDT

    Philadelphia Phillies v New York Mets Getty Images

    Wilpon denies the claim that he urged Martinez to pitch hurt in 2005.

  14. Yasiel Puig expected to go on a minor league rehab assignment next week

    May 2, 2015, 11:05 AM EDT

    Los Angeles Dodgers v San Francisco Giants Getty Images

    Puig is currently sidelined with a strained left hamstring, but he’s nearing his return to the Dodgers.

  15. Willie Mays congratulates Alex Rodriguez for reaching 660 career home runs

    May 2, 2015, 10:10 AM EDT

    Alex Rodriguez AP

    Willie Mays issued a statement to congratulate Alex Rodriguez for tying him on the all-time home run list.

  16. Video: Nelson Cruz hit a home run off the train at Minute Maid Park

    May 2, 2015, 9:35 AM EDT

    nelson cruz getty Getty Images

    Another day, another tape-measure blast for Nelson Cruz.

Top 10 MLB Player Searches
  1. J. Hamilton (3761)
  2. A. Rendon (3020)
  3. J. Lowrie (2944)
  4. A. Colome (2898)
  5. C. Gomez (2778)