Skip to content

If you judge a players’ character, you have to acknowledge the forces which shaped his choices

Jan 8, 2013, 4:26 PM EDT

Ken Caminiti

Tom Verducci has a major piece on PEDs and baseball today, all of which serves as a preface to his Hall of Fame choices.

Obviously he and I disagree on the issue, but his take is cogent, well-reasoned and strong. Which makes sense given that Verducci was way, way ahead of all of his media brethren when it came to reporting on steroids and has thought about the matter more than just once a year when his Hall of Fame ballot shows up.  If you consider PED use to be a disqualifier for the Hall of Fame, you basically have to follow Verducci’s lead here: presume innocence, then act on actual information or evidence rather than playing parlor games.

But I do take issue with Verducci when he takes the exceptions to his position one-by-one.  He does an acceptable job explaining his differences with the “it wasn’t against the rules,” “everybody did it” and “the Hall of Fame already has bad apples” arguments.  Again, I disagree as a matter of opinion on some of these points, but I think his position is a coherent one based on the opinion he holds.

I think he errs, however, by portraying baseball players as having made the free, moral choice to either take drugs or not take drugs, consulting only their conscience and a syringe. That’s because steroids in baseball was never just about players’ choices, but the knowing acquiescence of clubs and the league as well, and that necessarily impacted players’ choices, no doubt forcing many of them to make bad choices.

Indeed, the Mitchell Report detailed instances of clubs being well-aware of players’ steroid use, but only caring about it insofar as the player going off the juice may hurt his production. Managers, coaches and front office players knew or should have known about it and did nothing. Well, they profited from them of course, but they never, to my knowledge, punished a single player for violating the rules Verducci so clearly explains everyone was well aware of.

I don’t offer this as just another excuse — “hey, no one else cared, so why should we?”  To the contrary, this is important specifically to those who do care. People like Verducci, in fact. Because if you take seriously the ethical and moral choices players made, you have to appreciate the context in which those choices were made. Yes, some players probably sat back and said “hell, I wanna hit more homers.” But many more likely felt the pressure to take steroids to save their jobs or solidify their careers with the full knowledge that their clubs would reward the performers and punish the non-performers, with no questions asked about the provenance of that performance whatsoever.

I don’t think we should be judging players’ character in the first place, but if you do judge one’s character, I don’t see how the prisoners’ dilemma into which many players were thrust can’t change the calculus for you to some degree.

Latest Posts
  1. Red Sox call up Jackie Bradley Jr. from Triple-A

    Apr 28, 2015, 3:20 PM EDT

    Jackie Bradley Jr AP

    Mookie Betts has started 18 of 20 games in center field.

  2. The Orioles will play to no fans tomorrow; this weekend’s series will move to Tropicana Field

    Apr 28, 2015, 2:49 PM EDT

    orioles logo

    The disruption to the Orioles’ schedule is pretty darn interesting.

  3. The Phillies option Domonic Brown to Triple-A

    Apr 28, 2015, 1:42 PM EDT

    Domonic Brown Domonic Brown

    The former All-Star and former prospect is back in the bush leagues.

  4. Kirk Gibson has Parkinson’s Disease

    Apr 28, 2015, 12:32 PM EDT

    Arizona Diamondbacks Photo Day Getty Images

    Awful news for one of baseball’s toughest customers.

  5. Dodgers outfield depth? Carl Crawford has an oblique injury

    Apr 28, 2015, 12:16 PM EDT

    NLCS - St Louis Cardinals v Los Angeles Dodgers Getty Images

    Crawford may be joining Yasiel Puig on the shelf.

  6. The White Sox and Orioles are postponed once again

    Apr 28, 2015, 11:36 AM EDT

    Baltimore AP

    Baseball takes a back seat as unrest continues in Baltimore.

  7. A scary trip home from the ballpark in Baltimore

    Apr 28, 2015, 11:19 AM EDT

    orioles logo

    CSNBaltimore.com’s Orioles beat reporter Rich Dubroff on his experience Monday night.

  8. Jed Lowrie leaves Astros to have MRI on injured thumb

    Apr 28, 2015, 10:47 AM EDT

    Jed Lowrie Astros Getty Images

    Returning to Houston as a free agent on a three-year, $23 million contract, Lowrie is off to a very strong start.

  9. A fan was injured by a flying bat at the Pirates-Cubs game last night

    Apr 28, 2015, 10:30 AM EDT

    Screen Shot 2015-04-28 at 10.17.58 AM Getty Images

    The fan was taken from Wrigley Field in an ambulance.

  10. Nationals prospect A.J. Cole will make his MLB debut in place of injured Max Scherzer

    Apr 28, 2015, 10:15 AM EDT

    A.J. Cole Nationals AP

    In calling up Cole for his debut the Nationals bypassed Tanner Roark.

  11. Video: Joc Pederson made a fantastic catch — and throw — last night

    Apr 28, 2015, 8:59 AM EDT

    joc pederson getty Getty Images

    Note to Nori Aoki: if the ball is heading to center field against the Dodgers, you want to get back to the bag more quickly.

  12. Blue Jays place Jose Reyes on disabled list with cracked rib

    Apr 28, 2015, 12:17 AM EDT

    Toronto Blue Jays v New York Yankees Getty Images

    Jose Reyes has been trying to play through a small crack in his left rib, but he’ll now get an extended absence.

  13. VIDEO: Daniel Murphy hits go-ahead three-run homer as Mets stun Marlins

    Apr 27, 2015, 11:01 PM EDT

    Daniel Murphy, Lucas Duda AP

    The Mets are now 15-5 on the young season and already hold an eight-game lead over the Nationals in the National League East.

  14. Anthony Rendon scratched from rehab game due to fatigue

    Apr 27, 2015, 10:03 PM EDT

    anthony rendon getty Getty Images

    The Nationals mapped out a plan that could have had Rendon make his season debut as soon as Thursday against the Mets, but that’s on hold for now.

  15. Report: Marlins talking to five teams about a trade involving Jarrod Saltalamacchia

    Apr 27, 2015, 9:04 PM EDT

    Miami Marlins v New York Mets Getty Images

    The Diamondbacks are reportedly among the potential landing spots for Saltalamacchia.

  16. Homer Bailey headed to DL with right elbow ligament sprain

    Apr 27, 2015, 8:10 PM EDT

    cD05ODdlNmNhY2MwMjRlZWQzNTJhM2ViYTQ1Y2VlY2YzOCZnPTk2MDdiZDc5ZmVlNDdhZTEwZDA0NTU3OTdkODA1ZTAw Getty Images

    Bailey is coming off flexor tendon surgery. Could Tommy John surgery be next?

Top 10 MLB Player Searches
  1. Y. Puig (2789)
  2. B. Zobrist (2724)
  3. D. Travis (2704)
  4. A. Rendon (2686)
  5. D. Mesoraco (2672)