Skip to content

George Mitchell speaks. And in doing so, illuminates how useless The Mitchell Report really was.

Jan 30, 2013, 3:35 PM EDT

George Mitchell

George Mitchell, the man behind and namesake of the Mitchell Report, was on Chuck Todd’s show on MSNBC this morning to talk about the latest PED business out of Miami.  He said something pretty sensible:

“Every society has laws against robbery and murder, yet everyone knows that robbery and murder are not going to end. It’s managing an ongoing human problem. That’s the case with performance-enhancing drugs. It’s a problem of…keeping pace, reducing the incentives to use and…increasing vigilance, regulation and punishment for those who use.”

Sensible, but unfortunately we don’t treat it like that. Instead, we treat it as a scandal/parlor game in which we care more about the names of users for their own sake than we do about the underlying problem and spend far more mental effort on the former than the latter.

Of course the reason we do that is because of George Mitchell’s report itself.  It was the Mitchell Report which set the tone of how we discuss PEDs in baseball. It was the Mitchell Report which decided that the most interesting and important thing about steroids in baseball was who used and who didn’t as opposed to how PEDs get into the game, what they mean for the game, how they damage it and how they damage the users.  It did so by having as its climax a woefully incomplete naming of names — and it was the names that got all of the press — as opposed to anything approaching a real understanding of the issue.  It was George Mitchell who took Jose Canseco’s lead and turned PEDs into a gotcha game as opposed to using his report as a means of giving us a better understanding of PEDs and their role in baseball.

And that’s not a trivial concern.  Because if Mitchell is right about PEDs being a chronic, human problem, it would be a much easier problem to get at if we did not have a culture in which 98% of the energy involved in any PED story was dedicated to naming a name as opposed to understanding the circumstances at play. It would be easier to combat PEDs if we understood any of the following factors (which I’ve identified in the past), none of which the Mitchell Report was at all interested in exploring:

  • How often do players use?
  • What’s the profile of an average user?
  • When do users actually start using? High school? College? In the minors? After making The Show?
  • Is drug use a personal thing? Specifically, do guys decide on their own, based on their own personal experiences to use steroids, or is it a peer pressure thing in which certain clubhouses or cliques within them promote a “steroid culture?”
  • How do players connect with their dealers? Word of mouth, or do the dealers seek out their customers?
  • What dealers — besides the dumb ones named in the Mitchell Report who took personal checks and shipped drugs to ballparks — are the big players, as opposed to which players are the big users?
  • Are non-users choir boys who have moral objections, or does the fear of the dangers of steroids and/or a belief that they simply don’t need them inform their decision making?
  • What impact do steroids have on actual performance, both actual and perceived?

These are questions which were never answered and never asked by the Mitchell Report. Indeed, the Mitchell Report and everything that has followed has evinced a profound lack of curiosity about such topics. Mitchell gave drug dealers immunity and focused on ratting out those who were in the best position to educate Major League Baseball about the nature of its drug problem.

We study crimes like the ones Mitchell mentions in order to figure out why they happen and how best to combat them. Those studies do much to inform our law enforcement strategies.  They go together.  But George Mitchell and Major League Baseball — by treating the players like criminals rather than resources at the time of the Mitchell Report — blew their best chance to truly get a handle on the problem of performance enhancing drugs.  Baseball has been playing catch-up ever since.

As I mentioned yesterday, baseball has done a pretty good job playing catch-up. It has taken over five years, but it’s getting there.  One wonders where we’d be, however, if George Mitchell hadn’t blown it so spectacularly with his famous, should-be infamous report.

Latest Posts
  1. Must-click Link: the challenges Major League Baseball faces in implementing a domestic violence policy

    Sep 16, 2014, 10:10 AM EDT

    Bud Selig AP

    Ken Rosenthal shows us that the task, however necessary, will not be easy.

  2. A-Rod unlikely to be charged in the Biogenesis case

    Sep 16, 2014, 9:46 AM EDT

    Alex Rodriguez Alex Rodriguez

    To baseball and baseball writers, A-Rod is still Whitey Bulger or Public Enemy Number One. To the cops, he’s just a kid who bought a bag of something.

  3. Marcus Stroman should be suspended for throwing at Caleb Joseph’s head

    Sep 16, 2014, 9:16 AM EDT

    Screen Shot 2014-09-16 at 8.09.58 AM

    MLB acts swiftly when someone grabs their crotch. Let’s see how swiftly it acts when a guy goes headhunting.

  4. Jonathan Papelbon’s suspension could possibly save the Phillies $13 million

    Sep 16, 2014, 8:55 AM EDT

    Screen Shot 2014-09-15 at 11.33.53 AM AP

    With this gesture, Jonathan Papelbon made triggering his 2016 option a tad tricker.

  5. Yasiel Puig, Matt Kemp exchange words in the dugout

    Sep 16, 2014, 8:23 AM EDT

    Puig Kemp

    I have to imagine that spending seven-plus months in close quarters with Yasiel Puig can get on one’s nerves.

  6. And That Happened: Monday’s scores and highlights

    Sep 16, 2014, 6:52 AM EDT

    Screen Shot 2014-09-16 at 6.50.57 AM AP

    The Angels clinch a playoff spot. The Nats and Orioles pull to within one game of clinching their divisions.

  7. VIDEO: Royals utilize speed for walk-off win against White Sox; keep pace with Tigers

    Sep 16, 2014, 12:09 AM EDT

    royals

    Pinch-runners Jarrod Dyson and Terrance Gore proved to be the difference in a thrilling win for Kansas City.

  8. Albert Pujols leaves game with hamstring cramp

    Sep 15, 2014, 11:29 PM EDT

    Albert Pujols AP AP

    Pujols suffered the injury while running to second base on a three-run double.

  9. Giants activate Brandon Belt from disabled list

    Sep 15, 2014, 11:09 PM EDT

    Brandon Belt Brandon Belt

    Belt has been limited to just five games since July 19 due to concussion symptoms.

  10. Anibal Sanchez could return as a reliever

    Sep 15, 2014, 10:25 PM EDT

    Anibal Sanchez Getty Getty Images

    Sanchez has been sidelined since early August with a right pectoral strain.

  11. MLB suspends Jonathan Papelbon seven games for incident during Sunday’s game

    Sep 15, 2014, 9:21 PM EDT

    Jonathan Papelbon Getty Getty Images

    Papelbon made a lewd gesture at fans and had a confrontation with umpire Joe West during Sunday’s game.

  12. Bryce Harper exits game after feeling lightheaded

    Sep 15, 2014, 8:35 PM EDT

    Bryce Harper Getty Getty Images

    Harper struck out in his lone at-bat in the top of the second inning before Nate Schierholtz replaced him as a pinch-hitter in the fourth inning.

  13. Ryan Zimmerman hoping to rejoin Nationals for final week

    Sep 15, 2014, 8:15 PM EDT

    Miami Marlins v Washington Nationals AP

    He last played on July 22 and previously missed time with shoulder problems that have plagued him, but he did hit .282 with five homers and an .802 OPS in 53 games when healthy enough to be in the lineup.

  14. VIDEO: Jacob deGrom begins game with eight straight strikeouts to tie MLB record

    Sep 15, 2014, 7:59 PM EDT

    Jacob deGrom Getty AP

    Jim DeShaies previously did it with the Astros in a start against the Dodgers on September 23, 1986.

  15. Danny Duffy not expected to rejoin Royals’ rotation until next Monday

    Sep 15, 2014, 7:35 PM EDT

    Danny Duffy AP

    Duffy hasn’t pitched since September 6 due to rotator cuff inflammation.

  16. Bud Selig says MLB and players union will meet this week about domestic abuse policy

    Sep 15, 2014, 7:04 PM EDT

    Bud Selig Getty Getty Images

    The union must sign off on a policy before any changes are put into effect.

  17. Hyun-Jin Ryu does not have structural damage, could be available for playoffs

    Sep 15, 2014, 6:48 PM EDT

    Hyun-Jin Ryu Hyun-Jin Ryu

    Dodgers left-hander Hyun-Jin Ryu exited his Friday start after just one inning with shoulder pain, but an MRI revealed relatively positive news: Ryu does not have structural damage and has been diagnosed with inflammation.

  18. Matt Harvey throws simulated game, takes break until 2015

    Sep 15, 2014, 6:30 PM EDT

    Matt Harvey Getty Getty Images

    “Everything we were trying to accomplish this season has been accomplished.”

  19. Evan Gattis missing seventh straight game with strep throat

    Sep 15, 2014, 6:15 PM EDT

    Gattis Getty Getty Images

    Gattis met with team doctors Monday in attempt to find an answer with his illness.

Featured video

Papelbon destined to be traded?
Top 10 MLB Player Searches
  1. G. Stanton (3565)
  2. B. Belt (2337)
  3. A. Rizzo (2324)
  4. J. Hamilton (2071)
  5. C. Young (2060)
  1. R. Castillo (2042)
  2. B. Gardner (2004)
  3. H. Ryu (1933)
  4. A. Pujols (1855)
  5. C. Kershaw (1773)