Skip to content

Revisiting Trout vs. Cabrera MVP debate — with a twist

Mar 4, 2013, 1:24 PM EDT

g-sport-121116-troutcabrera.nbcsports-story-612 Reuters

So, get ready for a bit of a shocker. I was on a panel with Farhan Zaidi of the Oakland A’s. He’s a great guy. A’s general manager Billy Beane often calls him “Emotional Stat Guy,” which he says will be the name of his fantasy baseball team (though I personally think it would be a better band name.*) Zaidi is utterly brilliant — economics degree from MIT, Ph.D from Cal Berkeley in economics — and a lot of fun to talk with about baseball.

*Zaidi told a great story about his interview with Billy Beane, who he idolized. It was 2003, and he was doing some consulting and fantasy sports work — basically, he was overqualified for whatever he was doing. He heard about an Oakland opening. He fished out an old resume and, without really reviewing it, sent it off to Billy Beane. One thing he had forgotten was that in the personal section of the resume, he had mentioned that he liked Britpop — you know, Suede, Sleeper, Oasis, a bunch of those Wonderwall bands that were cool in certain circles in the mid-to-late 1990s. Unfortunately, it was now 2003.

First thing Beane said to Zaidi was, “So, I understand you like Britpop.” Zaidi felt his face go white hot as he sunk into his chair. He started to hem and haw about how he had not updated his resume in a while and that, you know, er, well, it’s just kind of …

At which point, Billy Beane said: “I am the biggest Oasis fan.”

How that scene was left out of Moneyball, I’ll never know.

So before the panel began, we were talking about all sorts of things, when the 2012 American League MVP argument came up. Yes, we’re still talking about it. In very general terms, the argument seemed to split baseball fans between those who embrace the new baseball metrics and those who do not.

That’s a sweeping generalization and does not tell the full story — there were brilliant mathematicians in the Cabrera camp and staunch traditionalists in the Trout camp. But in general terms, the traditional statistics (Triple Crown!) and general principles pointed to Cabrera. And the advanced statistics seemed to show that Trout wasn’t just better than Cabrera but markedly better.

Baseball Reference WAR

Trout: 10.7 WAR
Cabrera: 6.9 WAR

Fangraphs WAR

Trout: 10.0 WAR
Cabrera: 7.1 WAR

That isn’t all that close. Basically WAR — and some other advances metrics — showed that whatever advantages Cabrera had in terms of power and batting average and timely hitting were swamped by Trout’s advantages as a fielder, base runner and player who gets on base. The argument made sense to many of us who champion the advanced statistics and their power to get closer to a player’s true value.

The Cabrera arguments, for the most part, were more about gut instinct, intangibles and the power of old statistics. Cabrera won the Triple Crown. Cabrera hit better down the stretch. Cabrera’s team made the playoffs. These arguments made sense to many baseball fans.

The two sides basically talked around each other for months. The gut arguments meant nothing at all to the sabermetric people, who feel like those gut arguments are shallow and often wildly off. The sabermetric arguments meant nothing at all to the people who do not trust a lot of these new statistics and feel like they are draining the fun out of the game. Back and forth it went, but neither side seemed to move any closer together.

Zaidi and I were talking about this when he told me something that I found utterly staggering. He said that Oakland’s objective model for measuring a player’s value — remember now, we are talking about the Oakland A’s, the Moneyball people, Jonah Hill and so on — found that Miguel Cabrera, NOT Mike Trout, was more valuable in 2012.

More from Sloan: Finding peace with WAR

Well, that’s not exactly right. He was quick to say that the difference between the two was so slight as to be almost invisible — they were, for an intents and purposes, in a virtual tie. But their system did have Cabrera ahead by the tiniest of margins.

I thought that was a pretty big deal. I know last year, a lot of people were spending a lot of energy trying to find a convincing statistical model that showed Cabrera was better than Trout. If there was one, I didn’t see it. Now, it turns out that Oakland (Oakland!) has such a statistical model.

We did not have time to get into details — and Zaidi might not have done that anyway since the A’s model for measuring players is proprietary — but I think the point comes through. Statistics are tools. People use tools differently. People see the world differently. Give someone a pen and paper, she or he might sketch out a breathtaking mathematical formula … or scribble a prescription … or write down the amazing story of a young boy who has discovered he is a wizard … or a sketch of a flying car … or draw a Calvin and Hobbes panel  … or a million other things.

Give a lot of different smart people the Miguel Cabrera and Mike Trout data, you should get different ways of using that data. And you just might get different answers. It’s an important thing to remember, I think.

My sense, based on my reading of the numbers, Trout was better than Cabrera. I also readily concede Zaidi and the people in the Oakland front office are a lot smarter than I am.

Latest Posts
  1. Video: Jorge Soler robbed Khris Davis of a home run

    Aug 2, 2015, 9:30 AM EDT

    Nice catch

    Note: that is not his hand or glove.

  2. Settling the Scores: Saturday’s results

    Aug 2, 2015, 8:25 AM EDT

    Cole Hamels

    Cole Hamels’ Texas debut didn’t go too well.

  3. Report: Dodgers only picking up $500,000 in acquisition of Bronson Arroyo

    Aug 1, 2015, 11:30 PM EDT

    Bronson Arroyo Bronson Arroyo

    The Dodgers aren’t paying much of Bronson Arroyo’s tab at all.

  4. Athletics designate Eric O’Flaherty for assignment

    Aug 1, 2015, 10:45 PM EDT

    Eric O'Flaherty Eric O'Flaherty

    Struggling lefty reliever Eric O’Flaherty was designated for assignment by the Athletics on Saturday.

  5. Chad Billingsley heading back to L.A. to have his elbow examined

    Aug 1, 2015, 10:05 PM EDT

    Chad Billingsley Chad Billingsley

    Chad Billingsley will meet with a doctor in L.A. He’s dealing with more elbow problems.

  6. Lucas Duda’s last eight hits have been home runs

    Aug 1, 2015, 9:33 PM EDT

    Lucas Duda Lucas Duda

    Lucas Duda doesn’t want to run the bases.

  7. Steven Souza, Jr. will go on the disabled list with a broken hand

    Aug 1, 2015, 9:02 PM EDT

    Steven Souza, Jr. Steven Souza, Jr.

    Steven Souza, Jr. was hit by a pitch and suffered a broken hand, so he’ll hit the disabled list for a spell.

  8. Rays to demote struggling lefty Matt Moore to Triple-A

    Aug 1, 2015, 9:00 PM EDT

    Matt Moore Matt Moore

    Rays lefty Matt Moore will try to fix himself in a low-pressure environment, as the Rays will demote him following Saturday’s poor start against the Red Sox.

  9. Joe Maddon: Kyle Schwarber stays when Miguel Montero returns

    Aug 1, 2015, 8:10 PM EDT

    Kyle Schwarber Kyle Schwarber

    Kyle Schwarber is staying in the big leagues when Miguel Montero returns, which is bad news for opposing pitchers.

  10. Report: Larry Lucchino stepping down as president and CEO of the Red Sox

    Aug 1, 2015, 7:19 PM EDT

    Larry Lucchino Larry Lucchino

    There’s a shakeup in the Red Sox front office, as Larry Lucchino is stepping down from his role as president and CEO.

  11. Clayton Kershaw blanks the Angels over eight innings, runs consecutive scoreless innings streak to 37

    Aug 1, 2015, 6:56 PM EDT

    Clayton Kershaw AP

    Clayton Kershaw is good at baseball, the lefty confirmed on Saturday.

  12. Phillies pitcher Matt Harrison diagnosed with hypothyroidism

    Aug 1, 2015, 6:05 PM EDT

    Matt Harrison Matt Harrison

    Matt Harrison has been diagnosed with hypothyroidism. The diagnosis, he hopes, allows him to deal with his various issues, including his back problems.

  13. David Wright could begin minor league rehab assignment next week

    Aug 1, 2015, 5:29 PM EDT

    SAN DIEGO, CA - JUNE 2:  David Wright #5 of the New York Mets looks out from the dugout before a baseball game against the San Diego Padres at Petco Park June 2, 2015 in San Diego, California.  (Photo by Denis Poroy/Getty Images) Getty Images

    The second-place Mets have been without Wright since mid-April.

  14. Clayton Kershaw and Mike Trout make MLB history in Saturday’s matchup

    Aug 1, 2015, 4:27 PM EDT

    ANAHEIM, CA - AUGUST 07: A behind the scenes photograph of Mike Trout #27 of the Los Angeles Angels of Anaheim and Clayton Kershaw #22 of the Los Angeles Dodgers during a photo shoot before the game on August 7, 2014 at Angel Stadium of Anaheim in Anaheim, California. (Photo by Matt Brown/Angels Baseball LP/Getty Images) Getty Images

    Saturday’s game marks the first time in MLB history that two reigning MVPs have squared off against each other.

  15. Wade Davis gives up his first home run in nearly two years

    Aug 1, 2015, 4:15 PM EDT

    MINNEAPOLIS, MN- JUNE 09: Wade Davis #17 of the Kansas City Royals pitches against the Minnesota Twins on June 9, 2015 at Target Field in Minneapolis, Minnesota. The Royals defeated the Twins 2-0. (Photo by Brace Hemmelgarn/Minnesota Twins/Getty Images) Getty Images

    Davis hadn’t allowed a home run since August 24, 2013.

  16. Esmil Rogers signs with the Hanwha Eagles in Korea

    Aug 1, 2015, 3:26 PM EDT

    KANSAS CITY, MO - MAY 17:  Esmil Rogers #53 of the New York Yankees throws in the fifth inning against the Kansas City Royals at Kauffman Stadium on May 17, 2015 in Kansas City, Missouri. (Photo by Ed Zurga/Getty Images) Getty Images

    Rogers made 18 appearances with the Yankees earlier this season, but now he’s headed to the Korea Baseball Organization.

  17. Video: Ben Revere makes leaping catch in debut with Blue Jays

    Aug 1, 2015, 2:41 PM EDT

    ben revere

    The speedy outfielder has made a good first impression in his Blue Jays debut.

  18. Matt Williams on Bryce Harper’s ejection: “He needs to stay in the baseball game”

    Aug 1, 2015, 2:25 PM EDT

    MIAMI, FL - JULY 28:  Bryce Harper #34 of the Washington Nationals looks on during a game against the Miami Marlins at Marlins Park on July 28, 2015 in Miami, Florida.  (Photo by Mike Ehrmann/Getty Images) Getty Images

    Nationals outfielder Bryce Harper was ejected from Friday’s game against the Mets in the top of the 11th inning after arguing balls and strikes with home plate umpire Jerry Meals.

Top 10 MLB Player Searches
  1. C. Gomez (5438)
  2. C. Hamels (5278)
  3. T. Tulowitzki (4543)
  4. Y. Cespedes (3952)
  5. M. Trout (3838)
  1. D. Price (3577)
  2. T. Clippard (3296)
  3. T. Ross (3201)
  4. G. Parra (3134)
  5. J. Reyes (3119)