Skip to content

Is Manny Machado in the same echelon as Mike Trout and Bryce Harper?

May 11, 2013, 6:45 PM EDT

Manny Machado AP

MASN’s Steve Melewski argues that Manny Machado should be considered in the same conversation as Mike Trout and Bryce Harper when it comes to the best young players in baseball. The Orioles’ 20-year-old third baseman is off to a fantastic start in 2013, carrying a .314/.356/.503 line through 166 plate appearances. By Baseball Reference WAR, he has been as valuable as Joey Votto and Troy Tulowitzki, among others, which ranks in the top-ten in baseball.

Putting him in with Trout and Harper, though? Melewski uses batting average, home runs, RBI, and doubles to make his case, which unfortunately leaves out base running and defense.

Melewski writes:

Did you know that through the first 84 big league games for each player, that Machado tops both Trout and Harper in batting average, homers, RBIs and doubles?

Well, he does, as found by Duquette, who is also heard on MLB Network Radio on Sirius-XM Radio. Here is the comparison:

Machado – .284 average, 12 homers, 47 RBIs, 20 doubles.
Harper – .258 average, nine homers, 29 RBIs, 16 doubles.
Trout – .282 average, 11 homers, 42 RBIs, 16 doubles.

Machado tops the dynamic duo in all four categories. Is there anyone out there that still doesn’t think he belongs in the conversation with Trout and Harper for best young player in baseball? He clearly stacks up with the other two.

Limiting to each player’s first 84 games is both arbitrary and unnecessarily reduces the sample size for two of the three players. Let’s go over all available data over their respective careers. (Warning: nerdiness ahead.)

The best all-encompassing offensive stat, in my humble opinion, is weighted on-base average (wOBA). It weights everything a player does by himself and is context-neutral (in other words, it doesn’t care about the inning, runner on base, outs, etc.). Trout is way ahead of the pack at .399, Harper is in second at .365, and Machado brings up the rear at .341. The MLB average is .315. The 58-point difference in runs between Trout and Machado, over Machado’s 368 career PA, is 17, which is huge — nearly two wins, or the equivalent of an average player by itself. The 24-point difference between Harper and Machado is seven runs over 368 PA.

Trout has also stolen 54 bases in 60 attempts (90 percent), Harper 19 in 27 (70 percent), and Machado six in seven (86 percent). In overall base running (which includes base-stealing), Baseball Prospectus credits Trout with 8.7 runs in 2012 and 0.1 runs in 2013 (8.8 total); Harper 5.4 and -0.9 (4.5); Machado -0.3 and -1.0 (-1.3).

Defense is tricky to gauge since even advanced metrics leave a lot to be desired in this area. There is no question that Machado grades highly in this area no matter which methodology you use — stats, scouts, your own eyes, etc. Baseball Reference credits him at 10 runs above average while Ultimate Zone Rating (UZR) puts him at 12. Mike Trout is at +11 in center and +6 in left field over his career per BR, and +12 and +4 via UZR. Harper is +14 in center, +8 in right, and +6 in left via BR, and +10, -2, and 0 respectively, going by UZR. As good as Machado is defensively, he would have to be a whole lot better to make up for the lacking offense in comparison to Trout in particular.

Machado is a very good player with a bright future ahead of him. It is perfectly acceptable to appreciate that without exaggerating his prowess and neglecting two very important facets of the game. And it is still quite possible that Machado ends up having the better career when all is said and done, but right now, he doesn’t quite match up.

Latest Posts
  1. Mets hire former Yankees hitting coach Kevin Long

    Oct 23, 2014, 6:06 PM EDT

    Kevin long Getty Getty Images

    For the majority of Long’s tenure the Yankees had one of the elite offenses in baseball and overall from 2007-2014 they scored MLB’s second-most runs, but the lineup fell apart during the past two seasons due to aging and injuries.

  2. Phillies sign Grady Sizemore to one-year, $2 million deal

    Oct 23, 2014, 5:30 PM EDT

    Grady Sizemore Getty Images

    Sizemore’s numbers in Philadelphia were nothing special and for the season overall he hit just .233 with five homers and a .654 OPS in 112 games.

  3. Craig Breslow expects Red Sox to decline 2015 option

    Oct 23, 2014, 5:17 PM EDT

    Craig Breslow Getty Getty Images

    Bad year at a bad time for the 33-year-old free agent.

  4. The World Series ratings are low. So what?

    Oct 23, 2014, 5:04 PM EDT

    old TV

    ‘Tis the season for concern trolling about World Series ratings.

  5. Blue Jays “willing to offer at least a three-year deal” to Melky Cabrera

    Oct 23, 2014, 3:45 PM EDT

    Melky Cabrera AP

    That’s quite a change from last time Cabrera hit the open market, when he managed only a two-year, $16 million contract coming off a 50-game suspension for performance-enhancing drugs.

  6. Pirates sign Josh Stinson

    Oct 23, 2014, 2:14 PM EDT

    Josh Stinson Orioles

    Stinson has had brief looks in the majors with the Orioles, Brewers, and Mets, combining to throw 52 innings with a 4.47 ERA in parts of four seasons.

  7. The Mets are interested in Michael Cuddyer

    Oct 23, 2014, 2:00 PM EDT

    Michael Cuddyer Getty Getty Images

    He only played 49 games this season, but they were 49 pretty good games.

  8. Gold Glove finalists announced

    Oct 23, 2014, 1:47 PM EDT

    gold glove award

    On your mark. Get set. Complain!

  9. The Brewers hire Darnell Coles as their hitting instructor

    Oct 23, 2014, 1:30 PM EDT

    Brewers logo

    He previously managed in the Brewers’ minor league system.

  10. Blue Jays “getting a lot of interest” in Adam Lind

    Oct 23, 2014, 1:15 PM EDT

    adam lind getty Getty Images

    Will the Blue Jays trade Lind after he hit .321 this season?

  11. HBT Daily: Did Ned Yost outduel Bruce Bochy?

    Oct 23, 2014, 12:45 PM EDT

    Division Series - Los Angeles Angels of Anaheim v Kansas City Royals - Game Three Getty Images

    Or did the players actually have something to do with all of this?

  12. The Rockies fire their pitching coach

    Oct 23, 2014, 12:12 PM EDT

    rockies logo

    Who wants THAT job? Anyone? Anyone?

  13. The Cubs’ battle with the rooftop owners may be coming to an end

    Oct 23, 2014, 11:26 AM EDT

    Wrigley Rooftop

    The team may soon own the buildings across Waveland and Sheffield Avenues.

  14. John Hart to be named Braves President of Baseball Operations

    Oct 23, 2014, 10:42 AM EDT

    John Hart

    Presumably, the Braves will also hire a general manager, giving them the two-headed front office we’ve seen in Chicago and will soon see in Los Angeles.

  15. There was a Tim Lincecum sighting last night! But then he went away again.

    Oct 23, 2014, 8:59 AM EDT

    Tim Lincecum AP

    The Freak was back last night. And he did OK, though he left with a stiff back.

  16. At least Hunter Strickland entertained us last night

    Oct 23, 2014, 7:44 AM EDT

    Screen Shot 2014-10-23 at 7.42.57 AM AP

    The rookie didn’t have control. With his pitches or with his emotions.

  17. Giants should give Yusmeiro Petit the Game 4 start

    Oct 23, 2014, 2:25 AM EDT

    Yusmeiro Petit Yusmeiro Petit

    Petit deserves the nod over probable starter Ryan Vogelsong.

Featured video

A managerial overanalysis epidemic
Top 10 MLB Player Searches
  1. M. Bumgarner (3107)
  2. J. Shields (2922)
  3. T. Lincecum (2832)
  4. M. Morse (2417)
  5. T. Ishikawa (2398)
  1. Y. Cespedes (2031)
  2. L. Cain (1675)
  3. B. Roberts (1646)
  4. B. Posey (1512)
  5. U. Jimenez (1503)