Skip to content

A-Rod’s cousin, Yuri Sucart, files an appeal challenging Major League Baseball’s Biogenesis lawsuit

Aug 20, 2013, 5:01 PM EST

lawsuit gavel

Alex Rodriguez‘s cousin Yuri Sucart has filed a writ with a Florida appellate court challenging the validity of Major League Baseball’s lawsuit against Biogenesis: the lawsuit which gave Major League Baseball the handle with which to turn Anthony Bosch and others as it pursued Rodriguez, Ryan Braun and other ballplayers who were alleged to have done business with the Biogenesis clinic.

Sucart is not a defendant in that lawsuit, but Major League Baseball did seek to take his deposition and sought to obtain documents and his medical records.  Sucart challenged MLB’s right to do so, seeking an order from the trial court preventing the deposition from taking place. That effort was denied and now he has filed today’s writ with the Third District Court of Appeal.

The basis for the appeal, which NBC Sports.com has obtained, includes some arguments which would relate only to Sucart, such as his rights under The Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act and his standing as a non-party to challenge the trial court’s orders. But Sucart also challenges the very foundation of the lawsuit, arguing that the trial court has no jurisdiction to hear Major League Baseball’s case at all. The reason: the dispute requires the interpretation of baseball’s Collective Bargaining Agreement in order to determine whether it was breached and state courts are forbidden from interpreting a collective bargaining agreement by operation of the Labor Management Relations Act.

Major League Baseball will have a chance to respond to Sucart’s arguments.  It will likely be weeks, and possibly months, before the court rules.

Sucart’s attorney, Jeffrey Sonn of the Fort Lauderdale, Florida law firm of Sonn & Erez PLC, told NBC Sports.com that if Sucart’s challenge is successful, it not only would mean an end to the Biogenesis case, but it could make waves for player-owner relations in baseball as a whole:

“In my opinion, if the 3rd district court of appeals agrees with our premise … I think the players would have a tremendous lawsuit against baseball for violation of their due process rights and other claims for violating the collective bargaining agreement. It would be tantamount to baseball knowingly violating the players’ rights. The bottom line is if you make a deal with the players, and you don’t like the deal, go renegotiate it. Don’t run to court. Don’t trample on people’s private rights.”

Sonn went beyond the implications of this writ, however, and offered an indictment of the CBA and Joint Drug Agreement overall, saying, “The method of the CBA, which basically holds you guilty until it proves you innocent, is antithetical to our justice system in that it holds you guilty until it proves you innocent. It is un-American.”

The overarching argument may be a moot one given that the MLBPA and all of the accused players with the exception of Alex Rodriguez have gotten on board with baseball’s Biogenesis investigation, accepting their punishment. With respect to Rodriguez, the evidence Major League Baseball will use against him at his upcoming arbitration has already been obtained.

But this appeal could test Major League Baseball’s ability to aggressively pursue similar cases under the theory it employed when it filed the Biogenesis suit. And, if successful, it could render any discipline it ultimately obtains against Alex Rodriguez the product of evidence that, were the law followed and the suit not filed, would likely have never fallen into baseball’s hands in the first place.

Latest Posts
  1. The Padres have talked to the Phillies about Cole Hamels

    Dec 21, 2014, 5:47 PM EST

    cole hamels getty Getty Images

    It makes a lot of sense. And now, it seems, the clubs themselves are starting to talk about it.

  2. Why is John Smoltz a shoo-in for the Hall of Fame?

    Dec 21, 2014, 4:17 PM EST

    (FILES) This 25 August, 2002, file photo

    Is Smoltz really so different than Curt Schilling and Mike Mussina?

  3. Giants, Red Sox still in the picture for James Shields

    Dec 21, 2014, 2:50 PM EST

    james shields getty Getty Images

    The field for James Shields has been winnowed down to a few, namely the Giants and Red Sox.

  4. Justin Upton open to signing a contract extension with the Padres before spring training

    Dec 21, 2014, 1:35 PM EST

    Justin Upton Justin Upton

    If the Padres want to keep Justin Upton around beyond 2015, they’ll have to hammer out a contract extension before spring training begins.

  5. Scott Boras: Matt Wieters will be ready for Opening Day

    Dec 21, 2014, 12:27 PM EST

    Matt Wieters AP

    Scott Boras says the Orioles should expect to have Matt Wieters behind the plate when the 2015 regular season opens on April 6.

  6. Padres GM A.J. Preller discusses the offseason

    Dec 21, 2014, 10:55 AM EST

    preller ap AP

    A.J. Preller, the second-youngest general manager in Major League Baseball, joined MLB Network this weekend to discuss the Padres’ incredibly active offseason …

  7. Video: Matt Kemp and San Diego’s “rockstar GM”

    Dec 21, 2014, 9:11 AM EST

    matt kemp dodgers getty Getty Images

    Matt Kemp was introduced to the San Diego media on Saturday at Petco Park …

  8. Rangers showing interest in Brandon Beachy

    Dec 20, 2014, 10:45 PM EST

    Brandon Beachy Brandon Beachy

    Bounce-back candidate Brandon Beachy has drawn interest from the Rangers lately.

  9. Josh Lindblom signs with the Lotte Giants in Korea

    Dec 20, 2014, 9:40 PM EST

    Josh Lindblom Josh Lindblom

    Josh Lindblom is taking his talents to the Lotte Giants of the Korea Baseball Organization.

  10. Angels sign Cuban infielder Roberto Baldoquin

    Dec 20, 2014, 7:35 PM EST

    angels logo

    The deal between Cuban infielder Roberto Baldoquin and the Angels became official on Saturday after the 20-year-old passed his physical.

  11. Brian Sabean doesn’t plan to talk to Max Scherzer

    Dec 20, 2014, 7:10 PM EST

    Max Scherzer Getty Getty Images

    The Giants reportedly have no plans to attempt to initiate contract talk with free agent Max Scherzer.

  12. Nick Hundley reportedly has a two-year offer

    Dec 20, 2014, 6:05 PM EST

    Nick Hundley Nick Hundley

    An unnamed team has reportedly offered a two-year deal to Nick Hundley. It’s not the Orioles.

  13. Rangers lose a player to release waivers due to quirk in MLB rule

    Dec 20, 2014, 5:26 PM EST

    Ben Rowen Getty Getty Images

    MLB’s waiver rules are complicated enough for fans and those who cover baseball on a regular basis, but apparently they can even confuse teams sometimes.

  14. Report: The Phillies could be a suitor for Asdrubal Cabrera

    Dec 20, 2014, 4:06 PM EST

    Asdrubal Cabrera Getty Images

    The Phillies could eye Asdrubal Cabrera as a replacement for Jimmy Rollins.

  15. Indians sign Scott Downs

    Dec 20, 2014, 2:45 PM EST

    Scott Downs Getty Getty Images

    Downs had a 4.97 ERA over 55 appearances this past season between the White Sox and Royals.

  16. Phillies GM told Ryan Howard they’d be better off “not with him but without him”

    Dec 20, 2014, 1:30 PM EST

    Ryan Howard Getty Getty Images

    With the Phillies in the middle of a rebuilding effort, they are facing some tough (and long overdue) truths with their veteran players.

  17. Troy Tulowitzki trade between the Rockies and Mets is “not happening”

    Dec 20, 2014, 12:16 PM EST

    San Diego Padres v Colorado Rockies Getty Images

    Tulowitzki would immediately take the Mets from a “maybe” contender to a “legitimate” contender, but don’t get your hopes up.

  18. Jimmy Rollins writes goodbye message to Philadelphia after trade to Dodgers

    Dec 20, 2014, 11:01 AM EST

    Miami Marlins v Philadelphia Phillies Getty Images

    Rollins was officially traded from the Phillies to the Dodgers yesterday in exchange for right-hander Zach Eflin and left-hander Tom Windle.

Featured video

Cubs shore up rotation with Jon Lester
Top 10 MLB Player Searches
  1. W. Myers (5088)
  2. M. Kemp (3552)
  3. J. Upton (2812)
  4. J. Kang (2801)
  5. W. Middlebrooks (2710)
  1. C. McGehee (2706)
  2. M. Morse (2422)
  3. A. Rios (2387)
  4. C. Headley (2219)
  5. J. Peavy (1948)