Skip to content

Could a Cardinal not named Yadier Molina win the MVP?

Sep 9, 2013, 8:24 AM EDT

Pittsburgh Pirates v St. Louis Cardinals Getty Images

The NL MVP race doesn’t have a consensus candidate, really. I feel like, among the chattering classes, Andrew McCutchen and Yadier Molina have the most juice behind them. But Paul Goldschmidt has his backers. Even guys like Freddie Freeman have people making their case for whatever reason. But how about a non-Molina St. Louis Cardinal? Derrick Goold presents the bonafides of Matt Carpenter’s season:

Carpenter’s two hits gave him 174 for the season, which leads the National League by eight. His two runs give him 112 so far this season. He’s the only player in the NL with more than 100. He ranks in the top 10 in average (.316), on-base percentage (.386) and on-base plus slugging percentage (.868). Baseball’s new math adores him, too, with a Wins Above Replacement at 5.5 that ranks seventh, just behind RBI leader Paul Goldschmidt’s 5.8. That is also ahead of Yadier Molina, at 5.1, who is having an MVP-caliber season.

Though WAR has entered the MVP conversation in pretty significant ways these past couple of years I don’t think it’s much beyond a talking point for single-season awards. Even among the stat-minded there is a general acknowledgment that single-season WAR numbers should be taken with copious amounts of salt given the uncertainty as to how to measure and weigh defensive numbers. Yes, it’s a fun caricature of a stat person to say they’re WAR-First and WAR-Only, but no one who thinks about this stuff thoughtfully or seriously should make such an argument (not that I think Goold is doing that here; he clearly isn’t).

All of that being said, I believe that if it came down to Carpenter and Molina, I feel like Molina will get all the support and then some, WAR notwithstanding. Generally speaking, when top notch defensive catchers hit .323, it’s really, really hard for voters to say no. Catchers do, quite understandably, get bonus points from people for stellar offense.

League-wide, I feel like it’s either Molina’s or McCutchen’s award, depending on how they and their teams finish and how much people want to wrap a bow on the Pirates’ breakthrough season. Each would be deserving. Even if Carpenter is having a great, great season.

Latest Posts
  1. The benches cleared in Friday’s Giants-Rangers game

    Jul 31, 2015, 9:53 PM EDT

    Madison Bumgarner Madison Bumgarner

    Madison Bumgarner was upset Delino DeShields was upset.

  2. Giants place Tim Hudson on the disabled list with a shoulder strain

    Jul 31, 2015, 9:35 PM EDT

    Tim Hudson Getty Images

    The Giants placed Tim Hudson on the disabled list, which created room on the roster for incoming pitcher Mike Leake.

  3. Pirates place A.J. Burnett on the disabled list with elbow inflammation

    Jul 31, 2015, 8:55 PM EDT

    A.J. Burnett A.J. Burnett

    A.J. Burnett hits the DL with an elbow issue. Recently-acquired pitcher J.A. Happ will take his spot in the rotation.

  4. Report: Padres asked Diamondbacks for Paul Goldschmidt in a Craig Kimbrel trade

    Jul 31, 2015, 8:28 PM EDT

    Paul Goldschmidt Paul Goldschmidt

    Diamondbacks GM Dave Stewart laughed when he recalled the Padres asking for Paul Goldschmidt in return in a potential trade involving Craig Kimbrel.

  5. Video: Kendrys Morales avoids tag at the plate with a nifty slide

    Jul 31, 2015, 7:49 PM EDT

    Kendrys Morales Kendrys Morales

    Kendrys Morales is more nimble than we give him credit for being.

  6. Yankees prospect Luis Severino’s next start will be his major league debut

    Jul 31, 2015, 7:20 PM EDT

    Luis Severino Getty Images

    Yankees pitching prospect Luis Severino will make his major league debut within the next week.

  7. Clayton Kershaw scratched from Friday’s start against the Angels

    Jul 31, 2015, 6:14 PM EDT

    Clayton Kershaw Clayton Kershaw

    Clayton Kershaw has been scratched from a start yet again due to a hip problem.

  8. The Winners and Losers at the Trade Deadline

    Jul 31, 2015, 5:37 PM EDT

    Cole Hamels Getty Images

    Yes, I realize it’s silly to do this an hour after the trade deadline, as time is required to see how this stuff truly shakes out. But what is the Internet for if not kneejerk reactions?

  9. Pirates acquire left-hander J.A. Happ from Mariners

    Jul 31, 2015, 4:33 PM EDT

    J.A. Happ AP

    J.A. Happ and Joe Blanton, reunited.

  10. Pirates pick up Michael Morse from the Dodgers for Jose Tabata

    Jul 31, 2015, 4:30 PM EDT

    Michael Morse Marlins Getty Images

    He was DFA’d by the Dodgers as soon as they got him but he may platoon at 1B for Pittsburgh.

  11. So, the Padres sure did a whole lot of nothin’, eh?

    Jul 31, 2015, 4:20 PM EDT

    San Diego Padres Logo

    People thought they’d make four or five trades. They ended up doing nothing.

  12. 2015 MLB Trade Deadline Tracker

    Jul 31, 2015, 4:15 PM EDT

    Detroit Tigers v Seattle Mariners Detroit Tigers v Seattle Mariners

    We’re recapping all of the deals as they come down.

  13. Report: Yoenis Cespedes heading to the New York Mets

    Jul 31, 2015, 3:59 PM EDT

    cespedes getty Getty Images

    The Mets add a big bat to their anemic offense. And they don’t have to part with Zack Wheeler to do it.

  14. Garrett Jones designated for assignment by the Yankees

    Jul 31, 2015, 3:12 PM EDT

    Garrett Jones Yankees Getty Images

    Jones struggled in a part-time role for the Yankees.

  15. The Mets are making a push for Yoenis Cespedes

    Jul 31, 2015, 2:27 PM EDT

    Yoenis Cespedes Getty Images

    This is the third outfielder to whom they’ve been linked in three days. Let’s see if this one takes.

  16. The Blue Jays pick up Ben Revere from the Phillies

    Jul 31, 2015, 2:13 PM EDT

    Ben Revere Ben Revere

    He’s hitting hitting .298/.334/.374 and will likely take over left field duties.

  17. The Cubs, Padres and Red Sox are said to be talking about a three-way deal

    Jul 31, 2015, 2:08 PM EDT

    San Diego Padres Logo

    Jed Hoyer has worked for all three of these teams. He may be in the middle of a big trade involving them all.

  18. Twins trade for Rays reliever Kevin Jepsen

    Jul 31, 2015, 2:05 PM EDT

    Kevin Jepsen Rays Getty Images

    Bullpen help has been an obvious need for Minnesota.

Top 10 MLB Player Searches
  1. C. Hamels (6023)
  2. C. Gomez (5041)
  3. T. Tulowitzki (4484)
  4. M. Trout (4058)
  5. J. Cueto (4023)
  1. C. Gonzalez (3762)
  2. A. Rodriguez (3726)
  3. D. Price (3677)
  4. J. Bruce (3390)
  5. T. Clippard (3254)