Skip to content

Could a Cardinal not named Yadier Molina win the MVP?

Sep 9, 2013, 8:24 AM EST

Pittsburgh Pirates v St. Louis Cardinals Getty Images

The NL MVP race doesn’t have a consensus candidate, really. I feel like, among the chattering classes, Andrew McCutchen and Yadier Molina have the most juice behind them. But Paul Goldschmidt has his backers. Even guys like Freddie Freeman have people making their case for whatever reason. But how about a non-Molina St. Louis Cardinal? Derrick Goold presents the bonafides of Matt Carpenter’s season:

Carpenter’s two hits gave him 174 for the season, which leads the National League by eight. His two runs give him 112 so far this season. He’s the only player in the NL with more than 100. He ranks in the top 10 in average (.316), on-base percentage (.386) and on-base plus slugging percentage (.868). Baseball’s new math adores him, too, with a Wins Above Replacement at 5.5 that ranks seventh, just behind RBI leader Paul Goldschmidt’s 5.8. That is also ahead of Yadier Molina, at 5.1, who is having an MVP-caliber season.

Though WAR has entered the MVP conversation in pretty significant ways these past couple of years I don’t think it’s much beyond a talking point for single-season awards. Even among the stat-minded there is a general acknowledgment that single-season WAR numbers should be taken with copious amounts of salt given the uncertainty as to how to measure and weigh defensive numbers. Yes, it’s a fun caricature of a stat person to say they’re WAR-First and WAR-Only, but no one who thinks about this stuff thoughtfully or seriously should make such an argument (not that I think Goold is doing that here; he clearly isn’t).

All of that being said, I believe that if it came down to Carpenter and Molina, I feel like Molina will get all the support and then some, WAR notwithstanding. Generally speaking, when top notch defensive catchers hit .323, it’s really, really hard for voters to say no. Catchers do, quite understandably, get bonus points from people for stellar offense.

League-wide, I feel like it’s either Molina’s or McCutchen’s award, depending on how they and their teams finish and how much people want to wrap a bow on the Pirates’ breakthrough season. Each would be deserving. Even if Carpenter is having a great, great season.

Latest Posts
  1. The Mets and Rockies have been talking about a Troy Tulowitzki deal “for weeks”

    Dec 19, 2014, 9:05 AM EST

    San Diego Padres v Colorado Rockies Getty Images

    But one insider says the package the Rockies are asking for Tulo is “bats**t”

  2. Vin Scully lost his 1988 World Series ring at Costco but got it back. And talks about how Costco is cool.

    Dec 19, 2014, 8:30 AM EST

    vin scully getty Getty Images

    He doesn’t say so, but I have this feeling he’s a chicken bake man. Chicken bakes are pretty underrated.

  3. Bud Selig will get a $6 million a year pension. Which is obscene.

    Dec 19, 2014, 7:28 AM EST

    Bud Selig Reuters

    Can someone justify this sort of golden parachute? Will anyone even bother to try?

  4. Jake Peavy agrees to a two-year, $24 million deal to stay with the San Francisco Giants

    Dec 19, 2014, 6:50 AM EST

    jake peavy getty Getty Images

    The Giants haven’t gotten many of their sought-after targets this offseason, but they keep one of their starters.

  5. Matt Kemp has officially been traded to the Padres

    Dec 18, 2014, 11:27 PM EST

    matt kemp dodgers getty Getty Images

    It took long enough, but Matt Kemp has finally been traded to the Padres.

  6. Padres acquire catcher Derek Norris from Athletics

    Dec 18, 2014, 9:30 PM EST

    Derek Norris Getty Getty Images

    The Padres continue to overhaul their lineup while the A’s continue to unload.

  7. Delmon Young would prefer to re-sign with the Orioles

    Dec 18, 2014, 8:46 PM EST

    Delmon Young AP

    Young, 29, batted .302 with seven home runs and .779 OPS (120 OPS+) over 255 plate appearances this past season.

  8. Mariners sign Mark Lowe

    Dec 18, 2014, 7:50 PM EST

    Mark Lowe AP AP

    Lowe began his career with Seattle and had his best season with the club in 2009.

  9. Report: Josh Johnson is “on the verge” of re-signing with the Padres

    Dec 18, 2014, 6:07 PM EST

    San Diego Padres Photo Day Getty Images

    Johnson missed the entire 2014 season after undergoing Tommy John surgery in late April.

  10. Ichiro is getting “some consideration” from the Orioles

    Dec 18, 2014, 6:00 PM EST

    Ichiro Suzuki Getty Images

    Does Ichiro really have one more year left in him?

  11. Royals designate Johnny Giavotella for assignment

    Dec 18, 2014, 5:17 PM EST

    Johnny Giavotella Getty Images

    Giavotella is a career .315 hitter with an .835 OPS and as many walks as strikeouts in nearly 2,000 plate appearances at Triple-A.

  12. The Walter White of the Biogenesis case pleads guilty

    Dec 18, 2014, 4:47 PM EST

    Screen Shot 2014-12-18 at 4.46.36 PM

    He’s probably not the one who knocks. Indeed, this crew seemed so amateurish he probably called first to make sure it was a good time for everyone.

  13. What Communists thought about baseball in 1934

    Dec 18, 2014, 3:34 PM EST

    Screen Shot 2014-12-18 at 3.21.56 PM

    Between Cuba and North Korea, it’s been a big couple of days for communism. Let’s see what communists thought about baseball once upon a time.

  14. Royals sign Kris Medlen for two years, with option for 2017

    Dec 18, 2014, 3:18 PM EST

    kris medlen getty Getty Images

    Medlen missed all of this year recovering from his second Tommy John elbow surgery.

Featured video

Cubs shore up rotation with Jon Lester
Top 10 MLB Player Searches
  1. W. Myers (3674)
  2. M. Kemp (3417)
  3. M. Cabrera (3334)
  4. M. Morse (2495)
  5. J. Kang (2228)
  1. J. Lester (2223)
  2. C. Headley (2130)
  3. C. Hamels (1776)
  4. A. Rios (1766)
  5. W. Miley (1755)