Skip to content

A Thoroughly Enjoyable Season

Sep 18, 2013, 10:45 AM EDT

Cleveland Indians v Kansas City Royals Getty Images

Well, it’s Sept. 17 … and the Kansas City Royals have a shot at the postseason. It’s a bit of a longshot, sure. They are 2 1/2 games behind Texas in the wildcard standings right now, which is hardly insurmountable (especially the way the Rangers are playing). But they also have Cleveland and Baltimore ahead of them, and the Yankees tied with them. That makes the math difficult.

Basically, when you play it out, the Royals are something like a 24-to-1 shot to reach the postseason. But, hey, when you look at the Royals the last 25 or so years, a 24-to-1 shot on Sept. 17 is a bleeping miracle.

Anyway, even assuming they do fall short, it really doesn’t change the headline. It has been a thoroughly enjoyable season.

I’ve written this before: It was Jason Kendall who finally broke my spirits. Well, not Kendall himself — Jason was a really good player as a young man — but the idea of him. The Royals signed Jason Kendall on December 11, 2009. Not coincidentally, that was the day I became convinced that the Kansas City Royals would never, ever do anything right.

Kendall was about to turn 36 when the Royals signed him. His slugging percentage the previous two seasons was .313. I want to repeat now — that was his SLUGGING PERCENTAGE. The Royals were coming off a 97-loss season weighed down by a bunch of 30-something veterans spreading the presence all over the place. Forget that the Royals did not learn any lessons from another dreadful season. They did not seem to even know there were lessons to be learned.

Kendall was only the latest in decades of bafflement. The Royals had given Jose Guillen $12 million a year for reasons that, I assume, are locked in a secret file somewhere in the bowels of Kauffman Stadium.* They had not only traded for Yuniesky Betancourt, they brought him back later. They signed Chuck Knoblauch when he was done, Reggie Sanders when he was done. Juan Gonzalez. Jose Lima, Mike Jacobs, Ross Gload, Sidney Ponson. On and on and on and on.

*The “Why KC signed Guillen” file is only one page long and has but one word written on it — “RBIs!”

And then … Kendall … it was the pitch that broke the camel’s bat. Kendall was typically gamey, he showed up ready to play, he refused to sit, and in the 490 plate appearances he managed before finally expiring, he did not hit even one triple or home run. It was all hopeless. The Royals were lost at sea. Of course, they had been lost forever. The despairing part was they seemed to have no particular desire to be found.

And here we are, less then four years later, and the reason this Royals team has been so enjoyable is not only that they are winning more than they are losing. That’s great. It’s not only that they are mathematically alive for a playoff spot. That’s great too. It is that the Royals, for the first time in almost two generations, are heading toward land. I don’t just feel good for them. I’m oddly proud of them.

At the start of the year, it looked to be a typically miserable year. The Royals made the controversial Wil Myers for James Shields trade, which looked pretty bad when they made it and, I suspect, will look progressively worse as years go on. They penciled Jeff Francoeur into the starting lineup. They thrust young Eric Hosmer into the coveted third spot in the lineup though he was coming off a dismal season. They seemed serious about returning Luke Hochevar to the rotation though he had proven pretty conclusively that he would never be even an average big league starter. And then, after getting off to a quick start, they went into this death spiral where they lost 19 of 23 games and descended into the abyss of last place in the American League Central. For way too long, they were leading off Chris Getz. Manager Ned Yost seemed to be overmatched. Another year in Kansas City.

Only, there was something different. I didn’t like the Shields for Myers deal … and still don’t. But there was something CALCULATED about it. Something LOGICAL about it. The Royals had determined that with a couple of good starters, they could take a leap forward. I was just talking about this with Arizona reliever Brad Ziegler, who grew up in Missouri, and he said this: “Look, we all know that Wil Myers is going to be a superstar. The ROYALS knew it. But James Shields is amazing. He throws eight innings every time out.”

It’s not quite that … but close. Shields leads the American League in innings pitched. Take away one dreadful start against Detroit, he has a sub-3.00 ERA. His 25 quality starts — no matter how you may feel about that stat — is second-highest for the Royals since the strike, behind only Zack Greinke’s absurdly good 2009 Cy Young season. Truth is, Shields really has pitched better than I thought he would. He has pitched just as well as the Royals thought he would. He has been exactly what the Royals hoped he would be — a metronome for a team learning how to keep time. Do I think that was worth Wil Myers? No. Do I think they will regret the deal longterm? Yes. But the Royals made a calculated decision to step forward now. And they are stepping forward.

They moved Luke Hochevar to the bullpen. If you are not a Royals fan, this will mean nothing to you — Hochevar struggled, OF COURSE they moved him to the bullpen, right? Big deal. But, you see, that’s not how the Royals work. The Royals have simply refused to move on from their mistakes. This is a team that gave Kyle Davies start after start after start in the hopelessly misguided belief that something would kick in. Davies made 99 starts for Kansas City — his ERA was 5.34 for those starts. Hochevar — who flashed good stuff and was also the first pick in the 2006 draft* — seemed to have Supreme Court job security.

*Ahead of — I’ve done this list so many times I can do it in my sleep — Evan Longoria, Clayton Kershaw, Tim Lincecum and Max Scherzer, to name only a few. Soon, I suspect, we will have a trivia question: In the first round of the 2006 draft, three Cy Young winners were selected. Who was the FIRST PICK of that draft?

But, the Royals moved Hochevar to the bullpen, where — as an added bonus — he has been brilliant. I think that was really the first time I looked at this team and thought: “Hey, wait a minute, Dayton Moore and the guys might have figured some things out.” My last line in that Hochevar post was this: “The Royals aren’t doubling down on their mistake. And that, I think, is a good sign that things are really changing in Kansas City.”

They got rid of Jeff Francoeur. Again a seemingly obvious move — Frenchy was hitting .208 at the time — but obvious moves have befuddled the Royals for years. Everybody loves Francoeur, and so the Royals of old would have stuck with him in a naive hope that his good attitude and consistent effort would help him hit baseballs. The Royals went into their system and pulled up a longtime minor leaguer named David Lough and let him play. Lough is a tough guy, can play all three outfield spots and play them pretty well, can offer a little something with the bat, it’s like the Royals finally grasped the concept of replacement players.

They moved Eric Hosmer to the No. 2 spot in the lineup. I’ve written about this before and don’t want to make too much of it because lineup stuff tends to be ridiculously overvalued — but this move also cut against the Royals decision-making history. Hosmer is a big first baseman who is supposed to have outrageous power … the Royals have been constitutionally opposed to hitting a guy like that second. But they did it with Hosmer when he was struggling, and (I suspect) told him to just relax, not worry about home runs, see the ball hit the ball, let his natural talents take over. Whatever the reason, Hosmer is having a wonderful rebound season — he’s hitting .302/.356/.448 after a dreadful start — and you can begin to see the outline of the star the Royals and scouts have expected Hosmer to become.

The bullpen is a spectacular array of golden arms the Royals have acquired through the years. This is the Dayton Moore philosophy of stockpiling great arms at work. Moore had hoped it would materialize in the starting rotation more quickly (though Danny Duffy and Yordano Ventura offer exciting possibilities for next season and beyond). Instead, it has come to life in the bullpen — the Royals might have the best bullpen in the league. In fact, I’m not sure there’s any question. The Royals bullpen has a 2.54 ERA and 451 strikeouts in 426 innings.The league is hitting .220 against this bullpen. It’s electrifying.

And the bullpen is almost all homegrown. Closer Greg Holland (43 saves, 1.33 ERA, 94 Ks in 61 innings) was a 10th round pick out of Western Carolina. Hochevar (1.64 ERA, 76 strikeouts, 16 walks) we’ve talked about. Kelvin Herrera, who has struggled at times this year but throws 100 mph and can be absurdly dominant, was signed by the Royals in the Dominican Republic as a 16-year-old.

Little lefty Tim Collins came over in the Rick Ankiel trade (yes, for once the Royals were trading someone like Rick Ankiel AWAY), Will Smith came over in the Alberto Callaspo deal, Aaron Crow was a first-round mistake (sheesh, Mike Trout was RIGHT THERE) but the Royals did not compound the mistake by trying to make a starter out of him. He’s a pretty good reliever with a a power arm. Louis Coleman was a fifth-round pick out of the marvelously named Pillow Academy. He has an 0.35 ERA in 23 appearances.That’s right. One run allowed all year.

The Royals are not a great team. They are hopelessly powerless — their 104 home runs is 29 fewer than any team in the American League. They are 11th in the league in runs scored, and they have players in their every day lineup with OPS+ of 55 (Alcides Escobar), 76 (Mike Moustakas), 83 (Lorenzo Cain) and whatever dreadful numbers their second baseman is putting up. Their starting rotation barely goes three deep — and they’ve basically been saved by the left-handed stylings of Maestro Bruce Chen.

But they are a good team. And there is reason to believe they will be a better team. There is young pitching coming. The minor league system is still pretty stocked. Guys like Salvador Perez and Hosmer are just entering their prime, Billy Butler and Alex Gordon should still be in it. They play great defense. They are athletic. They have a direction and purpose.

And — man is this a great thing to say — they finally seem to know what they’re doing. It’s not that I agree with everything they do — I don’t. I’m not sure Ned Yost is the manager to take them to the next level. I’m not sure how the rotation will come together (right now, they’re counting on FOUR thirty-somethings). I don’t know if the bullpen can be this great again. I don’t know if they will hit enough … and, because of that, I do think the Wil Myers trade will look worse and worse if he becomes the MVP type hitter he just might become.

But, none of that is the point. The last couple of weeks could be a lot of fun if the Royals can win a few games, but that’s all gravy. The point is the Royals are finally pointing North. Yes, it has been a thoroughly enjoyable season.

  1. spudchukar - Sep 18, 2013 at 10:55 AM

    MLB parity is a good thing. Royals, Pirates, and Indians all contending. The O’s continue to compete. The Dodgers are back, even if they did it the old fashioned way, by buying their team. Hopefully the young Twins will be next.

    Prediction: The Brewers will be in the running in 2014, especially if they acquire a couple of starters.

    Toronto cannot be as bad, SF will rebound, the Padres aren’t that far away.

    The Mets and Cubs will still struggle, but they are young and improving. Harvey’s decision to reject the knife, may help the New Yorkers in the short term, but I believe it is a mistake, cause their chances in 2014 are still slim.

    The Angels, will probably spend for a starter or two, and Pujols and Hamilton will rebound.

    The Yanks are heading south, where Houston still has a solid grip on last, and Miami a ways to go.

  2. spacemaker101 - Sep 18, 2013 at 11:05 AM

    Haha royals are horrible

    • Old Gator - Sep 18, 2013 at 11:13 AM

      They are one trade for the Iron Giant away from being the second-to-class of their division.

      Right, kcrobert?

      • kcrobert10 - Sep 18, 2013 at 10:09 PM

        Yes gator if they could get the iron giant that in my mind would put them right there with Detroit. If my math was right we beat them in season sieries. Anyway ur Marlins don’t seem willing to trade him which I can’t really figure out. As I’ve stated before they won’t be able to compete till 2015 or 16 by then he will be gone and everyday they wait his value drops. As for the royals next yr I belive resigning Santana is key. I would also tender hochavear and trade him for an outfielder or 2nd baseman. I would also sign Charlie Manuel to manage.

    • sportsdrenched - Sep 18, 2013 at 11:20 AM

      Hey, who let the ProFootballTalk commenter in here?

  3. Old Gator - Sep 18, 2013 at 11:21 AM

    Well, it was a great season if you didn’t live in Macondo (“Twinned with Toronto,” says the sign driving south across the border from Hallandale, or “Doblado con Toronto” driving north across the border from La Avventura). If you did, it was about as much fun as having your vacation in Yucatan ruined by the K-T meteorite.

  4. sportsdrenched - Sep 18, 2013 at 11:29 AM

    For me it’s a season of whatifs. What if they won just 8 games during that 23 game stretch in May? It’s said that managers only make a difference in 3-4 games a season…look how short the Royals will be of a playoff spot. As much as JoePas thinks the front office learned something. I think they finally gave up on their favorite players because they knew they wouldn’t be around if they didn’t.

    I hope Dayton & his minions learned something. If they did 2014 should be even more enjoyable. But we’ll see what happens this off-season. If Ned, Chris Getz, & Jamie Carroll are on this team next April we’ll know the answer.

  5. scoutsaysweitersisabust - Sep 18, 2013 at 11:44 AM

    The O’s have competed this year, we’ve had a lot to enjoy, Chris Davis, Manny Machado, a front office making moves to improve, a playoff opportunity. But there was also a few disappointments this year, Gaussman, Bundy, the inability to take hold of opportunities presented to them, the inability to sustain a 5 game winning streak, Wieter’s regression as a hitter, Markakis’ bat evaporating completely. Considering where we were two + years ago we can’t complain too much, but man we really had a good shot this year and they just couldn’t get it done.

  6. gerryb323 - Sep 18, 2013 at 12:15 PM

    Good stuff Joe. Picking a nit, but Louis Coleman was a 5th round pick out of LSU…not exaclty nowhere.

  7. mqcarpenter - Sep 18, 2013 at 2:10 PM

    Solid break down. We need more articles like this

  8. spursareold - Sep 18, 2013 at 2:43 PM


  9. weaselpuppy - Sep 18, 2013 at 3:35 PM

    Kyle Zimmer looks pretty special too as an arm that isn’t too far away. 2014 was the due date I had on them for the playoffs 3 yrs ago…looks about right.

    It better be, as Shields is a FA after that season and if they aren’t playing October ball, his re-signing gets more difficult.

    • sportsdrenched - Sep 18, 2013 at 4:11 PM

      Assuming Tommy John doesn make another appearnce: Zimmer, Duffy, Ventura, & Dwyer look to be pretty solid. Pony up for 2 FA (including Shields) and it could get real fun around here in the coming summers. Of course, I said the same thing with Mike Montgomery and he continues to be lost in the TB organization.

  10. yankeepunk3000 - Sep 19, 2013 at 2:47 AM

    it has been a great season. exciting and its still not even over! great article Joe. top notch one of the best I’ve read on here in a long time.

Leave Comment

You must be logged in to leave a comment. Not a member? Register now!

Top 10 MLB Player Searches
  1. B. Crawford (2772)
  2. Y. Puig (2443)
  3. C. Correa (2436)
  4. G. Stanton (2388)
  5. G. Springer (2297)
  1. H. Pence (2222)
  2. J. Hamilton (2115)
  3. M. Teixeira (1905)
  4. H. Ramirez (1900)
  5. J. Fernandez (1872)