Skip to content

Andy Pettitte’s complicated Hall of Fame case

Sep 20, 2013, 1:25 PM EDT

New York Yankees v Toronto Blue Jays Getty Images

Andy Pettitte was never a dominant starter. That’s pretty much indisputable.

In 18 big-league seasons, Pettitte has never won a Cy Young Award, an ERA title or a strikeout crown. The only “black ink” on his Baseball-Reference page comes from the three times he led or shared his league lead in games started. He’s thrown four career shutouts, which is one more than Justin Masterson has this year.

Yet here he is. As he retires for a second time, he leaves MLB as the active leader in wins with 255 and strikeouts with 2,437 and the all-time leader with 19 postseason victories.

So, yeah, Pettitte’s Hall of Fame case is based largely on wins, which should lead to a great deal of skepticism given that he spent most of his career pitching for baseball’s most successful franchise. Among pitchers with at least 300 decisions since 1901, Pettitte ranks 16th with a .627 winning percentage, ahead of obvious Hall of Famers like Tom Seaver, Carl Hubbell, Warren Spahn, Bob Gibson and even Walter Johnson. Make the cutoff 400 decisions instead and Pettitte jumps all of the way to eighth on the list.

One could argue that says as much about the Yankees as it does about Pettitte.

On the other hand, it might surprise people to see Pettitte currently sitting with a 117 ERA+. That’s not Jack Morris territory (he’s at 105). That’s squarely in the Hall of Fame range. Baseball-reference’s Play Index gives us 51 Hall of Fame starting pitchers since 1901. Pettitte’s ERA would sit right along sign Gaylord Perry at No. 30 in that group. It’s better than Steve Carlton and Fergie Jenkins at 115. It’s much better than Don Sutton’s 108. It’s just below Bert Blyleven at 118.

Of course, Pettitte didn’t pitch as much as those guys. Jenkins has the low innings total of that group at 4,500. Pettitte is currently at 3,300. And given that modest innings total, one would certainly like to see more dominance than Pettitte offers.

Going by Baseball-Reference’s WAR, Pettitte’s 60.4 puts him right around Hall of Famers Juan Marichal (61.8), Jim Bunning (60.5) and Hal Newhouser (60.4) and ahead of guys like Whitey Ford (53.9), Early Wynn (51.6) and Catfish Hunter (36.5). But it also ranks behind non-Hall of Famers like Kevin Brown (68.7), Rick Reuschel (68.2), Luis Tiant (65.9) and David Cone (61.8). WAR rates question marks Mike Mussina (82.7) and Curt Schilling (80.7) as much more deserving.

So, Pettitte’s Hall of Fame case largely comes down to two things: the postseason and doping. Some will disqualify him automatically based on his admitted hGH use. I think that’s a discussion for a different time, though. The postseason is of more interest to me here. Pettitte clearly deserves some sort of boost for making 44 postseason starts and going 19-11 with a 3.81 ERA. He has five World Series rings, and he wasn’t a bystander for any of them.

How much credit is the tough part. I’m sympathetic to both sides of the argument. If Pettitte had been drafted by any team other than the Yankees, it’d doubtful he’d have any Hall of Fame case right now. His career is hardly any different than Chuck Finley’s.

On the other hand, Pettitte made the most of the opportunities he was given. And he’s pitched the equivalent of an extra season and a third. Would Pettitte’s regular-season numbers look better if he didn’t so often make an extra five or six starts in October? I think they probably would.

Personally, I think Pettitte still comes up short. I like my Hall of Famers to have higher peaks — to have been among the best players in their leagues, even if only for a couple of years. But it’s unfair to dismiss his case as just being Yankee hype. He has a better argument than Jack Morris, and there are certainly worse pitchers enshrined already. But there are better ones to pick from, too.

Latest Posts
  1. Cubs ready to make a big play for pitching

    Sep 22, 2014, 3:15 PM EDT

    theo epstein getty Getty Images

    The Cubs know they can’t just get by on change-of-scenery guys and sign-and-flip deals.

  2. Sandy Alderson is getting a three-year deal with the Mets

    Sep 22, 2014, 3:00 PM EDT

    Sandy Alderson AP

    The Mets are staying the course. And it is probably a good idea.

  3. Desmond Jennings won’t return to play the final week

    Sep 22, 2014, 2:48 PM EDT

    Desmond Jennings AP

    He finishes the season hitting .244 with 10 homers, 15 steals, and a .697 OPS in 123 games, falling back to his 2012 production after posting a .748 OPS last season.

  4. Adam LaRoche doesn’t expect to re-sign with the Nationals

    Sep 22, 2014, 2:14 PM EDT

    laroche getty Getty Images

    LaRoche has bounced back nicely from a down season in 2013, hitting .255 with 25 homers and a career-high 80 walks on the way to an .811 OPS.

  5. HBT Daily: Who will be on the outside looking in?

    Sep 22, 2014, 2:00 PM EDT

    HBT Daily Logo

    The A’s? The Mariners? The Royals? Does it help if I tell you that I’m always wrong about these things?

  6. Royals finish with their highest attendance in 23 years

    Sep 22, 2014, 1:47 PM EDT

    Ned Yost Getty Images

    They’re an unshakable bunch, Royals fans.

  7. Major League Baseball creates a pace of game committee

    Sep 22, 2014, 12:13 PM EDT

    Clayton Kershaw, Chad Billingsley

    They hope to have some measures in place to attack slow play in time for the 2015 season.

  8. Mat Latos is done for the year

    Sep 22, 2014, 11:44 AM EDT

    latos getty Getty Images

    The whole year?!!! *someone whispers in my ear that there’s only a week left* Oh, in that case.

  9. Frank Wren fired as Braves GM, John Hart to take over on an interim basis

    Sep 22, 2014, 10:56 AM EDT

    Frank Wren

    The Braves cratered this year. Someone had to take the fall.

  10. UPDATE: Frank Wren likely to be fired by the Braves, Fredi Gonzalez likely to stay

    Sep 22, 2014, 10:31 AM EDT

    Fredi Gonzalez Getty Images

    It looks like Frank Wren is gonna take the fall for the Braves’ collapse.

  11. AND DOWN THE STRETCH THEY COME! Sizing up the final week of the regular season

    Sep 22, 2014, 9:40 AM EDT

    Screen Shot 2014-09-22 at 9.39.12 AM AP

    What’s left to be decided? And who will be left standing this time next week?

  12. Giants CEO Larry Baer thinks advertisements on uniforms are coming soon

    Sep 22, 2014, 8:45 AM EDT

    Your Ad Here

    And he tries to peddle the idea that allowing them would keep ticket prices down. Suuuuure it will, Larry.

  13. Must-Click Link: Derek Jeter opens up. Seriously, he really does.

    Sep 22, 2014, 7:00 AM EDT

    Derek Jeter Getty Images

    About his future. About the press. About the Steinbrenners. About Old Yankee Stadium vs. New Yankee Stadium. But not about A-Rod.

  14. And That Happened: Sunday’s scores and highlights

    Sep 22, 2014, 5:14 AM EDT

    Screen Shot 2014-09-21 at 7.55.58 PM AP

    The Royals salvage one and their hopes of an AL Central title remain alive.

  15. Video: Josh Donaldson crushes walk-off homer as Athletics down the Phillies

    Sep 21, 2014, 11:05 PM EDT

    Josh Donaldson Josh Donaldson

    Josh Donaldson gave the Athletics a spark when he delivered a walk-off two-run home run in the 10th inning against the Phillies on Sunday.

  16. Neal Huntington intends to keep Russell Martin in a Pirates uniform

    Sep 21, 2014, 10:15 PM EDT

    Russell Martin Russell Martin

    It seems soon-to-be free agent Russell Martin is on his way to a big payday in the off-season, but Pirates GM Neal Huntington still intends to keep the catcher in a Pirates uniform.

  17. Joe Maddon on league-wide drop in offense: “The hitter’s at a total disadvantage right now”

    Sep 21, 2014, 9:25 PM EDT

    Joe Maddon Joe Maddon

    Joe Maddon’s Rays are just one piece of the puzzle that has been the MLB-wide drop in offense over the last five years.

  18. Jurickson Profar won’t play in the Arizona Fall League due to shoulder soreness

    Sep 21, 2014, 8:35 PM EDT

    Jurickson Profar Jurickson Profar

    More bad news for the snakebitten Rangers: Jurickson Profar won’t play in the Arizona Fall League due to lingering soreness in his right shoulder.

Featured video

Who's outside looking in on playoffs?
Top 10 MLB Player Searches
  1. R. Castillo (2926)
  2. D. Ortiz (2033)
  3. A. Pagan (2029)
  4. M. Trout (2023)
  5. A. Pujols (1977)
  1. J. Hamilton (1912)
  2. N. Arenado (1851)
  3. G. Stanton (1819)
  4. H. Ramirez (1807)
  5. C. Kershaw (1777)