Skip to content

Mark Prior and The Heartbreak Club

Dec 10, 2013, 2:20 PM EDT

mark prior cubs-thumb-175x244-11817

There were two eye-opening bits of news here in this story about Mark Prior retiring.

1. I honestly thought he retired five years ago.

2. Mark Prior is still only 33 years old.

The second of those bits is even more shocking than the first. He is STILL only 33? If Mark Prior had stayed healthy, he would only now be signing a seven-year, $190 million deal with the Mariners or somebody. Baseball can be an extremely cruel game.

Prior probably should have won the Cy Young Award in 2003, when he was just 22 years old. The award went to Eric Gagne because it was one of those periodic years when the voters fall in love with relief pitching all over again. Gagne had a superb year for a closer … but not markedly different from John Smoltz that same year, Trevor Hoffman in 1998 or Craig Kimbrel and Greg Holland this year. Prior pitched more than twice as many innings and was significantly more valuable.

Anyway, people had to figure Prior would win plenty of Cy Young Awards. Here are the greatest pitching performances since World War II for pitchers 22 or younger:

1. Dwight Gooden, 1985, 24-4, 1.53 ERA, league-leading 276 Ks.
2. Bert Blyleven, 1973, 20-17, 9 shutouts, 325 innings pitched.
3. Mark Fidrych, 1976, 19-9, league leading 2.34 ERA, 24 complete games.
4. Vida Blue, 1971, 24-8, league-leading 1.82 ERA, 301 strikeouts, Cy and MVP winner.
5. Larry Dierker, 1969, 20-13, 2.33 ERA, 305 innings, 20 complete games.
6. Sudden Sam McDowell, 1965, 17-11, league-leading 2.18 ERA, 325 strikeouts.
7. Mark Prior, 2003, 18-6, 2.43 ERA, 245 strikeouts.
8. Frank Tanana, 1975, 16-9, 2.62 ERA, league-leading 269 strikeouts.
9. Bret Saberhagen, 1985, 20-6, 2.87 ERA, Cy Young winner.
10. Frank Tanana, 1976, 19-10, 2.43 ERA, 261 strikeouts.

Of this list, only Blyleven went on to a Hall of Fame career. Tanana, who is on the list twice, blew out his arm and reinvented himself as a soft-tossing lefty. Dwight Gooden, Sam McDowell and Vida Blue all dealt with various demons and fell a few steps short of greatness. Larry Dierker had an up and down career, and Bret Saberhagen was alternately brilliant and injured.

Then, Mark Fidrych and Mark Prior belong to the same club, the heartbreak club. They each had one glorious year in the Major Leagues. Their bodies would not hold up for another. Fidrych felt his arm go dead in the middle of the next season. Prior had trouble with his achilles tendon the next year — people would always suspect it was his elbow and the Cubs just didn’t want to admit it. In 2005 he was pitching quite well and he got hit by a batted ball that smashed his elbow. In 2006 the Cubs announced that he had a “loose shoulder,” which does not seem like a medical term but Mark Prior was never even a decent Major League pitcher again.

Lots of people blame overwork for the fall of both Fidrych and Prior, and that does make some sense. Fidrych in particular was abused — from May 15 to August 29 that year he made 22 starts and pitched 198 innings. Quick math will tell you, he AVERAGED nine innings for those 22 starts. This is in part because he pitched 11 innings four times during the stretch and 10 innings once. It was pretty close to criminal.

Prior’s overuse was not nearly as pronounced, but people did notice even at the time that Dusty Baker was having Prior (and fellow phenom Kerry Wood) throw a lot of pitches. In September of 2003, during the pennant run, Prior threw 131, 129, 109, 124, 131 and 133 pitches in his six starts. It’s interesting: None of those were complete games. Even now, there is much disagreement about pitch counts and how best to protect young pitcher’s arms and so on. I guess the infuriating part with the Cubs was that there seemed no visible effort whatsoever to protect Prior’s arm. Maybe it wouldn’t have made any difference, but you sort of wished they would have at least made a show of it.

When Prior was young and right, he was all but unhittable. He had a fastball he could pump up into the high 90s and his better pitch was a curveball that was like setting the phaser to stun. His curve would just leave Major League hitters frozen — sometimes it seemed like they were still standing at the plate long after Prior had reached the dugout. He walked just 50 batters in his amazing season.

His effort to come back has been both touching and sad. Anyone can understand: He was destined to become one of the best pitchers in baseball history, and he had it taken away from him, and he had trouble accepting it. From Tennessee to Iowa, from Orange County to Oklahoma City, from Tampa to Scranton to Pawtucket to Louisville he chased ghosts, hoping against hope for some part of himself to return. I imagine that at times he snapped off the old curveball or fired a fastball that hopped a bit, and he found himself believing that he would come all the way back. Then there would be more pain.

The Chicago Tribune on Tuesday had a three paragraph note acknowledging Prior’s official retirement. The first few words were “Former Cubs Phenom Mark Prior.” And sadly, those are the last words too.

  1. djdvd - Dec 10, 2013 at 2:23 PM

    On a positive note, he could start a sick music career as “Mark Prior and The Heartbreak Club”.

  2. sdelmonte - Dec 10, 2013 at 2:26 PM

    You read things like this, and you look at Harvey and Strasburg, and you hold your breath every time they pitch, even when they are being amazing.

  3. hittfamily - Dec 10, 2013 at 2:29 PM

    24 Complete games?!? 20 Complete games?!?

    Todays ballplayers are such sissies. Guys like Larry Dierker and Mark Fidrych used to throw 20 complete games a year, and look how their careers turned out.

    And turn down that music!

    • number42is1 - Dec 10, 2013 at 2:42 PM

      this is exactly what caught my eye too. in fact i had to do a double take to make sure i read it correctly. out of his 28 decisions he had 24 complete games… that is insane.

      • hittfamily - Dec 10, 2013 at 6:18 PM

        Dierker was a starter in the Majors at 17 years old. His career was basically over by 25. Old guys always point to the survivors when talking about how today’s pitchers are coddled. They never speak of the Dierker’s and Fidrych’s though.

  4. innout10 - Dec 10, 2013 at 2:30 PM

    How many articles do we need for a guy who won 40 games in the majors? Yes he was incredible and its sad he got hurt… I can promise you he doesn’t want this much press about him retiring.

    • hittfamily - Dec 10, 2013 at 2:34 PM

      More than the 2 that’s been written here. You know how Matt Harvey was really good this year? Imagine if he was even better, then never pitched again.

  5. riggz91 - Dec 10, 2013 at 2:43 PM

    Mets had Harvey on an innings limit, pitch counts, the whole bit. They increased his innings each year ever so slightly, but still got hurt, luckily the elbow not the shoulder. That being said, you just never know with pitchers, not like its a natural motion.

    • yahmule - Dec 10, 2013 at 3:32 PM

      Harvey’s path to dominance wasn’t quite as straight as Prior’s. His injury was possibly due to over reliance on a suddenly ultra filthy slider and his reluctance to tell the Mets right away when his arm was hurting. Prior was more of a Strasburg type. Mega hyped from the start.

  6. JuniorGriffey'sRecliner - Dec 10, 2013 at 3:29 PM

    Dang you, Dusty Baker! Dang you to heck!

  7. hustleandflomax - Dec 10, 2013 at 4:15 PM

    I would like to suggest Rick Ankiel the pitcher for honorable mention. in 2000, he struck out 194 batters in 175 IP with an 11-7 record and a respectable 3.50 ERA. He was electrifying. One of the most devastating curveballs I have ever seen with mid-90s heat. yes, he carved out a decent career as an outfielder so he wasn’t forced from the game with injuries, but his 2000 post-season was pretty heartbreaking for Cards fans.

Leave Comment

You must be logged in to leave a comment. Not a member? Register now!

Top 10 MLB Player Searches
  1. G. Stanton (2322)
  2. B. Crawford (2291)
  3. Y. Puig (2269)
  4. G. Springer (2034)
  5. D. Wright (1999)
  1. J. Hamilton (1971)
  2. J. Fernandez (1959)
  3. D. Span (1907)
  4. H. Ramirez (1863)
  5. C. Correa (1823)