Skip to content

A-Rod will try to appeal to federal court, but he’s not likely to have success

Jan 11, 2014, 12:26 PM EST

In the wake of Alex Rodriguez’s 211-game suspension being reduced to 162 games, he said that he plans to appeal the decision to federal court. This is not unexpected, but I also believe that it will be a waste of his time and his money.

Arbitration is chosen by parties for the express purpose of avoiding litigation.  Courts are well aware of this. And in order to not undermine the integrity of arbitration awards, they very, very rarely overturn them.  Indeed, The Federal Arbitration Act provides the grounds for review of an arbitration decision. Such review is limited to overturning awards obtained by corruption or fraud. Or where the arbitrator himself is shown to be corrupted or to have engaged in misconduct of some kind or has shown a “manifest disregard for the law.”  Federal courts do not look at the facts and evidence anew and substitute their judgment for that of the arbitrator.

If there was any doubt about this at all, one merely peruse the trilogy of seminal decisions by the U.S. Supreme Court on the matter — Steelworkers v. Warrior & Gulf Navigation Co,  Steelworkers v. Enterprise Car and United Paperworkers v. Misco — and they can see how tall and steep a hill A-Rod has to climb:

Federal courts should decline to review the merits of arbitration awards under collective bargaining agreements . . . The question of interpretation of the collective bargaining agreement is a question for the arbitrator, and the courts have no business overruling his construction of the contract merely because their interpretation of it is different from his.

Collective bargaining agreements are governed by the Labor Management Relations Act. Under the LMRA, review of an arbitrator’s decision is even more limited. Courts cannot look at the case anew to decide if the collective bargaining agreement was followed or if the evidence was misinterpreted. They may only overturn the decision if the arbitrator clearly abused his authority and went way, way out on a limb. It’s hard to see A-Rod making that case here, even if a 162-game suspension seems a bit . . . random. Or, more to the point: calculated to have A-Rod gone for a certain length of time as opposed to reflecting the actual severity of the offense.

So go ahead, A-Rod: sue in federal court if you want. But you will waste your money. You will likely not get any help from the union — which, when MLB made noises about appealing the favorable arbitration ruling Ryan Braun received following his 2011-12 suspension, strongly stated such a move was ill-advised — and, most importantly, you will almost certainly lose.

Latest Posts
  1. O’s, Reds, Mariners “among possibilities” for Nori Aoki

    Dec 17, 2014, 11:35 PM EST

    nori aoki getty Getty Images

    According to CBS Sports’ Jon Heyman, the Orioles, Reds, and Mariners are among the possible landing spots for the 32-year-old free agent corner outfielder.

  2. Video: Jeff Samardzija welcomed back to Chicago before Blackhawks hockey game

    Dec 17, 2014, 10:18 PM EST

    jeff samardzija getty Getty Images

    Jeff Samardzija, former Cubs starter and recent White Sox trade acquisition, was welcomed back to the Windy City prior to Tuesday night’s NHL game between the Chicago Blackhawks and visiting Minnesota Wild …

  3. Diamondbacks avoid arbitration with David Hernandez

    Dec 17, 2014, 9:24 PM EST

    david hernandez getty Getty Images

    David Hernandez looked like a non-tender candidate after undergoing Tommy John reconstructive elbow surgery in April, but the Diamondbacks decided to keep him around …

  4. Marlins, Braves, Giants considering Jake Peavy

    Dec 17, 2014, 8:10 PM EST

    peavy getty Getty Images

    Ken Rosenthal of FOX Sports reports that the Marlins, Braves, and Giants have all expressed interest in free agent starter Jake Peavy …

  5. Royals sign Edinson Volquez for two years, $20 million

    Dec 17, 2014, 7:02 PM EST

    edinson volquez getty Getty Images

    From CBS Sports’ Jon Heyman comes word that the Royals have agreed to terms on a two-year, $20 million free agent contract with Edinson Volquez.

  6. Rays, Padres, Nationals agree to 11-player trade

    Dec 17, 2014, 6:16 PM EST

    wil myers rays getty Getty Images

    A three-team, 11-player trade has been agreed upon between the Rays, Padres, and Nationals. It centers around outfielder Wil Myers.

  7. Nick Markakis had neck surgery

    Dec 17, 2014, 5:08 PM EST

    Nick Markakis AP

    He is expected to be able to resume baseball activities before Spring Training begins.

  8. Blue Jays sign Ryan Kalish

    Dec 17, 2014, 4:16 PM EST

    Daniel Nava Getty Getty Images

    One-time Red Sox prospect trying to snag a bench gig.

  9. On some days, Pedro Martinez knew opposing hitters were “f****d”

    Dec 17, 2014, 4:05 PM EST

    Pedro Martinez AP

    If you don’t love Pedro Martinez there is no helping you.

  10. The Dbacks were apparently not pleased with Wade Miley’s conditioning

    Dec 17, 2014, 2:31 PM EST

    wade miley getty Getty Images

    The pitcher denies there were issues. But now he’s off to Boston, so I guess it doesn’t matter.

  11. So, apparently we’re sweating the Matt Kemp physical now

    Dec 17, 2014, 12:53 PM EST

    matt kemp getty Getty Images

    And if it blows up, it could impact the Jimmy Rollins trade too.

  12. The Red Sox acquire Anthony Varvaro from the Braves

    Dec 17, 2014, 12:30 PM EST

    Anthony Varvaro Getty Getty Images

    The Sox are getting themselves a handy reliever.

  13. Mariners acquire outfielder Justin Ruggiano from Cubs

    Dec 17, 2014, 12:12 PM EST

    Justin Ruggiano AP

    Seattle is looking for right-handed bats.

  14. Michael Kohn knew he’d play for the Braves when he was ten-years-old

    Dec 17, 2014, 11:53 AM EST

    crystal ball

    Right team, even if he picked the wrong position.

  15. “Nothing brewing” on Red Sox trading Allen Craig

    Dec 17, 2014, 11:15 AM EST

    allen craig getty Getty Images

    They’re getting lots of calls on him, though.

  16. The Wil Myers trade is “nearing the finish line”

    Dec 17, 2014, 11:10 AM EST

    wil myers getty Getty Images

    It appears as though it’ll only be a two-team trade, with Myers heading to San Diego.

  17. The United States will seek to normalize relations with Cuba

    Dec 17, 2014, 10:03 AM EST

    Cuba

    Which could have some baseball implications

Featured video

Cubs shore up rotation with Jon Lester
Top 10 MLB Player Searches
  1. M. Cabrera (4194)
  2. W. Myers (3065)
  3. M. Kemp (2667)
  4. W. Miley (2410)
  5. C. Headley (2341)
  1. J. Lester (2295)
  2. M. Morse (2272)
  3. M. Scherzer (1978)
  4. J. Upton (1939)
  5. C. Hamels (1907)