Skip to content

Jose Abreu and amazing home run starts

May 14, 2014, 11:51 AM EDT

jose abreu getty Getty Images

So to play off something that our own Aaron Gleeman wrote earlier here, there have been seven players in baseball history who have hit 15 home runs in their first 50 major league games. Chicago’s Jose Abreu will likely become the eighth — he has 14 home runs already in just 40 games.

The seven players so far are:

1. Wally Berger, 18
2. Wally Joyner, 17
3. Albert Pujols, 16
(tie) Mark McGwire, 16
(tie) Zeke Bonura, 16
6. Kevin Maas, 15
7. Ryan Braun, 15

It is fun to note that there are two guys named Wally on the top of the list … there have been five guys named Wally who have played in an All-Star Game; Berger and Joyner are two of them. The other three are Wally Moon, Wally Moses and Wally Westlake — all three  fantastic names. Wally Post cerainly should have been an All-Star in 1955 or 1956 but he was not. Wally Backman was a pretty good player. Wally Pipp was jobbed by history; he was a very good player who twice led the league in homers and once in triples but is remembered only as the guy Lou Gehrig replaced.

Anyway, of those seven who got off to such amazing home run starts, one is an all-time great (Albert Pujols), one was, for better or worse, the most prolific home run hitter in the game’s history (Mark McGwire) and one is a superstar who led the league in home runs in 2012 and now gets booed a lot (Ryan Braun).

The other four are  interesting.

Wally Berger was a very good player who has probably been overlooked by history. Here’s a great little piece of trivia that you can use wherever you might use great little piece of baseball trivia: Wally Berger is the only starter from the 1934 All-Star game who is NOT in the Hall of Fame. Here’s a list of those All-Stars with their Wins Above Replacement (WAR) and their Wins Above Average (WAA). I have a post coming up that talks about the difference.

Babe Ruth (163 WAR, 125.8 WAA)
Lou Gehrig (112.4 WAR, 78.5 WAA)
Jimmie Foxx (96.4 WAR, 62.9 WAA)
Charlie Gehringer (80.6 WAR, 45.4 WAA)
Frankie Frisch (70.4 WAR, 39.1 WAA)
Carl Hubbell (67.8 WAR, 38.7 WAA)
Joe Cronin (66.4 WAR, 35.9 WAA)
Al Simmons (68.7 WAR, 34.8 WAA)
Bill Terry (54.2 WAR, 31.8 WAA)
Bill Dickey (55.8 WAR, 31.6 WAA)
Gabby Hartnett (53.4 WAR, 29.6 WAA)
Joe Medwick (55.5 WAR, 28.1 WAA)
**Wally Berger (42.1 WAR, 23.5 WAA)**
Travis Jackson (44.0 WAR, 22.7 WAA)
Kiki Cuyler (46.7 WAR, 21.2 WAA)
Lefty Gomez (43.1 WAR, 19.7 WAA)
Heine Manush (45.8 WAR, 15.5 WAA)
Pie Traynor (36.2 WAR, 10.2 WAA)

Point is, if you were going to leave one starter from that game out of the Hall of Fame, it probably should not have been Berger. Bill James talked about three similar contemporary center fielders: Berger, Hack Wilson and Earl Averill. He thinks Berger was the best player. The other two, though, are in the Hall of Fame.

Berger is not in the Hall of Fame because his career ended abruptly. Up to age 30, he was a career .305 hitter with a .533 slugging percentage, he had led the league in home runs and he set a rookie home run record (38) that lasted for more than a half century until it was finally broken by another guy on this list, Mark McGwire. But Berger hurt his shoulder and was traded to the Giants in 1937, it was not a good fit, he only got three at-bats in the World Series and was shipped to Cincinnati less than a year later. He never played a full season after that, and he retired at 34 and joined the Navy.

Wally Joyner was a legitimate phenomenon — in 1986 he was called Wally World after the theme park in National Lampoon’s Vacation. Nobody had expected that kind of power from him. He seemed more a doubles kind of guy. He had hit 12 home runs as a 22-year old in Waterbury, and he 12 home runs as a 23-year-old in Edmonton. He hit his first home run off of Mark Langston … that was in his second career game. A week later, he hit one off Milt Wilcox. He had six home runs through his first 23 games, which was mildly surprising.

But then he got hot. He hit homers on back-to-back days at Milwaukee. Afteout a week later, he homered against Milwaukee again and the next day he had his first two-homer game, hitting both off of Boston’s Al Nipper. He homered again the next day and, after a homerless day, had ANOTHER two-homer game, this time in Detroit.

Man everybody was excited about Wally Joyner. Everybody talked about what a nice guy he was, what a magical story he was. Of course, he was not really a home run hitter, and so the home run thing could not last. It did not. Joyner hit 19 home runs in his first 61 games. He hit three in the 93 games that followed.

The next year, Wally World did hit what would be a career high 34 home runs … but that next year was 1987, when baseballs flew like lightning bugs, and once things settled down Joyner settled into the kind of player everyone kind of thought he would be — a pretty good average, double-digit homers kind of guy. He played all through the Selig Power Hour Decade but only once managed even 20 homers in a season in the 1990s and he never hit 25.

Zeke Bonura played for the Chicago White Sox in the 1930s — he was a very likeable character like Wally Joyner. His actual name was Henry, but they called him Zeke because a sportswriter once commented about him, “What a physique” and “physique” was just shortened to “Zeke.” He was 6-foot, about 210 pounds and was a a football player at Loyola in New Orleans. He hit two home runs in his second game and had back-to-back two-homer games in May. In all, he hit 27 homers as a rookie which was a White Sox record for about a half century, until Ron Kittle broke it.

Any time you can mention Ron Kittle, you should.

Bonura hit 21 homers in his second year, had 138 RBIs in his third and was a very good hitter until age 30, not quite as successful but similar to Wally Berger. He was among the first major leaguers to enlist for World War II and never played in the big leagues after 1940 — his career was short but his .307/.380/.487 lifetime slash numbers are awfully good.

Finally there’s Kevin Maas — if you are a Yankees fan over a certain age, you probably feel a certain lump in your throat when you hear the name Kevin Maas. He came up in June of 1990 with almost no fanfare at all. He had been a 22nd round pick, better known for his academics (he was an engineering major at Berkeley) than his baseball. He’d hit a few home runs in a mostly uninteresting four years in the minors. He came up in the middle of the worst Yankees season since they were named the New York Yankees.

And he mashed home runs. He hit his first on the fourth of July … it was that kind of story. He banged two home runs 10 days later againt the White Sox. In Texas, he hit homers on three consecutive days and a few days later he hit three more homers in a series against Detroit. He reached 10 home runs faster than any player in baseball history.

Maas had a beautiful swing, classic, left-handed, like The Natural. If he had come up in any other year, for any other team, it would have been a cool story. But in New York, in the middle of an otherwise lost season, Maas became this phenomenon. Yankees fans — and there are so many Yankees fans all over America — pinned so many hopes on him. “I’m not going to try to be the next Babe Ruth,” Maas pleaded but the next Babe Ruth was exactly how many people saw him, how many people HAD to see him. After hitting 21 homers in 79 games as a rookie and finishing second to Sandy Alomar in the Rookie of the Year award, he hit just .220 in his one full season in the big leagues in 1991 and then faded away.

What does this suggest about Abreu. Who knows? None of the previous home run heros were 27-year-old players who had already established themselves as superstars in Cuba. Abreu has shown in his first 40 games to be a free swinger who will strike out a lot and has massive power. McGwire might be the best comp on the board. I’m predicting 40 homers, approaching 45, if he stays healthy. But I predicted Kevin Maas would be a star too.

  1. georgewashingtonsghost - May 14, 2014 at 12:05 PM

    “But I predicted Kevin Maas would be a star too.” Who didn’t think he was going to be a star? I still have about dozen of his 1990 Upper Deck rookie cards. Man, those things were going to put me through college…

  2. greej1938l - May 14, 2014 at 12:09 PM

    Could have sworn this was an “Wally” article and not an Abreu one!

  3. drunkadamschefter - May 14, 2014 at 12:13 PM

    Not to be a grammar natzi, but the editing on this is horrible. Now I remember why I stick to my NFL lane.

    • drewsylvania - May 14, 2014 at 12:38 PM

      This is really enjoyable. One beef, though–how can McGwire be Abreu’s best comp? McGwire always had loads of walks.

      • drewsylvania - May 14, 2014 at 12:38 PM

        (once nested, always nested, says the site code)

    • dlevalley - May 14, 2014 at 1:21 PM

      You’ve got to understand — Joe writes more in an afternoon than most national writers produce in a month.

      His pieces (especially on his blog) will have a few typos. Even with the typos and a few awkward sentences, his writing is better than 98% of the crap people publish.

      Enjoy it; appreciate it. Or go read a well-edited “article” full of one-sentence paragraphs and ideas no better developed or researched than those you had eating breakfast this morning. There are plenty of those.

    • jerze2387 - May 14, 2014 at 1:24 PM

      Ironic that you spelled nazi wrong.

    • bellweather22 - May 14, 2014 at 1:39 PM

      Joe Poz is a typo waiting to happen. If that bothers you fellas in the “NFL Lane”, then hustle back over there. I hear there is some great intellectual discourse going on over there right now about Michael Sam’s first training camp shower.

  4. tysonpunchinguterus - May 14, 2014 at 12:16 PM

    Kevin Maas hit a HR in the first Yankees game I ever attended in 1990. Against the Indians. Yeah, it wasn’t exactly a killer matchup, but at 12 years old, I was just thrilled to be in Yankee Stadium and more thrilled to see that awful team win a game even if I didn’t get to see Don Mattingly play that day. What makes me feel even older than I am, that game was not televised in the NY area. Times have changed.

  5. psunick - May 14, 2014 at 12:41 PM

    45 home runs…and zero bat flips.

    • Jeremy T - May 14, 2014 at 2:16 PM

      Such a waste

  6. RickyB - May 14, 2014 at 1:07 PM

    I was at Kevin Maas’ first big league game and saw his first hit. But it wasn’t the most memorable thing about that day in MLB history — same night Fernando Valenzuela and Dave Stewart both threw no-hitters. And it wasn’t the most memorable event in that series against the White Sox — Andy Hawkins threw what was then a no-hitter in a 4-0 loss two days later (didn’t get to pitch the bottom of the ninth because it was a road game, so MLB doesn’t consider that a no-no no more). Saw that game in person, too.

  7. mikhelb - May 14, 2014 at 2:01 PM

    Mass was a very good story on that awful season (for those who were not around or were not in the yanks bandewaggon in those years: the 2013-2014 Yankees look a lot like them though the 90s NYY at least hit HRs).

    Donnie was injured, our pitchers were very old and on their way out, the few younger pitchers were not very good, the front office was taking care of trading their minor leagues for MLB fill ins, etc.

    PS
    I too still have a few of Mass’ rookie cards (Donruss and Fleer).

  8. peddealer - May 14, 2014 at 9:21 PM

    Go back to before Abreu signed, when he first defected and I predicted some of this….

    I wanted my Rangers to invest in him and Tanaka, and find a serviceable OF, not Choo….

    So far Tanaka, lights out,
    Abreu , Offensive Star, and better at D than Prince, …. Any non believers need me to go back and find it?

    I called Abreu hitting .295 with 35-40 HR and 110 RBI THIS SEASON…

    Also think of a 1-2 of Darvish and Tanaka, just made my hairs on my arm raise…..

Leave Comment

You must be logged in to leave a comment. Not a member? Register now!

Featured video

Papelbon destined to be traded?
Top 10 MLB Player Searches
  1. G. Stanton (3454)
  2. B. Belt (2149)
  3. A. Rizzo (2046)
  4. C. Young (1992)
  5. J. Hamilton (1971)
  1. B. Gardner (1963)
  2. R. Castillo (1922)
  3. H. Ryu (1762)
  4. D. Pedroia (1708)
  5. C. Davis (1704)