Skip to content

A strange replay in Oakland reveals a big hole in the replay rule

Jul 4, 2014, 9:04 AM EST

Screen Shot 2014-07-04 at 9.03.24 AM Getty Images

The Oakland A’s were put in a lose-lose situation by an umpire’s call and an instant replay decision in yesterday’s game against the Blue Jays. It was a play and a call which should, if anyone is paying attention, lead to an immediate tweak to the instant replay rule.

Here’s what happened: with one out in the second inning, the Blue Jays loaded the bases against Sonny Gray and the A’s. Anthony Gose hit a grounder to A’s first baseman Nate Freiman. Freiman appeared to tag Munenori Kawasaki as he ran for second base, but umpire Vic Carapazza ruled that Freiman missed the tag and Kawasaki was safe. The play is still in motion with runners heading toward every bag. Freiman fires the ball home to catcher Steven Vogt. Vogt receives the ball and steps on home plate to get the force out of Edwin Encarnacion, who was running from third. Play ends. You can watch it all here.

Blue Jays manager John Gibbons comes out to challenge the call on the Freiman tag of Kawasaki. That is, he comes out in an effort to have his own base runner, who was called safe, called out. He does so because if Kawasaki was tagged, there was no force play in effect at home and Encarnacion needed to have been tagged, rather than forced out. After a four minute+ review, it is ruled that, yes, Kawasaki was tagged and that Encarnacion, since he was not tagged, was safe at home. A run was awarded to the Jays.

Which is totally freaking insane.

Vogt had absolutely no reason to tag Encarnancion. He was, quite reasonably, relying on the call that was just made in real time during an active play — that Kawasaki was safe and thus a force play was in effect — in doing what he did. By awarding the run the way it was rewarded, the umpires and replay officials were doing more than correcting a call. They were creating fictions. Bob Melvin played the rest of the game under protest. Luckily for the A’s and the league it ended up not mattering, as the A’s won the game regardless.

You can’t anticipate every eventuality when a new rule is put in place, but you can certainly move quickly to patch a hole. Major League Baseball needs to patch this hole immediately and acknowledge that the players can only act based on what they know at the time, so what is known at the time has to control. There needs to be an immediate tweak to the rule which goes something like this: if an umpire’s call on the field affects the subsequent decision-making of players on the same play, the call is not reviewable.

Latest Posts
  1. Report: Matt Kemp has arthritis in both hips

    Dec 18, 2014, 12:17 PM EST

    Matt Kemp Getty Images

    And the Padres “continue to consult medical experts.”

  2. Let’s not get ahead of ourselves on the United States’ conquest of baseball in Cuba

    Dec 18, 2014, 11:39 AM EST

    Cake

    Let’s pump the brakes a bit on the imminent MLB takeover of Cuba.

  3. The future of the Rays in St. Petersburg could be decided today

    Dec 18, 2014, 10:30 AM EST

    Tropicana Field

    The city council will vote on the deal allowing the team to look for a new stadium site.

  4. Hideki Okajima is staying in Japan

    Dec 18, 2014, 10:15 AM EST

    Hideki Okajima AP

    Okajima, who pitched six years in the majors for the Red Sox and briefly the A’s, has signed with the Yokohama Bay Stars.

  5. Kenta Maeda will not be posted

    Dec 18, 2014, 9:58 AM EST

    kenta maeda getty Getty Images

    He profiled as a back-of-the-rotation starter in the United States.

  6. What will the future of Cuban players in MLB look like?

    Dec 18, 2014, 9:41 AM EST

    Cuba

    It won’t be a free agent free-for-all and it likely won’t be a draft. So how will the Cuban baseball players come to the United States?

  7. A former White Sox outfielder is the Ambassador to New Zealand

    Dec 18, 2014, 8:55 AM EST

    white sox logo

    Sadly, it is not Rudy Law. Though it is one of his teammates.

  8. Chris Davis will have a therapeutic use exemption for Adderall next season

    Dec 18, 2014, 8:00 AM EST

    chris davis getty Getty Images

    The Orioles’ slugger got a 25 suspension for taking the drug without an exemption in 2014. He’ll be back on it in 2015.

  9. O’s, Reds, Mariners “among possibilities” for Nori Aoki

    Dec 17, 2014, 11:35 PM EST

    nori aoki getty Getty Images

    According to CBS Sports’ Jon Heyman, the Orioles, Reds, and Mariners are among the possible landing spots for the 32-year-old free agent corner outfielder.

  10. Video: Jeff Samardzija welcomed back to Chicago before Blackhawks hockey game

    Dec 17, 2014, 10:18 PM EST

    jeff samardzija getty Getty Images

    Jeff Samardzija, former Cubs starter and recent White Sox trade acquisition, was welcomed back to the Windy City prior to Tuesday night’s NHL game between the Chicago Blackhawks and visiting Minnesota Wild …

  11. Diamondbacks avoid arbitration with David Hernandez

    Dec 17, 2014, 9:24 PM EST

    david hernandez getty Getty Images

    David Hernandez looked like a non-tender candidate after undergoing Tommy John reconstructive elbow surgery in April, but the Diamondbacks decided to keep him around …

  12. Marlins, Braves, Giants considering Jake Peavy

    Dec 17, 2014, 8:10 PM EST

    peavy getty Getty Images

    Ken Rosenthal of FOX Sports reports that the Marlins, Braves, and Giants have all expressed interest in free agent starter Jake Peavy …

  13. Royals sign Edinson Volquez for two years, $20 million

    Dec 17, 2014, 7:02 PM EST

    edinson volquez getty Getty Images

    From CBS Sports’ Jon Heyman comes word that the Royals have agreed to terms on a two-year, $20 million free agent contract with Edinson Volquez.

  14. Rays, Padres, Nationals agree to 11-player trade

    Dec 17, 2014, 6:16 PM EST

    wil myers rays getty Getty Images

    A three-team, 11-player trade has been agreed upon between the Rays, Padres, and Nationals. It centers around outfielder Wil Myers.

  15. Nick Markakis had neck surgery

    Dec 17, 2014, 5:08 PM EST

    Nick Markakis AP

    He is expected to be able to resume baseball activities before Spring Training begins.

  16. Blue Jays sign Ryan Kalish

    Dec 17, 2014, 4:16 PM EST

    Daniel Nava Getty Getty Images

    One-time Red Sox prospect trying to snag a bench gig.

  17. On some days, Pedro Martinez knew opposing hitters were “f****d”

    Dec 17, 2014, 4:05 PM EST

    Pedro Martinez AP

    If you don’t love Pedro Martinez there is no helping you.

  18. The Dbacks were apparently not pleased with Wade Miley’s conditioning

    Dec 17, 2014, 2:31 PM EST

    wade miley getty Getty Images

    The pitcher denies there were issues. But now he’s off to Boston, so I guess it doesn’t matter.

Featured video

Cubs shore up rotation with Jon Lester
Top 10 MLB Player Searches
  1. M. Cabrera (4244)
  2. W. Myers (3305)
  3. M. Kemp (2910)
  4. W. Miley (2449)
  5. C. Headley (2384)
  1. M. Morse (2380)
  2. J. Lester (2339)
  3. M. Scherzer (2028)
  4. J. Upton (1990)
  5. C. Hamels (1940)