Skip to content

No, Jeter’s final season isn’t that much better than Mantle’s, DiMaggio’s and Mattingly’s

Jul 18, 2014, 10:17 AM EDT

Jeter Respect AP

Weird column from Mike Vaccaro at the Post today. In it he looks at Derek Jeter‘s swan song and compares it to Mickey Mantle’s, Joe DiMaggio’s and Don Mattingly’s. The upshot: Mantle, DiMaggio and Mattingly all had their glorious careers end rather ignominiously, with their bodies hobbled and their production a shadow of what it once was. Jeter, on the other hand, is “sticking the landing” better, still being reliable and atoning nicely for his 2013, which was lost to injury:

Could he have a skid like the one that nearly obliterated Mattingly’s last go-round? He could. He’s had stretches of ineffectiveness this year. But again, when you’ve watched Jeter as long as you have, you understand something: There’s no way he will allow himself to become a burden. It seems he’s come to peace with who he is at age 40: a contributor, a leader, a captain, a player you’d certainly rather have on your team than not, a star by reputation rather than repetition. Reliably reliable.

I guess he’s certainly in better physical shape than those other guys were but it’s not like they were chopped liver while Jeter remains some prime contributor:

  • Mantle’s final season by OPS+: 143
  • DiMaggio’s final season by OPS+: 116
  • Mattingly’s final season by OPS+: 97
  • Jeter’s final season by OPS+ 81

I get that the optics were bad for those other guys given that they were hobbled physically while Jeter is not, but I feel like the stories told about the end to their careers — and careers like that of Willie Mays and other major stars — are often misleading. Mantle was still an extremely valuable hitter and most people who say otherwise don’t appreciate how good an offensive season he was actually having in 1968 given that it was The Year of the Pitcher. The other guys weren’t what they used to be, but to say they left on a terrible note says more about what we thought of them in their primes, not what they actually were in their last year.

Jeter really isn’t that different than them. He’s still useful given how thin shortstop is in major league baseball, but he has fallen off just as much if not more than the other retiring Yankees legends have. It’s the same story that can be told about most players when they reach this point, actually. Not a different one in any notable respect.

It just feels like yet another instance of telling stories we want to be true rather than stories that actually are true. We were sad that Mickey Mantle didn’t look like Mickey Mantle anymore so we overstate his decline. We’re generally OK with how Jeter looks now so we overstate the value of his final season.

Latest Posts
  1. Report: Yoenis Cespedes heading to the New York Mets

    Jul 31, 2015, 3:59 PM EDT

    cespedes getty Getty Images

    The Mets add a big bat to their anemic offense. And they don’t have to part with Zack Wheeler to do it.

  2. Garrett Jones designated for assignment by the Yankees

    Jul 31, 2015, 3:12 PM EDT

    Garrett Jones Yankees Getty Images

    Jones struggled in a part-time role for the Yankees.

  3. The Mets are making a push for Yoenis Cespedes

    Jul 31, 2015, 2:27 PM EDT

    Yoenis Cespedes Getty Images

    This is the third outfielder to whom they’ve been linked in three days. Let’s see if this one takes.

  4. The Blue Jays pick up Ben Revere from the Phillies

    Jul 31, 2015, 2:13 PM EDT

    Ben Revere Ben Revere

    He’s hitting hitting .298/.334/.374 and will likely take over left field duties.

  5. The Cubs, Padres and Red Sox are said to be talking about a three-way deal

    Jul 31, 2015, 2:08 PM EDT

    San Diego Padres Logo

    Jed Hoyer has worked for all three of these teams. He may be in the middle of a big trade involving them all.

  6. Twins trade for Rays reliever Kevin Jepsen

    Jul 31, 2015, 2:05 PM EDT

    Kevin Jepsen Rays Getty Images

    Bullpen help has been an obvious need for Minnesota.

  7. Cubs trade for Dan Haren

    Jul 31, 2015, 1:30 PM EDT

    Dan Haren Dan Haren

    The Cubs get a starter.

  8. 2015 MLB Trade Deadline Tracker

    Jul 31, 2015, 12:30 PM EDT

    150731-Justin-Upton Getty Images

    We’re recapping all of the deals as they come down.

  9. Cardinals add more bullpen help, get Jonathan Broxton from Brewers

    Jul 31, 2015, 12:02 PM EDT

    Jonathan Broxton Brewers Getty Images

    Cardinals’ bullpen is suddenly stacked with closers and ex-closers.

  10. David Price got a flat tire on the way to Toronto

    Jul 31, 2015, 11:11 AM EDT

    david price getty Getty Images

    Maybe he’ll see Daniel Norris coming the other way in his van?

  11. Orioles trade for Brewers outfielder Gerardo Parra

    Jul 31, 2015, 10:39 AM EDT

    Gerardo Parra Brewers Getty Images

    Milwaukee receives a starting pitcher prospect in return.

  12. Now the Yankees said to be “aggressively pursuing” Aroldis Chapman

    Jul 31, 2015, 9:49 AM EDT

    Aroldis Chapman AP

    Or, the very least, want the Padres to think they are so as to bring Craig Kimbrel’s price down.

  13. Red Sox are considering moves for Tyson Ross or Carlos Carrasco

    Jul 31, 2015, 9:25 AM EDT

    red sox logo

    They have the worst ERA in the AL, so any starter would be a nice addition.

  14. Cardinals hoping Matt Holliday will play again this season

    Jul 31, 2015, 9:18 AM EDT

    St. Louis Cardinals v Cincinnati Reds Getty Images

    Another torn quadriceps muscle for the All-Star left fielder.

  15. Padres and Astros said to be “working on something big”

    Jul 31, 2015, 8:55 AM EDT

    astros logo

    I feel like Ken Caminiti has to be involved.

  16. The Cubs and Indians are talking about Carlos Carrasco

    Jul 31, 2015, 8:43 AM EDT

    Carlos Carrasco AP

    He’d be both a 2015 and a future move.

Top 10 MLB Player Searches
  1. C. Hamels (5865)
  2. C. Gomez (4800)
  3. T. Tulowitzki (4371)
  4. M. Trout (3933)
  5. J. Cueto (3893)
  1. C. Gonzalez (3698)
  2. A. Rodriguez (3637)
  3. D. Price (3533)
  4. J. Bruce (3200)
  5. T. Clippard (3170)