Skip to content

Winners and losers at the trade deadline

Jul 31, 2014, 10:12 PM EST

It doesn’t take a whole heck of a lot of baseball sense to name the Tigers, A’s and Red Sox trade deadline winners this year, so let’s see if we can’t be a little less obvious than that. Here are some other people, as well as teams, that had good and not so good days Thursday.

In case you missed it, here’s our Trade Deadline Tracker.

Winners

Tigers GM Dave Dombrowski: I’m not so convinced the Tigers made the right move parting with Austin Jackson and Drew Smyly for David Price for three reasons. First, Rick Porcello and his 3.24 ERA were likely to be more than fine in the postseason rotation. Second, the downgrade from Jackson to Rajai Davis in center field is big offensively and defensively (Davis’s OBPs against right-handed pitching the last three years: .290, .273 and .299). Third, Smyly seemed poised to be a very important piece of the Detroit pen in October.  Of course, all of that said, Price was the most valuable pitcher on the market. Dombrowski got his man yet again. He always seems to.

Jon Lester (LHP Athletics): Not only does Lester get to fatten up his numbers in Oakland for a couple of months and potentially improve those Hall of Fame credentials during another playoff run, but thanks to today’s trade, he’s no longer tied to draft-pick compensation as a free agent this winter. That could increase his haul by a few million bucks.

Oscar Taveras (OF Cardinals): It’s your turn to shine, Oscar. After getting mentioned in the Price and Lester talk, Taveras not only stayed put in St. Louis, but he now has himself a clear starting gig with Allen Craig gone to Boston. It hardly seemed like a coincidence that he responded by homering today against the Padres. The Cards could call up Randal Grichuk to platoon with Taveras against left-handers, but even if that happens, Taveras will no longer have to wait until the lineups are posted each day to figure out whether he’s playing.

St. Louis Cardinals: They got John Lackey and Justin Masterson without parting with Taveras or dipping into their stable of arms beyond Joe Kelly. Lackey has been a bulldog in the playoffs, and while I’m not sold on Masterson turning it around as a starter this year, I don’t deny it’s a possibility, and even if he doesn’t, he could be a force in relief in October. Also good: the Pirates did nothing Thursday and the Brewers failed to add to their staff (though they did get a nice piece in Gerardo Parra for the outfield). The Cardinals still have to get to the playoffs, but if they do, they have at least as good of a chance as any NL team of reaching the World Series.

Houston Astros: I’ve never been a big Jarred Cosart fan. I’m also not a big Jake Marisnick fan, so today’s trade with the Marlins wasn’t necessarily a slam dunk. It is worth a try, though. 2013 first-round pick Colin Moran should make it as at least an average regular at third base and might be something more. Marisnick has the tools to be an above average regular, too; I’m just skeptical he’ll put them together. To get the pair (along with a wild card arm in Francis Marte and a draft pick) for Cosart, and a couple of likely role players in Kike Hernandez and Austin Wates was a smart move.

Losers

Every AL contender besides the A’s and Tigers: Pick your poison… Lester, Sonny Gray, Scott Kazmir and Jeff Samardzija or Max Scherzer, Price, Justin Verlander and Anibal Sanchez. The Angels have been the AL’s second best team this year — probably MLB’s second best team — but it’s going to be awfully difficult to get past those pitching staffs and into the World Series.

Philadelphia Phillies: OK, so this one is terribly obvious. It could be seen coming, too. It at least seemed that Ruben Amaro Jr. would move Marlon Byrd and/or Antonio Bastardo, two guys who had some legitimate trade value without the Phillies having to eat any money. Nope. Nothing. Nada. It’s disappointing that Amaro couldn’t pull off some sort of a deal with so little to lose. On the plus side, most of the rest of the Phillies will clear waivers, making them available in August deals.

Kansas City Royals: GM Dayton Moore couldn’t sell. To do so would have been to admit defeat and most likely would have cost him his job. Unfortunately, Moore also failed to add anything after flirting with several starters. All signs point to the Royals finishing in the neighborhood of .500 as a result.

Daniel Nava (OF Red Sox): The Yoenis Cespedes acquisition left room for Nava, but that changed a couple of hours later when Craig joined him on Boston’s roster. That’s a shame. Nava is hitting .330 over the last couple of months, has a better career OPS against righties than Craig and is a better defender in the outfield than Craig. He deserves to start against righties, but he’s probably going to take a backseat because of Craig’s contract.

Mookie Betts (2BOF, ?? Red Sox): Hard to tell what’s in store for one of baseball’s best prospects now. Already having moved off his natural home of second base, Betts finds himself behind Cespedes, Craig, Jackie Bradley Jr., Nava and Shane Victorino in the Red Sox outfield. Perhaps Betts will overtake Bradley at some point, but that’s going to be a tough assignment, what with Bradley looking like the AL’s premier defensive center fielder at the moment.

Cincinnati Reds: Johnny Cueto, Mat Latos, Homer Bailey, Mike Leake and Alfredo Simon, yet your GM and ownership won’t step up to bring in any kind of bat with Joey Votto and Brandon Phillips hurt. This has been bothering me for weeks.

Joc Pederson (OF Dodgers): Pederson’s minor league numbers sat he’s ready — the 22-year-old is hitting .319/.448/.587 for Triple-A Albuquerque — but he stayed buried in Los Angeles after both being involved in Price and Lester rumors and also potentially being a candidate for promotion in the event of a Matt Kemp, Carl Crawford or Andre Ethier deal (of course, one of those could still come in August).

Colorado Rockies: Kevin Gausman for Jorge De La Rosa? Telling teams you’re not interesting in moving the NL’s oldest player (LaTroy Hawkins)? Sometimes it seems like the Rockies are perfectly content to be bad.

Not Losers

New York Yankees/Seattle Mariners: I can’t put them in the winners category since they’re AL contenders not located in Oakland and Detroit, but I still like the moves. The Yankees added Martin Prado and Stephen Drew to the haul that already included Chase Headley and Brandon McCarthy without significantly dimming their future prospects. That’s just good dealing. And while the Mariners did give up a pretty nice piece in Nick Franklin, he stopped fitting into the club’s future the day Robinson Cano was signed. With Jackson and Chris Denorfia in the fold, the Mariners upped their chances to reach the playoffs and gave their fans a product worth investing in for the first time in a long time.

Latest Posts
  1. Blue Jays acquire Josh Donaldson in a trade with the Athletics

    Nov 28, 2014, 9:57 PM EST

    josh donaldson getty Getty Images

    Brett Lawrie and a couple of minor leaguers are headed to the Athletics in exchange for Josh Donaldson.

  2. Report: Athletics working on a trade

    Nov 28, 2014, 8:44 PM EST

    Josh Donaldson Josh Donaldson

    The Athletics are reportedly close to getting three or four players back in a trade involving starter Jeff Samardzija.

  3. Aaron Crow could get a chance to start for the Marlins

    Nov 28, 2014, 8:15 PM EST

    Aaron Crow Getty Images

    Marlins pitcher Aaron Crow, recently acquired from the Royals, could get a shot in the starting rotation.

  4. Report: Ross Detwiler’s camp has suggested the Nationals trade him, if possible

    Nov 28, 2014, 7:10 PM EST

    Washington Nationals starter Ross Detwiler throws a first inning pitch against the Los Angeles Dodgers during their MLB National League baseball game in Los Angeles Reuters

    Ross Detwiler had a frustrating 2014 season with the Nationals. It sounds like he wants a change of scenery, if possible.

  5. White Sox sign Tony Campana to a minor league deal

    Nov 28, 2014, 6:05 PM EST

    Tony Campana Getty Images

    The White Sox signed speedster Tony Campana to a minor league deal.

  6. Jamie Moyer leaves the Phillies’ broadcasting team

    Nov 28, 2014, 4:42 PM EST

    Jamie Moyer

    It’s one and done in the booth for the old lefty.

  7. Marlins acquire Aaron Crow from Royals

    Nov 28, 2014, 12:23 PM EST

    Aaron Crow AP

    Crow made the All-Star team as a rookie in 2011.

  8. Shane Victorino says he should be the Red Sox’ starting right fielder

    Nov 28, 2014, 12:00 PM EST

    Shane Victorino Getty Getty Images

    And he’d like you to tell him who’s a better option.

  9. Pedro Strop was involved in an accident in the Dominican Republic

    Nov 28, 2014, 11:00 AM EST

    Chicago Cubs v Cincinnati Reds Getty Images

    He’s reportedly uninjured, though details are scarce at the moment.

  10. Royals re-sign Jason Frasor for $1.8 million

    Nov 28, 2014, 10:47 AM EST

    Houston Astros v Texas Rangers Getty Images

    Barring some trades he’ll fill a middle relief role for the bullpen-rich Royals in 2015.

  11. Not so fast on the Cardinals’ reported interest in Jon Lester

    Nov 28, 2014, 10:15 AM EST

    Jon Lester AP

    “Their interest in the lefty appears as much opportunistic as enthusiastic.”

  12. A.J. Hinch likes horrible and awful things for Thanksgiving dinner

    Nov 28, 2014, 8:15 AM EST

    Jell-O salad

    Won’t somebody think of A.J. Hinch’s children?

  13. Justin Masterson is all over the AL Central radar

    Nov 27, 2014, 9:20 PM EST

    masterson getty Getty Images

    The AL Central seems to be particularly fond of free agent pitcher Justin Masterson.

  14. Padres drawing a lot of interest in their catchers

    Nov 27, 2014, 8:15 PM EST

    Rene Rivera Rene Rivera

    The Padres have three worthy catchers and all of them are drawing trade interest.

  15. Billy Butler takes out a full-page newspaper ad to thank Royals fans

    Nov 27, 2014, 7:10 PM EST

    New York Yankees v Kansas City Royals Getty Images

    Billy Butler, now with the Athletics, thanked Royals fans for an “amazing ride” in Kansas City.

  16. Brandon Moss, Allen Craig on Marlins’ first base radar

    Nov 27, 2014, 6:05 PM EST

    Brandon Moss AP

    A couple more options have appeared on the Marlins’ radar for an upgrade at first base.

  17. 2015 Free Agent Tracker

    Nov 27, 2014, 4:00 PM EST

    Jon Lester Jon Lester

    Your one-stop shop for all of the offseason signings.

  18. Dave Martinez is moving toward a reunion with Joe Maddon

    Nov 27, 2014, 10:15 AM EST

    Dave Martinez Getty Images

    Martinez was passed over for the manager job in Tampa Bay.

Featured video

Maddon has high hopes for Cubs
Top 10 MLB Player Searches
  1. P. Sandoval (5179)
  2. H. Ramirez (4524)
  3. Y. Tomas (4307)
  4. J. Lester (3218)
  5. C. Headley (2918)
  1. Y. Cespedes (2454)
  2. M. Kemp (2318)
  3. C. Hamels (1812)
  4. A. LaRoche (1809)
  5. M. Scherzer (1777)